Quote:
Originally Posted by Kaijo
No, she didn't. Watch episode 2 again, where Sayaka admits to Madoka she doesn't know what to wish for (the rooftop chat). It's not until further into episode 3 that Sayaka begins to realize she could wish for Kamijou, prompting her to ask the question. Madoka doesn't even figure out a wish until shortly before Mami dies!
So neither one had a wish ready when they met Kyube.
|
there's a difference between not knowing the wish & not having one.
Quote:
|
Yeah, interesting that he keeps singing the same tune of wanting to help humanity, eh?
|
saving humanity? or defeating witches? and the two are not the same. his goal could very well be collecting grief seeds. isnt that speculation?
Quote:
|
Bingo. This is what we've been saying from the beginning. We acknowledge that speculation is speculation. It's fine to have a theory and have some way of thinking; just that we'd like to avoid stating speculation as fact. So, due to overwhelming encouragement, we'll continue pointing out where certain "facts" really are just speculation.
|
facts are facts. their interpretation is speculation
Quote:
|
Yeah, if only Mami hadn't of believed in Kyube, then she wouldn't have died. She should have been more suspicious.
|
she had literally no choice but to either die or agree; not much of a choice
Quote:
|
Or Kyoko! If only she hadn't of believed in Kyube, then she'd be back in her starving to death family, and everything would be peachy.
|
the way it ended... there was at least the option of greater # of family members surviving the other way around. i can hardly call father butchering his family the right way to go.