Quote:
Originally Posted by Reckoner
Wasn't too impressed with her work on Wandering Son (The anime ended up being despite of her work on it but mostly because the manga is just that good, though arguably you could say it's due to the limitations placed by noitamina).
Her work on Gosick was mediocre. Did not like her work on Canvas 2.
One of the main series I was thinking of here though was Darker than Black II, but I brain cramped since that's not an adaption.
Overall she's fairly competent at adaptions, but I am mostly concerned with her original work.
|
Can't comment on Wandering Son since I'm not familiar with the source.
I'll agree on Gosick,there were some adaptation choices that left me puzzled.
However she wasn't Series composer for Canvas 2 (and only wrote 3 out of 24 episodes) and speaking of originals Darker than Black II was still very much Okamura Tensai 's baby and I doubt she had major influence in the overall concept and plot (hell,that'd be a question to ask her at the Q&A),though I can't say I liked her episodes (4-6) much.
Just to be clear,I'm not trying to defend her at all cost here, for example I'm with you on originals such as Ano Hana and the only reason I didn't drop black rock shooter was the action scenes.