View Single Post
Old 2009-01-11, 03:54   Link #3137
shelter
Every word must conjure
 
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: City of No Yesterdays
Send a message via MSN to shelter
Hello, NobodyMan.

Quote:
He refused to though, not in front of Raki, who knew not of his or Priscilla’s true nature. He wasn’t about to let that change if he could help it
At the moment, this is one of the more glaring tense errors I could spot. There are some awkwardly phrased sentences, but since all of them are dialogue, I don't think they do matter too much.

It's interesting that you begin your fic in action, & hold Raki's perspective all the way. Because the entire chapter, despite the near-death duel Raki had, comes across as very light-hearted. Add to that our knowledge of Isley as a master swordsman who's simply playing with the bandits & the atmosphere is more comic than dramatic. Was that your intention?

There is also nothing 'sloppy' about the action sequence. There's a lot of repetition of one particular conjunction - "however" - which shows the turn of our expectations in who would win. Another thing about your fight scene is that written one move at a time: each character's movements are described nicely within a sentence, sometimes a paragraph. There's nothing wrong with that at all. But it gives an impression of a very, very calculated fight. Compared this to MisterJB in his last chapter (each sentence has multiple moves by multiple characters, creating a very confused but detailed brawl), or Yosei (fight scenes are moderated by setting descriptions & dialogue). In building your own style, it's always good see how others describe action-filled sequences & try to fill each scene with the appropriate amount of tension, detail, dialogue & structure.

But good effort. Especially from someone whom everyone has been waiting for to continue after that prologue Update soon!
shelter is offline