Overall, I'd have to argue for A- at least as far as the show itself goes. While I might find that I would question continuing with the show in the middle, lackluster part, the end would bring it all together satisfactorily.
That said, I've generally found that type B shows have far more interesting discussions online. There's a lot of merit in discussing the great parts, and also in picking apart just where the show went wrong (and disagreeing with each other over it, of course).
|