AnimeSuki Forum - View Single Post

Classified Info · 2012-01-21, 23:42

Finished Gosick, and if i have to describe my grade of appreciation in function of the time, here it goes:

I basically loved the whole show as long as it remained light with some investigation and action here and there. I started to dislike it when it began bringing back II World War times, and all those depressing history facts that i find boring. Even tho the ending was happy, i just disliked it: why the fuck Victorique's hair turn gray? Wtf, pooped pants? Also, what is wrong with Avril getting lost in some isle? Nice way to get rid of other characters eh. Also very funny how Vic didn't grow one fucking centimeter after 5 years. Really interesting.

Moreover, i have some questions that remained unsolved:

Spoiler for might spoil ending:

I would have liked not to have watched the last 4 episodes. My opinion just began dropping after 18-19 episodes, to totally go underground with the ending. I was really so happy about this anime the whole time that i was expecting an awesome development near the end, like any other anime (not named school days), and instead i get the feeling of those ancient movies about lovers being separated from war and writing each other, while keeping memory of each other and getting back together in the end. I found that part really depressing. I'll split my vote in two:
Episodes 1-19: 9.5
Episodes 20-24: 4
Thank you really much for suggesting me this title, because i really loved it: the detective element was bearable, even tho i'm not a fan of it, and i liked the romance developing (I have to say that Kujo disturbed me much when he insisted about friendship: fuck it man, it's love). It had a nice plot that didn't evolve the way i thought tho. Also, i like very much the period from 80's to 90's, and i liked the whole atmosphere. Didn't like the war part.

2012-01-21, 23:42	Link #201
Classified Info I miss Haruhi Join Date: Sep 2011	Finished Gosick, and if i have to describe my grade of appreciation in function of the time, here it goes: I basically loved the whole show as long as it remained light with some investigation and action here and there. I started to dislike it when it began bringing back II World War times, and all those depressing history facts that i find boring. Even tho the ending was happy, i just disliked it: why the fuck Victorique's hair turn gray? Wtf, pooped pants? Also, what is wrong with Avril getting lost in some isle? Nice way to get rid of other characters eh. Also very funny how Vic didn't grow one fucking centimeter after 5 years. Really interesting. Moreover, i have some questions that remained unsolved: Spoiler for might spoil ending: 1) Just from where the fuck did the other redheaded guy pop out? I thought there was only Brian Roscoe and then i find out there is another identical individual with the same face and voice: just what the fuck is going on? What are their relation with Cordelia? And the redheaded guy they met before... was it Brian or the other guy? It's just so messed 2) The whole boat story (taking place between episode 2 and 4 if i recall correctly) was so messed up: just who was the culprit? At the beginning i thought it was the old man, since he knew how the boat was, and since he hid all those weapons. Then i discover it was that blonde guy, the hunting dog, to be the one screwing around and in the end... what what what? The girl in red dress is the culprit.... of what? 3) What's up at the very end? I see Vic in some white dress, are they getting married or what? If that's it, then the ending was just rushed: they didn't even confess and after 3 frames they are married. What the fuck, seriously I would have liked not to have watched the last 4 episodes. My opinion just began dropping after 18-19 episodes, to totally go underground with the ending. I was really so happy about this anime the whole time that i was expecting an awesome development near the end, like any other anime (not named school days), and instead i get the feeling of those ancient movies about lovers being separated from war and writing each other, while keeping memory of each other and getting back together in the end. I found that part really depressing. I'll split my vote in two: Episodes 1-19: 9.5 Episodes 20-24: 4 Thank you really much for suggesting me this title, because i really loved it: the detective element was bearable, even tho i'm not a fan of it, and i liked the romance developing (I have to say that Kujo disturbed me much when he insisted about friendship: fuck it man, it's love). It had a nice plot that didn't evolve the way i thought tho. Also, i like very much the period from 80's to 90's, and i liked the whole atmosphere. Didn't like the war part.