Quote:
Originally Posted by UsagiTenpura
So as I see it either...
1- It was really an accident
2- It never happened (ange's world is also a story basically)
3- The culprit is suicidal and died failling to kill everyone else
4- The culprit, just like Battler, escaped the island and is still alive but no one ever found him and found some ways or another to evade the red about being dead.
5- Murders occured but it was an accidental situation that got out of hand and those who survived might not understand much of what happened.
None of these are really satisfying.
|
#5
Quote:
Originally Posted by UsagiTenpura
Suppose we take the arc 7 tea party. Why didn't Rudolf and Kyrie just somehow drag Battler to Kuwadorian and let the island be blown up killing everyone else -why actually doing any of the murders yourself if you know there's a bomb, and on the opposite it sounds really dumb to murder someone on a closed off island if you don't know there's a bomb.
|
Because the bomb only goes off at midnight. Everyone else would wake up in the morning and realize something was wrong when half their relatives were missing. They would become a very risky contingency. For example, Kyrie and Rudolf wouldn't
know this, but if they left Genji alone he would end up checking the gold room, find everyone dead, and flip the bomb switch off. K&R would be fucked.
Quote:
Originally Posted by UsagiTenpura
Outside of Yasu's scenario, it doesn't seem like someone could have planned this massacre, as if anyone did they'd just have blown up the island (and survived most likely)- or else use a better place then a closed off island during a storm to only murder their specific target and not everyone from Kumasawa to Maria.
|
Also, with 1986 technology no one could have planned for the weather more than ~3 days in advance.