[risingstar3110]

Originally Posted by Nightbat®

Can I vote "Nay" on all?

I think the least worse are probably
-Ex-yakuza/ mercenaries/ terrorists
Though I'm not sure you could ever be totally free of these kind of things

-Covered with scars or burnt marks
Beauty is only skin deep

-Your students/ adopted daughter
Students: if they're adults (or both just a few years apart)?Why not?
Adopted daughter: NO, even if she is an adult (apart from a probably big age difference)
you chose her to raise as a daughter, not your future lover
Your feelings be damned, you're a man not an animal (just don't get drunk while in moral emotional turmoil and she decides to dress up for you )


I'll add a more real-world turnoff:
If she's already in a relationship
(Let's not argue the type/quality of relationship she already has, let's just keep it at good/healthy/normal, not abused/battered/neglected kind)

The dilemma has 2 sides, morals and trust
-Am I such a bastard to (try to) destroy a relationship
-If she decides to break it off for me, will I end up being broken off for another guy?

In both cases it's a matter if integrity
In the first just my own
in the second of both of us

My concience wouldn't give me a good night's rest
for making her 'betray' someone (Golden rule kind of principle),
And/or -well aware I'm not the best thing since [insert male sexsymbol of choice]-
allowing doubt and insecurity to her commitment
(Which Ironically in such a case is founded on truth, not paranoia)

Good post

I didn't think about "in the relationship option", because i want the hypothetical girl to be available. And it's totally your choice to push forward or not (rather than in this case, where it's a bit up to her to end her relationship and get to you).

Btw, it seems to those who like NTR, that will turn them on (i think)

Originally Posted by GenjiChan

Going to the selections, I may choose by most that would turn me off.

Hermaphrodite - in real life?! ugh!!!
Your blood sibling - yeah, but look at the bright side... Oniichan onegai...
Your parent's secret illegitimate child - similar to blood siblings
Covered with scars or burnt marks - reminds me of Katawa Shoujo
Ex-yakuza/ mercenaries/ terrorists - its her clan that would turn me off
Multi-personalities - hope she doesn't have that yandere thing
Your best friends/ brothers' teen daughters - will make me a pervert
Your students/ adopted daughter - definitely turns me on.
Your childhood mother-figure - Undecided, if she's damn hot.

I did try to make a variety of everything. Many are obvious but these were in because:

• Your parent's secret illegitimate child: similar to your sibling, but a) you have no history connection and b) many will despise her especially if she indirectly put your family in turmoil
• Covered with scars or burnt marks: frankly I thought this will be a more popular option. Because it will take a lot of will to keep yourself turning on. But people here seems to be more dignified (or hypocrite ) than i expected
• Best friends/ brothers' teen daughters: there is a sense of betrayals toward your best mate/ brother in this case. Then she's under 18 as well, making it's even more vulnerable case of betraying (rather than 2 mature adults decide on relationships)
• Student/ adopted daughter: basically someone you invest a lots of emotions on, then things just start getting hot or heavy. Many finds the students' is a much easier option. But there are those like in "Kodomo no jikan" where the protagonist keeping up with his students since she was 9, probably until 15 at least.
• Childhood mother-figure: i guess this will be more popular choice for East Asia because their stronger family hierarchy. Take lots of will to date someone at least a decade older, whom you admired since childhood (while calling her oba-san or sensei throughly)