AnimeSuki Forum - View Single Post - [Game] Umineko - Spoilers, Theories, Interpretations

I had a long flight home and was trying to get the overall concept of Umineko and what is the main purpose of Beatrice and Battler and the whole story, not messing with the details too much.
So... yeah, this is the effect.
I wonder if it may be true (you just can't prove much of it, but you also can't find the way to just deny it - devil's proof

)

Spoiler for what is Umineko about - all episodes:

2009-10-09, 23:35	Link #2386
Umineko_neko Junior Member Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: inside my head	I had a long flight home and was trying to get the overall concept of Umineko and what is the main purpose of Beatrice and Battler and the whole story, not messing with the details too much. So... yeah, this is the effect. I wonder if it may be true (you just can't prove much of it, but you also can't find the way to just deny it - devil's proof ) Spoiler for what is Umineko about - all episodes: 1. We know that Beatrice is more like a concept (a title which can be inherited) and that Kinzo was obsessed with Beatrice. 2. We know that "Beatrice" lend the gold to Kinzo. So my theory is: 1. There are at least three different Beatrice: the one who lend the gold, the one who was living on Rokkenjima and present one (who I think is Jessie or Shannon) 2. Beato (Jessie or Shannon) is not murdering people, the murderer is someone from the family. 3. We have two points of view - Battler sin was leaving the family - that is how Beato sees it, but it was his return that triggered the (potencial) murders, for which Beato resents him (he forced one or more of her family to become potencial future murderer/s). Personal reasons for resentment can also be applied 4. The title of the head of Ushiromiya family doesn't equal the gold because the gold was borrowed. Which means that Battler can be a descendant from the first Beatrice and is legally entitled to the gold. That's why Rudolf was somehow pressed not to marry Kyrie but someone else. Together with the Ushiromiya name (which Battler got back on his return) and some proof that the gold is legally his - he skips the inheritance line and is the main target. However as long as he is oblivious to the fact, he doesn't need to be necessarily removed immediately. 5. Beato (J. or S.) came to know that some person/people from her "family" want to murder him and is trying to resolve the matter differently by letting him discover it all by himself. 6. She may be involved with other people faking deaths and all those horrors to confuse the real murderers or just to made him think. 7. Why she can't just tell him... I don't know... I can think of a few reasons but they are just as difficult to prove as anything else here.