View Single Post
Old 2012-08-16, 08:55   Link #30032
jjblue1
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2011
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kealym View Post
The same motive as for murdering Natsuhi, George, and Kumasawa.
The question was 'what's the motive?' not 'who shared the same motive for being murdered?'

Also Ryukishi said that in George's case it was love suicide. I seriously doubt the same can be applied to Gohda.
And Yasu had a motive to kill Natsuhi, which was that Natushi tried to kill her first.... which Gohda didn't.

Kumasawa (Genji and Najo) can claim they've saved Yasu but actually they also covered up for Natushi and condemned Yasu to be a servant for the person who tried to murder her when she actually could have been the heir to the house.
And again, Gohda never did anything as such.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kealym View Post
Well yeah, it's just that someone listed "Missing" in the TIPS usually just means "left to blow up", so why would it be different in this one case?
Yasu's still alive and there's a lot of time before the bomb will explode while in all the other episodes she's already dead or the bomb is about to explode so she might feel like finishing the work instead than just helping Jessica to hide.

Eva is also still alive and has just killed Battler. Either she did it because she wanted to murder everyone, so why should she spare Jessica and Nanjo (she's not aware he's already dead) or because she believed him to be the mastermind.

In that case she wouldn't think to abandon Jessica and Nanjo but to save them. However once she goes back and find Nanjo dead she can only assume Jessica killed him as everyone else is dead and Battler never had the time to murder Nanjo as he was with her. Ergo Jessica is the mastermind, she would think she was mistaken into thinking it was Battler and Jessica would end up meeting the same fate as Battler.

And why can't be different? After all Krauss too was declared missing in Ep 5 but then it turned out he'd been killed during it.

Last edited by jjblue1; 2012-08-16 at 09:06.
jjblue1 is offline   Reply With Quote