View Single Post
Old 2007-03-20, 17:26   Link #46
Raniie
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Just keeping it simple and short.

Here's what I thought without getting into too much details about the whole series.

Animation: 9
It's still not perfect with some of the inconsistancy in animation to details.

Art: 8
It's the standard Bishōjo Art Style with slightly more refined details, it's far from the perfect and very detailed art concept of the original material.

Story: 8
The story isn't very innovating or outstanding, but the experience through it all, the storytelling was enjoyable, even with a few occasional abrupt pacing. It still manage to fill in the blanks while leaving plenty of room for after thoughts.

Voice Performance: 10
Absolutely perfect, until proven otherwise. This is the best it'll get. Even with a perfect score in this area, it doesn't necessarily mean everyone will fall in love with it, but rather, it means the Seiiyuu(s) are seriously putting effort into portraying the character's emotions, quirks, and personality to their fullest.

Sound/Music: 8
A few occasional abruptness in some of the scenes lowered the score. The sound / music isn't anything all too soundbreaking that would even be consider reaching a 10 rating anyway.

Characters: 9
You'll either hate or love them and continue to hate or love them, or grow to have sympathy for previously hating them. That's a definite sign of character progression or developement.

Value & Enjoyment: 9
Second viewing is a must for this series. As there are many things you can very easily overlook. There are plenty of easter eggs left behind by KyoAni, which is a nice touch and increasing the value of the series.


Overall Rating: 8.7
In this case, a 9 rounded up.


Edit for Vexx's comment below: Yes, that was back then, this is now. You can't call this story an innovation anymore. :P

Last edited by Raniie; 2007-03-22 at 16:39.
Raniie is offline   Reply With Quote