I like the Oneshot better, it does have better moments and a better feel to the story.
The part with her asking for Zenkichi to stay be her side is very sweet.
Zenkichi is a pretty cool male lead, he ain't like the usual useless morons around.
Altho his jacket/jersey escapade in ch 2 is lol
Just hoping the realtionship between Medaka and Zenkichi actually moves along and not dragged out for like forever.
Well Medaka is rather jealous in ch 3 so I guess it might actaully move along with the story in this case.