View Single Post
Old 2009-12-05, 09:26   Link #3878
Geekodot
Senior Member
 
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Quote:
Originally Posted by chounokoe View Post
Yes there is still the fact of Battler being alone, yet being killed...which is the big paradoxon which is leading us to the whole discussion.
But if it had to be a bomb it had to be prepared for a certain radius and a certain time to explode. Yet if the culprit was able to somehow avoid being present and yet being able to kill Nanjo in Episode 3 or Natsuhi in Episode 1, why would he bring him/herself in immediate danger of being killed in 'the explosion'? The problem here is that there would be no logic for that action and therefore it seems pretty much wrong compared to the otherwise very orchestrated crimes.

Arson may be the only 'accident' that would prove itself not totally counterproductive or too accidental to be true.
There is no reason for the one who kills Natsuhi and Nanjo to be the same person who planted the bomb. The bomber might already be dead, you know... If you go with this theory, you should look for someone who never makes it to the end to be the bomber.

There is a very very high chance that there are more than one murderer and different motives going around. If Kanon was the murderer in Episode 1 and killed Natsuhi, then he wouldn't know about the bomb if it was prepared by Krauss (just an example)... and the bomber himself wouldn't be saved because he was killed in the first twilight.
Geekodot is offline   Reply With Quote