[AC-Phoenix]

Originally Posted by Voxxen

Thanks for clearing that up, something that gets me though...

Mei States that the "Another" is at the hotel correct? (Episode 10)
That rules out the school staff and his aunt...
I was really in favor of the aunt theory, guess we read too into it and it would make the preview of characters in the intro useless...

Btw, I admire your conviction towards KNOX with so many people throwing you down, myself included. xD

Its not really conviction;
As you may have seen I have often referred to Miss Marple books during my different attemps to analyze the evidence (before and after I got to know the solution). You now have to know that A. Christie and R.Knox were both in the same club, so it was easy to get that you can probably solve her novels using Knox rules. So I'm actually just used to apply them.
I can do a detailed analysis with all the hints given and where later.

As to the other part:
(no actual spoiler, just something to think about)

Spoiler for Theory about Mei's eye:

I leave it to you whether i'm just teasing people now and trying to lead them away from the goal a bit:
But don't you think that it is strange that a person can see using an occular prothesis? Especially since visual protehsis do in fact exist and even existed 1998, but still need a good pat of the eyeball to be intact. - to asnswer a possible queestion now: Evidence points to her prothesis is meant to be there for aesthetics.

Does this mean anything or am I just pretending that it does?Is this part of the pehnomenon a deus ex Machima, a Lie Misaki told us? A hallucination or optical deception? Who knows :P.
I'm thrilled to see whether they have the same Another in the Anime as it is in the other works thouggh, because at least one death got already swapped between victims.