Recommendations so far:
Of those shows, I'd second
Baccano!, Claymore, Cross Game, Madoka, Noein, Planetes, RahXephon, School Rumble, Seirei no Moribito, The Melacholy of Suzumiya Haruhi, and
Usagi Drop.
I'll add
Hikaru no Go,
Natsume Yuujinchou,
Twelve Kingdoms, and
Welcome to the NHK! to the list.
I'll try to update these counts from time to time. If you would like to vote for any of these shows, or make new nominations, just wrap the show titles inside bold tags ([b][/b]), so I can find the titles easily. If you want to wrap the title with another code as well, like I'd did with the URL links above, please bold the title first, then wrap the bold content in the URL or other tag. Please avoid using bolds for emphasis; use italics instead. If you'd simply like to post a list of votes, please wrap your posting in [tldr][/tldr] tags to help keep the size of this thread under control.