Quote:
Originally Posted by Smeckledorf
Yet again, there can be co-culprits and it is not an established fact that there is more than one murderer. So, yea I would say you are hellbent on pushing your theories.
|
And what is a co culprit exactly? Another person who murders? Or someone who gives a key and ends up being a murderer by helping them? Either way your a murder. Again if you think one person did everything in this story there is no helping you.
Quote:
|
So, if I am to understand your last point correctly, you believe that Umineko no Naku Koro Ni is written based on what you think? That is a rhetorical question, save face and don't even answer it.
|
No what I am saying is that
fan involvement affects the
way the story is written in one way or another. These games are based on speculation by the reader. If nobody made a Natsuhi culprit theory we wouldn't have Bernkastel suggesting Natsuhi had sex with Kinzo or Erika cornering her. We also wouldn't have theories about fake deaths or aspects of a characters personality being confirmed if there was no fan speculation. It's not about what I think it's about what the fans think. Speculation by the readers and how that affects the story is the basis for both of his games.