Quote:
Originally Posted by Keroko
Query: Is Nanoha a show meant to display a realistic military in a realistic military setting?
Observation: Nanoha is a magical girl show that has a bit of military sprinkled in. The show itself is meant to represent heroines battling the wicked forces and helping the weak through the power of friendship and beams of pink death.
Analysis: Being that is the case, the scenario writers (whom themselves aren't exactly an army in numbers) will do research into the military as far as is considered important. Ranks, methods of referral and some military jargon will be found and utilized. Research into proper military tactics won't yield enough knowledge to accurately write battle tactics unless vast amounts of research is made. This is not even counting the research needed for animators to display such a setting.
Secondary query: What is the target audience of Nanoha? Are military buffs among them?
Observation: The target audience of Nanoha are fans of the magical girl and action genre.
Conclusion: Since the show was never meant to display a realistically accurate military setting, attempting to do a vast amount of research into correct military tactics is a waste of time and budget, and is better spend elsewhere.
|
REBUTTLE: Then the TSAB will continue to be incompetent.