Quote:
Originally Posted by Arkeus
Sure, let's compare selling TV and forcing girls to fight a war for the rest of their lives with nor respite no retirement.
The fact is, Kyuubey make sure to tempt the girls again and again, and follow them to check if they weaken. He *also* set things up where they'd be weak.
For example, Kyubey can find MG and potential MG, so he knew where kyoko was. He knew what was coming. That is was 'inevitable' is bulshit, preparing sayaka for it would mean she wouldn't have freaked out about it, and might have dealt with it in a less frantic manner.
Also, madoka wouldn't have been there to make a wish.
|
Why wouldn't have Madoka have been there? You heard it yourself; Madoka wanted to come because she was worried about Sayaka. And Sayaka wanted Madoka to come because having her there would have given her reassurance.
And no analogy is perfect, but it was meant to illustrate that there was no manipulation was going on. If you want to believe he's evil, sure, fine, go for it. But there has been no evidence of it thus far. As I said, the worst you can say is that he takes advantage of situations to offer once again to Madoka a contract of being a magical girl.
And as Fukarming and I mentioned, if you find Kyube evil, then you have to find Luna, Yuuno, Keroberos, Mepple/Mipple, and many other magical animals evil as well. In fact, Kyube is
less evil then them, because they practically forced their girls into doing it. Madoka is the first one to just be given the freedom to choose, and to sometimes be told to stay out of it.