Okay, let me try to put this into perspective:
You're seriously equating the premeditated actions of a highly intelligent alien being who doesn't give a crap about humanity even at large (as shown in the last timeline Homura went through) to an impulsive choice made by a young girl who just found out her entire existence was a lie and only wanted to protect her very human friends.
The irony of your argument is you're saying Mami would have been a better character if she took the Kyubey approach and remained awkwardly emotionless after seeing Sayaka turn into a Witch.
|