Thread: Review Forum
View Single Post
Old 2004-06-07, 15:53   Link #9
dragonz20
Cantonese Dimples
 
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: North Jersey (near NY city)
Age: 46
Send a message via AIM to dragonz20
Quote:
Originally Posted by boneyjellyfish
I'm not talking about anime discussion, I'm talking about having people criticizing the reviews and general discussion about the reviews. Constructive criticism and pointing out things that the person writing the review got wrong should be allowed.
which could easily lead to flaming if done improperly... some people take constructive criticism well but others do not. If there was some way of screening each review/post before they are officially posted then this might work. If not, then any banana brain (the average Naruto fan for example) won't hesitate in starting up a flame war to defend their favorite anime...

but this type of screening would mean appointing one or a few people to read and approve reviews...

we could also provide some basic guidelines for reviews (no flaming of other reviewers, meaningful and constructive postings, etc.. ) I dunno... but it sounds pretty cool...
dragonz20 is offline   Reply With Quote