2008-02-25, 06:14 | Link #1921 | |
Banned
|
Quote:
Last edited by Amirali; 2008-02-25 at 06:45. Reason: Speak for myself alone |
|
2008-02-25, 06:22 | Link #1922 |
Chicken or Beef?
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Seattle
Age: 42
|
Despite how sad you're trying to make Rukia's childhood sound, a slum child is the norm in Soul Society, and in fact she was quite happy, until she was adopted into the Kuchiki family, thats when she started feeling "lonely" as she felt out of place. And the fact that Renji, the only person she cared about at the time, was the one who pushed her to accept the adoption.
Whether you like it or not, everything goes back to Kaein when it comes to Rukia, its always been about Kaein. Its only until recently that she finally resolved her internal conflict dealing with Kaein, even still we're not sure as to whether or not its completely done with as the manga hasn't gotten past her laying in a pool of her own blood. Ichigo is not that private, he's not mister mystery here. If he feels something he expresses it passionately. Everything Ichigo says and do is with passion, thats not the attribute of someone who is "private". Ichigo didn't introduce her to anyone, she forced herself into his world, everything was merely circumstantial. Orihime, became friends with her on her own, Ichigo wasn't involved, Ishida hates shinigami, he targetted her on his own, Chad, only cause he's Ichigo's friend who got powers all of a sudden. Everything involving Rukia's relationships with the people around her are circumstantial, ichigo didn't go around trying to be mr. nice guy making friends for her. You're making a mountain out of a mole hill. |
2008-02-25, 06:48 | Link #1923 | |
Banned
|
Quote:
No, I don't seriously think Rukia should be sending Aizen thank you notes.......just that if one starts attributing everything on basis of circumstance, those are the kind of weird conclusions you'll get. |
|
2008-02-25, 07:10 | Link #1925 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Yes, who wouldn't be happy to watch her friends die off? It may have been the norm but it doesn't make things pleasant. She didn't have a lovely time at the academy either, her and Renji were in separate classes and while his open personality made it easy for him to make friends, Rukia? Not so much.
You're not looking at the full picture, Kaien is only a part of it. Her inferiority complex didn't start with him, it began before that, probably when she was a student at the academy and Renji was placed in the advanced class while she struggled with swordsmanship. It built up again when she was adopted by Byakuya, pushed forward to graduate the academy (when she was clearly not read), did not seat in her division and made her feel unworthy of her adoptive family and name. That Byakuya was emotionally distant and uncommunicative did not help and then helped further perpetuate this idea that she was inferior and not worth very much. Indeed it's Kaien who tries to help Rukia find her worth again by treating her like a valuable division member and helping her train, it's just that when she's forced to kill him her self-worth totally goes down the drain and it's not until Ichigo saves her that she's forced to re-evaluate herself again. Anyway, that meanders from my point, which is that seeing as the roots for her inferiority and low self-worth began prior to her meeting with Kaien, clearly it has not always been about him. Also, Ichigo not private? Sure he's abrasive, impulsive and passionate, but so what? So is Kenpachi, but it doesn't mean he's good at expressing his feelings and troubles. How many times have we seen Ichigo's back when he's trying to hide his emotions? God, Kubo does it all the time! Ichigo doesn't go around talking to people about what's on his mind and what's bothering him, people have to pry a bit in order for him to open up. We saw this with Rukia in regards to his mother in the first Memories in the Rain arc and again post-Soul Society when he was dejected after not being able to protect Chad and Orihime and wouldn't talk to anyone, walked around like an emopot. Emotions like anger and a fighting spirit flare easily from him, but other than that he's socially handicapped. I'm not saying Ichigo directly helped Rukia establish her friendships, though he certainly helped Renji and Byakuya wake the hell up, but because of him her world opened up exponentially, just as Rukia gave Ichigo the means to protect and as a result, opened his world as well. The characters themselves recognize how much they've changed each other's lives, I'm just explaining how and in what ways. |
2008-02-25, 07:42 | Link #1926 |
Chicken or Beef?
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Seattle
Age: 42
|
Rukia's inferority complex was gone a long time ago, she surely didn't have it from episode one. Only when she was imprisoned awaiting trial and execution was when she started reflecting back on the past, her life with Kaein and then how its her fault that Ichigo is "dead", which is kinda stupid because if she didn't give him the powers, he would've been dead a lot sooner... so dead now? or dead later? oh well, lets not think on that... since it doesn't make much sense from a logical stand-point. She fell into a funk, as people usually do when facing a crisis. The rescue broke her from that funk, and brought her back to normal.
As seen in the current arc, Rukia was still brooding over Kaein, the only thing she can never forget, as he was the most important person in her life. If Kaein miraculously came back to life, she'll probably give him a BJ if he asked her to. The way I see it, is that to Rukia, Kaein > Ichigo, any day of the week. Perhaps its been too long since I've watched the earlier episodes of Bleach, but I don't recall her friends "dying", as far as I know you can't die as a spirit unless something kills you. Rukia and Renji were having a ball running around being trouble makers in the neighborhood, IIRC she wanted to go back to those days with Renji, when Rukia was started to feel out of place in the academy. |
2008-02-25, 07:50 | Link #1927 | ||
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Kneeling in front of my ICHIGO SHRINE.
|
Quote:
You are just saying random stuff...to try and prove your case...and none of it's true. @KYU...Matsu said they were both important yes...but she also said it fine that Orihime couldn't be to Ichigo what Rukia is ..so basically she was saying Quote:
|
||
2008-02-25, 08:12 | Link #1929 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Kneeling in front of my ICHIGO SHRINE.
|
For the last time...I have Ichigo glasses on and my fanaticism is about him. How many times must I say that.?!
Secondly...I only use FACTS. You just make up random things and swear it's truth...And the only time you answer me...Is when you think you can...Most time you can't and use my long posts as an excuse. (Sinta's is just as long yet you answer his)Except you were wrong those times too...So I don't know why you bothered You can like Orihime...and Ichigo as a couple But don't just make shit up...or twist them to give Orihime a better case You keep saying I am interpreting it to my own benift by like Sinta said "Just saying I am wrong without showing proof to indicate that I am wrong....Just makes you look silly" His words not mine...but they apply to you as well. |
2008-02-25, 08:25 | Link #1930 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Gone a long time ago? Since when? Rukia's all about false bravado and putting on faces of confidence and arrogance, especially when it comes to Ichigo. Our initial impression of her certainly isn't one of someone who is insecure in her self-worth, but we're not supposed to find out these things right away; moreover as a shinigami she shouldn't be showing such weakness anyway, but it doesn't mean it's not there.
She has no need to feel inferior and worthless when she meets Ichigo, he's a stupid human, she's a shinigami, but when she's taken back to Soul Society we see a completely different side of Rukia, one that doesn't value herself and thinks of herself as weak and unworthy of saving. That vulnerability is rooted in her past experiences, it doesn't just go away, it can certainly be pushed aside, especially should the situation require her to stand strong, as she did to the best of her ability in the living world, but it's always been there. We saw traces of it in the Memories in the Rain arc, she's not strong and abrasive all the time, she can be weak and vulnerable as well, and I think Kaien just embodies so much of what negative feelings Rukia has towards herself. Thankfully, she's been trying to move on from her guilt over Kaien's death, and her relationship with Byakuya, which long caused her to feel unworthy and weak has improved exponentially. She even learns that she didn't get seated as an officer because Byakuya asked that she not be placed in order to protect her, not that she lacked the ability, so any feelings of inadequacy that she felt from not being able to get a seat can be quashed. With that, one should recognize that these burdensome feelings didn't just go away, that they take time and effort to heal. Honestly I love Rukia and Kaien's relationship but I think Ichigo's relationship with Rukia is much stronger due to the fact it's development, understanding and supportiveness is more mutual and equal. I think both relationships are lovely though and they both have been important to the shaping of her character. I don't recall how her friends died, I only remember them stating that the 78th District was a particularly hard place to survive, especially for a bunch of kids, and then recall the image of Renji and Rukia standing infront of their graves deciding to go enter the shinigami academy. |
2008-02-25, 10:17 | Link #1931 | ||
The Ironman
Join Date: Sep 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||
2008-02-25, 11:02 | Link #1932 | |||
Junior Member
Join Date: Feb 2008
|
Quote:
Quote:
In this instance, though, Ichigo knows his strengths and his weaknesses and he knows how strong his opponents are. It hasn't been that long since his spectacular defeat against Grimmjow and it is a defeat for him, considering what he said in response to Renji pointing out his "win". He knows 11 seconds aren't enough to storm HM but he does so anyway. Grimmjow is only the 6th from the top and Ichigo was already owned that badly. What he needed at that time was to master his untapped Hollow-side but he leaves that behind. He goes to save Orihime from what he deems is her being in danger, despite not really knowing the situation and despite Aizen, Ulquiorra and whoever else planning to make her look like a traitor. Considering he's done all these before, considering he should know the do's and don't's already, Ichigo is acting pretty darn reckless. And since he's been shown to be quite pragmatic when it counts, this is a very noticeable move for him. I see. Thank you for your time, then. When you have the time, please elaborate as you wish. I'm interested in knowing how you came up with your conclusion. Quote:
If you don't mind my asking, may I ask up to what point of the series you are? I'm interested in knowing how you came to the thought that Orihime's affections were some sort of schoolgirl crush only. |
|||
2008-02-25, 11:03 | Link #1933 | ||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
|
Quote:
No she didn't. that was one of the worst translated chapters. the most correct translation was matsu said Ichigo is a child he won't get anywhere with out the help of both Rukia and orihime and she was impressed that Orihime was dealing with her envy instead of running from it. there was little to no hint of relationship importance at all other then Orihime was jealous http://bleachasylum.com/showpost.php...9&postcount=40 http://bleachasylum.com/showpost.php...0&postcount=20 Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||||
2008-02-25, 13:12 | Link #1935 | |||||||||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2006
|
Happy Monday everyone,
Lucifer I’m not going to answer everything in your post as I don’t think most of it was relevant to our original topic. You also assume I say alot of things when i don't. I will take it slow however so I don’t miss anything. Quote:
Quote:
But on the subject of love, I push my definition on no one, I can’t force anyone to believe the way I do. I make my arguments just like anyone else. People are welcome to believe what they may. But, I do believe they are in love, and would argue such (I HAVE NOT DONE SO WITH YOU YET) but, if you believe otherwise your post makes it difficult for you to argue that way as you seem unwilling to define your concept of love and defend it. Is inoue as a possibility for Ichigo the only position you have? How do you know if she's a possibility you aren't willing to define love? How do you know if inoue really even loves ichigo if you aren't willing to define it? Does just saying you are in love make you in love? You can't go further without some interpretation and application. This post adds nothing to discussion, saying people can’t apply their understanding to a given situation completely displaces our discussion and would kill off the thread. Its also not true. I’m really not sure why you wrote this in the first place. I don’t know if you are trying to be poetic but stop accusing people of things and lets get down to the debate. If you think Inoue and ichigo are the most likely (that is the thing we are debating, now at least) then, give me an analysis saying such. If not, then i don't know that we have much more to talk about as I don't know where our conversation could go. Quote:
Opinions do matter in love, especially Kubo’s opinion, as he’s the one writing. I think the opinion I’ve developed towards Bleach, and ichigo and rukia interactions is what he’s trying to tell me and that is, that Ichigo and Rukia are in fact in love and will eventually get together. Maybe I’m wrong and maybe I’m right, but as long as the story remains unfinished we won’t know. Maybe in the next chapter ichigo, inoue or rukia will do something to make me feel different but know this. Bleach isn’t a abstract, it’s a story, a story that is trying lead us on an adventure into a different world. People do, say and act for a reason. I make arguments based on that. What are you doing? On the issue of equality, where does your real question lie? You asked if its necessary. Do you mean is it necessary that Ichigo and inoue be equal in their relationship? (the answer would be no, there are plenty of relationship’s that are not.) Or are asking whether Inoue and Rukia need to be equal in the terms of relationship potential or probability? The answer is yes as this is the simple question people ask. Who is more likely given their interactions currently shown? But back up, I think we are getting bogged down in the abstract and its distracting us from the real issues. So lets simplify, I ask this question. If Ichigo and Rukia are so important to each why would he fall in love with inoue? Don’t misunderstand, we aren't saying it’s a given, people however see their depth and development ask why this wouldn’t lead to love. it seems the most likely conclusion. Take the discussion in another direction. Why would feelings between inoue and ichigo develop when they don’t have a very close relationship? Where would his interest come from when he has thus far shown none? There are the questions that many people ask and none of your arguments address. Quote:
This thing called “love” is suppose to coming from a single individual correct? So if you want to ask the question who is the most likely that Ichigo love’s (as of right) I would say Rukia, they have the history, the foundation and many other things in their favor. (I won’t list them) Now inoue, if you believe that inoue is the most likely then make argument for an eventual romantic pairing, but this post doesn’t do anything for you. People in this thread are discussing the possibilities. I rule out nothing as a possibility but a relationship between two people with no recognizable reason as to why they entered into that relationship is bad story telling and totally contrary to life. Since when do people fall in love for no reason? You say that Inoue doesn’t have to do anything? If she doesn’t have to do anything then how do you justify a relationship with Ichigo? That just doesn’t make any sense. The manga chapters represent history, history of the bleach story. There is nothing in that history to show me that inoue could be loved by ichigo. There is also nothing in the back story proceeding bleach to show me that they have an unseen connection to fall back. Kubo is not going to get them together without explaining to us. So how will he justify it? If you disagree, show me. That’s why were here are we not? How would basing a potential relationship on a bond undermine the manga? Shouldn't relationships be based on bonds and the feelings we develop from those bonds? If they aren’t, what are relationships based on? Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
What are all these other actions that says that ichigo believes that inoue didn’t go on her own? He expressed outrage and he’s implusive that doesn’t mean he doesn’t harbor doubt. I also have never said ignore words you silly man, when have I said that? I said that words, actions and circumstances have to taken into account, but that action speaks louder then words. Ichigo came to inoue because he believes she is innocence but it doesn't mean he doesn't have doubts. Quote:
Quote:
Of course circumstances are important, but asking what someone could have said, what another person could have answered, then making arguments based on that is not important or relevant to the conversation. It is pure speculation. It just not information that we have or could can really guess at. I think its too far removed to take the time to entertain arguments based on them. That’s what my original argument was referring to. I thought that was very clear. Did you actual read the whole post? This is what i said. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
EDIT; Nakama (仲間 or なかまin hirgana) means companion, partner, or associate and also the plural of these, so group or circle of friends. It's nothing more (or less) than that. I think you need to rethink your point, instead of trying to reinvent the meaning of words. Again, you quote me but you don’t actual read my posts it seems. This is what I actually said was it not? Quote:
Ichigo’s circumstances when leaving in both arcs actually pretty similar, Ichigo knew he wasn’t as strong in both cases, he had just gotten owed by Byukuya in one case and Grimm in the other. He planned to go by himself both times and was reluctant to let his friends come with him both times. It sounds like you need to re-read the beginning of the SS arc if you didn’t know that. He didn’t know Inoue, Chad and Ishida were planning to come. There are some differences however, mind you ichigo wanted to SS before he was even healed. The only reason that he couldn’t is Urahara, you must have forgot that conversation. Furthermore compare his reactions. He didn’t express the despair at inoue’s departure like he did with Rukia. Nor did think anxiously about her. I’m sorry if you are trying to argue that Ichigo was more passionate about Inoue then Rukia you are going to have to do better then that. Quote:
Last edited by Sinta; 2008-02-25 at 16:07. |
|||||||||||||||
2008-02-25, 17:41 | Link #1936 | |||||||||
Oxymoron
Join Date: Feb 2008
|
Please calm down. Take a deep breath, again, and again, until you are rested.
You spent a lot of spaces denying what you did, while nobody is accusing you of anything at all. This is how it is pointless to, well, direct you elsewhere because you get off-topic, paranoid, then accuse people of things which you commit yourself. Now, here's for civilization. Quote:
assuming one character has equal status with another character when there is nothing to base it on seems silly to me. Yes, Sinta, your sentence here is an implication that to equal status is important, and yes, to address status is to address worth. I'm sorry that my post were made in a way that you missed my point; but i was indeed addressing you're about making equality in status. I said that it wasn't an important criteria. Quote:
Why should you define what is love in the first place? You were purposely ignoring the arguments on how some are not in the belief that the relationship of Ichigo and Rukia meant that they are in love - and I humbly try to tell you that we are not in the same perimeter simply because we are not conforming to what you defined as love, namely IchiRuki. Now, even the scientist who are constantly studying human are not so sure on how two people could fall in love, why should be undermine them and say that we know what love is. I wouldn't be as arrogant as to define what love is - it is definitely not our job. However, many people will agree that love in Bleach definitely not defined as IchiRuki. Quote:
Quote:
Thanks for realizing that Ichigo and Orihime needed not to be equal; but your credibility spoke for itself in the second part. After a rational first part, you said that close relationship in Ichigo-Rukia relationship meant that they will likely fall in love. Ever heard of love at first sight? My point is that bonds and love may be related, but not necessarily interlinked. You mention that Ichigo and Rukia have a great bond, true. However, what is the basis to mention that Ichigo and Orihime do not share a great bond too? You are again, doing what you denied, measuring up every relationship to Ichigo-Rukia bond. Thus, why would feelings not surface even if they do not share the same bond as Ichigo and Rukia. There are many ways in which you probably had insulted Kubo-sensei's credibility just by saying that IchiRuki meant love, and this is one instance. There are many types of relationship, and to say that Kubo-sensei is completely incapable of exploring someway other than IchiRuki is not a good thing to say about his calibre. Likewise, let me say that close bonds between two person (regardless of gender) is not an indication of instant romance defined; to which the same way that apparent unfamiliarity does not spell and definite impossibility of romance. See why you impose your own definition of love again and again? To which asked on how could Ichigo shown interest in Orihime when he had thus far shown none, I believe that many could answer you better; or you may just read the HM arc again. I am just a non-believer in IchiRuki ever happening, but that doesn't mean I'm talking on IchiHime happening - again, you forget that not everybody thinks that romance will prevail at all. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Ooh, there wasn't romance in SS arc, and it didn't end in "I love you Rukia" and so by your logic, it never will happen. Quote:
Take a look at these: http://www.onemanga.com/Bleach/238/19/ Preferably the entire chapter. Then you tell us that he wasn't anxious. The accusations of "not reading the manga" seemed to go back to you. Quote:
|
|||||||||
2008-02-25, 18:42 | Link #1937 |
Junior Member
Join Date: Feb 2008
|
Whoa people do post a lot on this thread... I barely even left for more than a few hours... But yeah, I am only as far as soul society, Hayashi, but sometimes when you make predictions for future developments the begginning is the most important because no matter what happens Bleach will eventually have to come full circle. It is the fundamental basis upon which every single story is told and Bleach began with Ichigo meeting Rukia and I still see that right now with Ichigo risking his life to save Rukia whereas Orihime is just hanging around. But if I am missing something of the grander picture please enlighten me in a positive manner, there is no need to bash a novice.
|
2008-02-25, 21:27 | Link #1938 | |
Chicken or Beef?
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Seattle
Age: 42
|
Quote:
Inoue became suspect of betraying Soul Society but that enraged Ichigo, Ichigo decides to go against orders and all better judgement that he was no where near ready to face the dangers that lies ahead in HM. to save Inoue alone. Later Ichigo found out that Rukia has been "killed" he decided to go save her, ignoring the enemy, but the enemy provoked him by saying he was the reason Inoue came to HM, which angered Ichigo in an instant, ignoring Rukia's flight, for Inoue. I'll stop there since this is where the anime stops. I wont go further into the manga. |
|
2008-02-25, 22:00 | Link #1939 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
|
Quote:
http://www.onemanga.com/Bleach/270/11/ http://www.onemanga.com/Bleach/270/12/ Ulquiorra asked Ichigo why Ichigo wasn't trying to kill Ulquiorra after Ulquiorra had goaded him with Rukia's death, (not Chad's death). Ichigo answered that because he (Ulquiorra) had not harmed his (Ichigo) nakama. Question:: In this case, would it not be a clear indication from Ichigo that Rukia is grouped together with his nakama? In another word, has Ichigo said that Rukia was his nakama here? Unless you are going to tell me that Rukia was not in his mind, hence he didn't mean as in Rukia his nakama.....but others minus Rukia as his nakama? Bleach Heat The Soul 5 is a computer game; latest Bleach game that revolved around during the time Orihime is kidnapped and imprisoned in Huenco Mundo. This is the official character profile for Kurosaki Ichigo in it's website(Bleach Heat The Soul 5) Spoiler for screen cap:
There, Orihime is described no longer as Ichigo's classmate, or Ichigo's nakama. She's called as Ichigo's shinyuu 親友. If you were to look carefully the word 親友 (shinyuu) were next to Inoue Orihime's name 井上織姫,as in 親友井上織姫 (second line sentence). The meaning of shinyuu is down below..... http://spencer.blackmarket.net/dic_w...l.asp?id=99176 it means "close friend, bosom (old, intimate) friend, buddy, crony, chum".....better than the word 'nakama' Quoted from this website>> http://www.krunk4ever.com/blog/2006/...asoline-prices Quote:
a) These people, who developed the games just as the animation is being told by Kubo Tite to write it as such, b) These people read different version of Bleach in compared to you guys? c) Or maybe.....there's something there that they(Ichigo and Orihime) didn't show, but it's there, Ichigo doesn't show it, but the animators, who equally read the same ones know that it is there; Ichigo --->Orihime? Quote:
Every positive / negative descriptions about certain Bleach female character, (or male character in my case) in compared to the others.....fans' strongly biased opinions regardless how systematic and eloquently you say in that long, long essay.......are just craps Do you personally think that Kubo Tite accentuate certain character's behaviours(weak / strong points) is going to be the reasons why Kubo Tite is heading towards certain pairing? Ichigo isn't the prize male bull that 'every Bleach female girls needs to compete in every aspect' in order to win his love. For all I know, Ichigo might end up with no one, or maybe his other classmates(male/female). Sinta, until you can come out with a speculated storyline that includes fightings scenes, weapons, tactics and other Bleach characters( eg Hitsugaya, Aizen, Ichimaru, Soi Fon, Yoruichi, Urahara, Vaizards, etc) then whatever stuffs that revolves around Ichigo and Rukia or Ichigo and Orihime are just a pigment of fandom dream and imagination. edit:: Unless of course, if the story ends abruptly Last edited by asam_laksa; 2008-02-25 at 22:35. |
|||
2008-02-25, 22:49 | Link #1940 |
Junior Member
Join Date: Feb 2008
|
I am new to this so stay with me a little bit. 1st of all I see this topic is causing malice in some people and I will like to say its not that serious. Moving on! I don't know who Ichigo will end up, none of us knows, so I can not get mad at others opinions about the storyline. I'm confused. In episode 17 Urahara states "if you disire with all your heart to save rukia....The power of love is greater than steel." Later in that coversation they show rukia walking away and ichigo next statement is"I felt like....the rain had stopped. It gets confusing when Ganju ask him if rukia is important to him and he says no. After that and the rest of the ss arc ichigo kept repeating how he owed her and nothing more. In episode 16 rukia states feelings which will become shackles....feelings of closeness....stated next by "me and ichigo are just friends."In episode 30 rukia goes into further details of how close she felt ichigo and herself was by stating how ichigo was someone she could trust"completely". This still does not make more than friends tho.In episodes 8 and 9 when the shinigami came to see what was up with rukia, he was going to go back to soul society saying that " I ain't crazy enough to break up a couple and...rukia has reached that age" she tells him not too say that. The interesting thing was she did not tell him what he was suggesting was wrong. Still it is no evidence for a relationship greater than friendship between them. Many people outside of them too think they are a couple in the 1st sixty something episodes of bleach. Rukia once denied it and Ichigo states" If I care what people said I would have dyed my hair black." With Orihime and ichigo the relationship has grown but there is no dialogue between them or speculators to suggest anything more. What I mean by that is there is no one in the bleach community who look at them two and say what they might think between Ichigo and rukia. Again I am not suggesting one over the other, this is just the facts. In my opinion both ichigo and rukia, ichigo and orihime has had moments who no words were said but you felt more than friendship. So even though I have a favorite I would like to see, there is no evidence for either romance right now.sorry guys.
|
|
|