Rate That Signature!

[vandakiara]

Originally Posted by Risa chan

Vandakiara : 9.4/10 I really like it. You captured the colors greatly and the text is perfectl placed. Good job! And good luck ^^

thanks for the positive feedback good luck to you too :3

actually I love your entry too - 9.7/10

[Katocchi]

Risa chan - 9/10 I like it

Now I use Rotator sig with same render

[vandakiara]

Kato-chan ~ I won't rate my own sig x)

but Risa's a 9/10 and Rin's an 8.5/10 for me

[Haladflire65]

Katocchi: 9/10 Very good.
vandakiara: 8/10 A little too centered, but pretty good.

[Chaho-Chi]

vandakiara: 9/10 Whats with the 'smile'. ._.
Katocchi: The one with the cellphone like text at the top right: 8.7/10 Pretty simple but nice. =)
Risa chan: 8.9/10 Not bad

It took me forever to render out the two pokemon. (Thank god its finally over) >.>

[Katocchi]

ayu-smepai - 8/10

[ganbaru]

The Chaos ( The girl in the sky one ) 8.9/10 good artwork
vandakiara 9/10 a good idea for the SOTM
Ayu smepai 8,4/10 that's pokemon?
Hs Vi Germania 8,3/10 not bad
Katocchi 9.3/10 exelent artwork

Originally Posted by ayu-smepai

I can't find much art or good renders outisde those two

There is plenty of others good stuff outside those 2, even if you have to scan it out of book yourself .

[grylsyjaeger]

Katocchi: Very beautiful for such a tragic scene. 9.5/10

[Bea Rabbit]

fallschirmjager : I think its meaning full. 8.10

[vandakiara]

fallschirmjager - that's a beautiful sig specially when someone has read onani master kurosawa and understands the scene - 9.5/10

Bea Rabbit - 8.5/10

[Temari of Suna]

Katocchi - 10/10.

That's awesome!

[Katocchi]

Bea Rabbit - 8/10

[Chaho-Chi]

Originally Posted by ganbaru

There is plenty of others good stuff outside those 2, even if you have to scan it out of book yourself .

I read more manga than anime and It's really hard to find art outside those three (I ment three sorry >.>)
Most of the anime I watch I'm not really "Obsessed" enough to make a sig anyways.

[Furuno]

ayu-smepai : 7.34 / 10
Katocchi : 9.46 / 10
Temari of Suna : 7.02 / 10
vandakiara : 8.89 / 10
Bea Rabbit : 7.43 / 10

I'm still trying to recovering my sig making skill...

[Miko Miko]

Furuno - 8/10 I think its a little plain.

[Hs Vi Germania]

Furuno: 7.5/10 Sorry.
ayu-smepai: 7.5/10 Sorry².
Katocchi: They really die too often and in too many sigs. 9/10
vandakiara: Same anime source again. 9/10
Bea Rabbit: It's a bit too small and simple, I guess, although I am Shana fan. ^^ 7/10
fallschirmjager: No words, much meaning. Good sig. 9/10
ganbaru: It's only bright. 7.5/10 Sorry³.

[Risa chan]

Can i have C&C From you guys?
I don't know about my entry.

wich one do you think is better?





HS : 8.6/10

Miko miko 9.5/10

[ganbaru]

fallschirmjager 8,8/10 which manga it came from ?
Bea Rabbit 8,4/10 look good
Furoro 8,3/10 not bad
Hs Vi Germania 8,3/10 exept being dark, I don't know what to say.
Risa chan ( posted one) the first is better 8,9/10

Originally Posted by ayu-smepai

I read more manga than anime and It's really hard to find art outside those three (I ment three sorry >.>)
Most of the anime I watch I'm not really "Obsessed" enough to make a sig anyways.

I know , I have the same problem with the sig than I use (I have pretty much given upo the hope to find any fan-art for the ''Bungaku Shoujo'' Serie. )

[Katocchi]

ganbaru - 8/10

[The Chaos]

Kato-Chan..look Great ..9.5/10