Rate That Signature!

[Faeyice]

Spectacular_Insanity: Pretty nice. 8

[guiltygearxt]

darkjester: 7/10 (dont like the color nor text and render is bad quality, good effect nonetheless.)

deathkillz: 8/10 (not a fan of text, i believe u used overlay on them)

diaboso: 8.5/10 (looks good but i dislike animation)

karuma: 7/10

mueti: 8/10

klashikari: all 4 = 8.5/10 (i personally dont like 2 much text and in all different places + outglow, but they still do look good in the sigs nonetheless and its been ur style.)

Ai Suzuki: 7.5/10 (text is way 2 big and should lower the contrast in my opinion)

[konstargirl]

darkjester: 9/10

[Silver Dragon]

Meuti: Simple, yet beautiful 9/10
Guiltygearxt: Good use of the pen tool and C4D's 10/10

[darkjester]

Deathkillz: me no likey pinky... and some of the blending is kinda er... also whats that stuff on the right supposed to be? still
its got pizzas... and creative... 7.1/10
Klashikari: love your strikers rookies set... creative, unique, and sexy... 8.7/10
-KarumA-: too plain, imo... sketches aren't that great a choices for sigs... 6/10

@mysigchange: mmmm kay, made some changes to my sig... messed with the color scheme(maybe all yellow was a bad idea.. )... as well as some of the blending... also changed one of the text...

Spoiler for sig rated:

Spoiler for "other versions of sig:

this is the original...


and this is sans most of the yellow "stars" with a different blend of text...

so, what u think? better? worst? bout the same? let me knows..

k thxs....

[Cyz]

@ Deathkillz: Somehow the BG color doesn't seem to suit Yoko. 8/10

@ Mueti: Is that Mishima Reiika? Awesome! You might want to reduce the width though since it's making a little empty. 9/10

@ guiltygearxt: Saber and the BG designs and colors really go hand in hand. 10/10

-> I just figured out the name of the girl on my sig. She's Enma Ai from Jigoku Shoujo

[Cyz]

@ Theowne: You forgot to rate.

-> Your sig is really peaceful no? 7/10

-> New sig I just finished making. C.C from Code Geass.

[guiltygearxt]

nuriko_konstar_2006: 6.5/10 (looks 2 plain and text doesnt really fit)

Silver Dragon: 8/10 (good effects but some parts could've been smudged better and need 2 work on text, also try 2 blur some parts in the background 2 create more depth and would make the sig alot better. Other than that its good sig.)

Cyz: 8/10 (i like the color and text, the simplicity on the sig is a beauty itself, looks smooth and clean. And gj on this non corp sig )

darkjester: 8/10 (current is definitely a better color choice)

[Theowne]

@ "Rate or die" message - I had thought I should put some stuff in before rating other's stuff, guess not

I like Mueti's sig because of the colors, very relaxing. I also think guiltygearxt's sig is nice, seems to weave together well, the character looks welcoming as well. 10/10 to both.

[Spectacular_Insanity]

Originally Posted by Klashikari

Spoiler for 4 signatures, saving space:

I give the first one (blue) a perfect 10/10.
Orange: 8/10
Yellow: 8/10
Pink: 9/10

Great job, overall.

[Silver Dragon]

3/10, because of the dancing banana dude

[Cyz]

Originally Posted by guiltygearxt

Cyz: 8/10 (i like the color and text, the simplicity on the sig is a beauty itself, looks smooth and clean. And gj on this non corp sig )

You could go and click on my sig and visit my thread if you want to

@ Silver Dragon: 7/10

[guiltygearxt]

Theowne:
sig: 7.5/10 (somehow i like this old looking style sig, but color and text could've been better)

Spectacular_Insanity:
sig: rofl/10

@ Cyz:
lol, even tho im kind shy....e-love sent XD

[darkjester]

Theowne: really does look nice & peaceful... the text kills it for me though 6.4/10
Cyz: very nice and serene, and her stare is mezmerizing... 8/10
guiltygearxt: everything just comes together nicely... i like it... 9/10

Spoiler for sig rated:

i have 2 other versions of my current sig...

Spoiler for "other versions of sig:

this is the original...


and this is sans most of the yellow "stars" with a different blend of text...

k thxs...

[KiNA]

@ Cyz .. Clean.. except the text placement is a little off =/

@ GGxt .. excellent.. Source = Ryu's latest work? I *think* I dont have that @_@... And I collect all T2 and Ryu's work :O

@ jester ..Star overload.. and Yuki kinda blurry a bit =/

[guiltygearxt]

Kina:
8/10 for creativity

and ur talking about the girl in the sig right? if so, probably, tho i got lots renders/vectors from many different sites

[Cyz]

@ guiltygearxt: That's Hibana from Kunoichi isn't it? Points for the nice img and BG designs. Text should be a little light IMO. 9/10

[Deathkillz]

guiltygearxt ~ ecchi!!! >_< but really nice :3 thought some parts are pixelated ~ 9/10

cyz ~ oo CC but imo you should loose the outer glow around her as it doesnt fit >.< but on the whole i like the mood ~ simple but effective 8/10


___________________

[Sephi]

@deathkillz 8/10 :P strikers ftw ^^ I made a somewhat similair one awhile ago. We probably used the same source.

Spoiler:

And your old Yoko sig. Mmm 7.7/8 What's up with Yoko these days!! Can't open a thread without seeing a Yoko sig these days. Perhaps i should really watch the anime.

@cyz 7.5/10 Simple but nice.

@guiltygearx. 7.7/10 Nice bre... errr signature.

@kira_naruto lol at the conversation ^^ Doesn't look spectacular. But 8.5/10 for the creativity.

@darkjester 7.5/10 I like the pure blue one the most. Basically the one your using atm. Though mm theres just a bit of yellow in it to. Btw, didn't you had a pure blue one? Or is that the one your using atm?

@silver_dragon 7.7/10. Overall looks good. But only problem is i can't read what the text says.

@nuriko_konstar_2006 7/10. Could be a bit more fancier.

@Mueti 7.9/10 crop or scale or not. It looks good. And my current one is also crop and scale with some border and text added.

@-KarumA- 7.5/10 bit plain. But looks nice

@Diaboso Nice shape on the signature. But mm the photo there looks a bit odd. Though it is creative. 7.5/10

[konstargirl]

@deathkillz: 8/10. I have no commemnt but to say I like it.

@-KarumA-: Looks plain but oh well. I like it. so 8/10

@guiltygearxt : 9/10. Love the purple background.

@Sephi: I love your siggy so 9.3/10

@Kira_Naruto : I love the dialog and the render so 10/10 for you.