2009-08-09, 04:51 | Link #342 |
Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
|
Not containing every single minor occurrence doesn't disqualify something from being an alternate form of canon. Altering events, or adding some however does. Only in that particular instance though. If you are holding out for an anime that is 100% canon you will be waiting till the end of time mate.
Haruhi is pretty much as close as I have seen, and the vast majority of the time it's a faithful adaptation. Containing every major event without (to my knowledge) exception. Your idea of "Novel Canon" doesn't seem relevant to even use in description of any adaptation. Are you going to claim that the LotR movies aren't canon because they missed a crapload of events out, yet still contains all of the important core story? Well sorry, but I think that's rather silly. |
2009-08-09, 04:51 | Link #343 |
Disabled By Request
Join Date: Dec 2008
|
Hm. Weird. Kouyouen Haruhi pictures ads, Yuki making that pulling motion...well, they DID give us eight Endless Eight...
I shiver to see what you will do with this. Anyway, I'm turning in, seeing as I've officially gotten NO SLEEP AT ALL until early morning, so I'm gonna sleep through the afternoon! Yay! |
2009-08-09, 04:52 | Link #344 | |
Disabled By Request
Join Date: Dec 2008
|
Quote:
|
|
2009-08-09, 04:57 | Link #345 | |
Homo Ludens
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Canada
Age: 34
|
Quote:
Seriously What?! I was only saying that you can't use anything the anime, and only the anime, did when trying to cite evidence for theories in relation to the the books. I wasn't knocking the adaptation at all. |
|
2009-08-09, 05:09 | Link #346 | ||
Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
||
2009-08-09, 06:18 | Link #348 | |
less qq; more pewpew
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Philippines
|
Quote:
Case in point: the Warcraft books. These books were written by different authors with differing storytelling styles but they we're all supervised and endorsed as canon by Chris Metzen, Blizzard's main Warcraft lorecrafter. Anyway, these are just my thoughts. I'd rather have the discussion move on to something else.
__________________
|
|
2009-08-09, 06:35 | Link #349 | |
Senior Member
|
Quote:
For another exemple, pick DragonBall. Dragon Ball: Online ignores Dragonball GT. Also, I am sure many fans will be pissed if you say that Dragonball Evolution is cannon. Warcraft, Star Wars, Warhammer40000... All of then has many authors, and all books are cannon. Suzumiya has only one author, Tanigawa. The anime and the manga is an adaption, de books are independent of them. |
|
2009-08-09, 07:25 | Link #350 |
Senior Member
Author
|
My take on the shipping wars thus far...
To be completely honest and frank, I tended to see the bossy, charismatic, dynamic, and passionate Haruhi as a bad romantic mix with the subdued easily pushed-over Kyon. Oh, I get that they work as a comedian/straight-man routine, but an outright serious romance/marriage perhaps should have two people involved in it more like one another than Haruhi and Kyon are. Nonetheless, it's obviously the most likely pairing to result based on the narrative framework of this anime/novel, and also based on the simple rule that main male protagonist usually ends up with the main female protagonist (unless one or the other is already attached to someone else - and even then that's not a foolproof exception). The first seven parts of Endless Eight took my reservations towards HaruhiKyon even farther though - it made me think that Haruhi is simply flat-out too good for this imbecilic lazy bum Kyon. The final part of Endless Eight, though... if Kyon can show a bit more of his Kamina side; maybe enough to even reign Haruhi in a bit - then I can perhaps like the pairing. Basically, if Kaisos theory holds true, then I'm fine with HaruhiKyon. Spoiler for Novel 4:
All told, if I were to give percentages for various shipping outcomes at this point (I may adjust them as I read further into the novels though), these would be them... Kyon and Haruhi - 40% Kyon and Yuki - 20% Kyon and Mikuru - 10% (it would be higher if not for what Kaisos said) Kyon and some other girl - 10% Kyon remains unattached - 20% Haruhi has as good a chance as all the other girls combined. It wouldn't shock me to see the shipping wars end with out firm conclusion, though - only one novel left, and a kiss in a "dream" is as far as Kyon as gotten with anybody yet.. a lot of ground has to be made up, and made up fast. Alternate shipping possibilities... Mikuru and Kyon - 10% Mikuru and Koizumi - 10% (he does consistently compliment her, I find) Mikuru and Haruhi - 5% (Haruhi is slightly bi-sexual, I think - leans straight, but some lesbianism and she adores Mikuru) Mikuru remains unattached - 75% (poor girl) Koizumi and Mikuru - 10% Koizumi and Yuki - 1% (only because these two are so mysterious) Koizumi and some other girl - 25% (if Haruhi becomes attached, he moves freely) Koizumi remains unattached - 64% Haruhi and Kyon - 40% Haruhi and Mikuru - 5% Haruhi remains unattached - 55% And you can determine Yuki's percentages from the above - I don't see her ending up with anybody other than Kyon, Koizumi, or nobody at all. |
2009-08-09, 07:43 | Link #351 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2009
|
Sheesh, I could imagine Tanigawa reading the countless shipping debates (such as the one in this thread), which in turn causes him -- out of sheer exasperation -- to execute a Macross Frontier "solution"...
Spoiler:
|
2009-08-09, 07:46 | Link #352 |
Senior Member
|
What a detailed post! A agree with most you said anyway. Though I would give Kyon with Haruhi more then 50%. Both are the focus of the series.
For Yuki, after a certan chapter, I can definitivelly see her with some one in the end. Even if is a random one. (this chapter is on book 6, if you are wondering) I am also a KyonYuki shipper, though I really don't believe it is happening. Ah, you forget KyonxKoizumi . I understand who says Itsuki is not gay, only like to tease Kyon. However, In novel9 he use himself as an exemple to someone Kyon would be jelous (before he move to Mikuru). It wasn't a tease, because Kyon didn't even know they are talking about romantic feelings. I really don't remeber Itsuki saying he acts gay to please Haruhi (outside TVtropes, at last). Also, he only act gay when Haruhi is notalround. I find the theory he thinks Kyon is hot because a mental link with Haruhi more understandable. Novel10 is not the last, btw. Or, at last, no one ever said it (officialy speaking). |
2009-08-09, 08:08 | Link #353 | |||
Senior Member
Author
|
Thanks! I've always been interested in seeing how romances play out in stories, and Haruhi's anime is certainly no exception.
Quote:
Kyon and Haruhi - 55% Kyon remains unattached - 5% Haruhi and Kyon - 55% Haruhi remains unattached - 40% Quote:
Quote:
|
|||
2009-08-09, 08:16 | Link #354 | |
is a myth
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: FL
Age: 30
|
Quote:
Koizumi will also probably remain alone; if not, it's probably gonna be Haruhi (but, seeing as how she's gaga over Kyon...). Yuki might end up with Kyon, Haruhi might end up with Kyon, Kyon might end up with either. IMO anyway. BTW, nice post; I know I don't have that much patience.
__________________
|
|
2009-08-09, 08:27 | Link #355 | ||||
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Also, "straight as an arrow". Funny how metaphor works, this phrase don't make sense when I (mentally) translate it to portuguese (soo it took me a while to understand). |
||||
2009-08-09, 08:48 | Link #356 | ||
less qq; more pewpew
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Philippines
|
Quote:
Yes. What I meant was that we should consider anime-LIS as a retcon if it is confirmed that Tanigawa had a hand on episode planning. As with the case with multiple authors, any work that the original author/lorecrafter blesses as canon will be part of canon. Anime example: Ga-Rei Zero Popular example: And Another Thing..., the upcoming book of The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy series Quote:
__________________
|
||
2009-08-09, 09:04 | Link #357 | |||
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Quote:
Do not know, sorry. Another anime exemple (and a better one): Fullmetal Alchemist. The first anime is very different from the manga. It is a continuity by it own, has it own cannon. And it is not the manga one. (the second is another hsitory, being more faithfull to the manga) Quote:
Eh, why? This is as important as shiping, I believe. Last edited by Heatth; 2009-08-09 at 10:29. |
|||
2009-08-09, 10:14 | Link #358 | ||
less qq; more pewpew
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Philippines
|
Quote:
Anime example would be True Tears by PA Works. True Tears (game) and True Tears (anime) have completely different plots and characters.However, by glancing at this article, one can say that canon is loosely used as a word to describe the original story itself. For example, the difference between fanon and "adaptation canon" becomes blurry when an adaptation references fan speculation. Quote:
The problem I see with multiple canons is that they might as well be split into different franchises under one brand name. But that's just me. I, too, would would like to hear others' thoughts on this.
__________________
|
||
2009-08-09, 10:28 | Link #359 | ||||
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Post Postum: An exemple of the "fanfic canon": Here you can see the archives of the Genderbend Project. A serie of fanfics. There is a lot of writes there, however, we only consider Kaiso's as offcial, canon here. There is no much importance (since this fanfics are just as important as any other), however, the Visual Novel Project being a child of this one, only consider the 'canon' of it (so Ryou attackeed Kyonko with a katana, not knife, even thoug dkellis write a scene with him using the latter). You may not call it 'canon', if you think it is wrong. It is just the word I am using to describe it. Last edited by Heatth; 2009-08-09 at 10:43. |
||||
2009-08-09, 11:49 | Link #360 |
Senior Member
Author
|
My take on the "What is canon?" debate.
My view is that there's four basic levels of canon. Ranging from most authoritative to least authoritative, imo, they are... 1) Source Material canon 2) Alternative material canon 3) Adaptation canon 4) Fan-created canon (i.e. gender-bended Haruhi being a good example here) I hasten to add that there are anime original animes - Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha is, IIRC, an anime original anime. So, any mangas or novels spawning from that anime are the adaptation (or alternative) canon. Mangas and novels are not always the source material for anime - there are instances (rare though they may be) where the opposite is true. Source material canon simply means the initial canon in its initial medium form, whatever that may be. For Haruhi, its the novels. For Nanoha, its the anime. For Bleach, its the manga. And so on, and so forth. So, the Haruhi novels are the definitive authoritative canon for Haruhi... if anything is. Now, alternative material canon refers to canons that differ from the source material to such an extent that it's basically like looking at an alternate reality world of the source canon. Usually, this is intentional - as in the case of some of the different Tenchi Muyo! realities, for example. These various alternate material canons are authoritative but only unto themselves - they have no bearing on the source material, or any interpretations thereof. In some cases, they should be treated as a totally separate story. Alternative material canon is often recognized by how it shares the same medium as the source material, but is placed in an alternate universe or with a different series of events. Adaptation canon refers to a medium translation of the source material - in Haruhi's case, from novel to anime. Source material canon is generally considered to trump adaptation canon where the two conflict... unless the adaptation canon is so radically different from the source material canon that you could consider it alternative material canon (which one could argue is the case with the older Full Metal Alchemist anime, as well as with the Shakugan no Shana anime). Seeing as how the Haruhi anime is a pretty faithful adaptation of the novel, thus far, the novel rules over any inconsistencies between the two, imo. Now, it should be noted that adaptation canon frequently has a lot of fans that haven't read or played or watched the source material - loads of people watch anime but don't read much manga, for example. For these people, the adaptation canon is the only one that counts, and... I'm inclined to let them think what they want, and not be dogmatic with them as it pertains to the source material canon unless they go claim "It doesn't matter what the source material canon says! This is what happened in the anime so its true for the entire fandom, and we must all adhere to it!". And finally, there's the fan-created canon - which is arguably not canon at all. As with adaptation canon, I'm not too dogmatic here unless fans of the fan-created fandom start saying that their fandom is more authoritative than even the source material is - then I jump in, and probably object. There is one caveat though - sometimes the source material is incredibly slim, and the fan-created fandom is basically all there is. The Touhou game, and the fandom that it was the catalyst for, comes immediately to mind here. In lieu of how Touhou has very, very little source material story, I'm inclined to consider fandom canon for it to be legitimate - it's filling in for the many gaps left by the game. However, this isn't the case with Haruhi - not yet, anyway. So, if Haruhi and Kyon end up together in the novels, but Kyon and Yuki; Haruhi and Mikuru end up together in the anime (I highly doubt that such a major difference will occur, but let's postulate that they do, just for argument's sake), then I'd either consider the novel canon ending the authoritative one... or I'd treat both canons as separate continuities/stories entirely. Just my take. What do other people here think? No, I don't have a blog. I might consider making one, though, if anybody here would be interested in reading it. I could focus it primarily on Haruhi for now, and then tack on other animes that interest me. Last edited by Triple_R; 2009-08-09 at 12:00. |
|
|