[SPOILER] Manga, Anime, & LN Where The Girl MC Ended Up With Is Not The Main Heroine

[wuhugm]

Originally Posted by Devaki

Since you added another category, would you like to add shoujo manga too?

Not shoujo manga

There are just too many

I like reading them

But all of them are the same

Black haired cool main hero always win

There are great shoujo like Hibi Chouchou and Tonari no Kaibutsu

But most of them are just not memorable enough

[Tenzen12]

Checked Elfen lied manga ending. It fits.

Also Mama wa dokyuusei

[Devaki]

Originally Posted by wuhugm

Not shoujo manga

There are just too many

I like reading them

But all of them are the same

Black haired cool main hero always win

There are great shoujo like Hibi Chouchou and Tonari no Kaibutsu

But most of them are just not memorable enough

That's exactly the core reason why this thread exist.

There is Tonari no Atashi if you want.

[wuhugm]

^Yes, but there are way too many trash shoujo manga that I wouldn't bother

Originally Posted by Tenzen12

Checked Elfen lied manga ending. It fits.

Also Mama wa dokyuusei

Added both

[Devaki]

^ OK then.


Anime : Walkure Romanze has unexpected "winner"

Spoiler for winner:

↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓

Well no kidding, but Celia actually wins in manga version.

Story wise it obviously based on her route from the game but the setting/starting plot still established and remind you that Mio also still the main heroine/cover girl for the series even though there is another manga for Mio's route.

[wuhugm]

^Really? Added then~

[Tenzen12]

I think this is rare case where you should open that spoiler before adding it into list.

[whiteshadow]

Hey, what about chihayafuru? Doesn't the series qualify for this thread?

[wuhugm]

^Dunno anything about that

[cyberdemon]

Originally Posted by wuhugm

Added IGPX: Immortal Grand Prix then

Even if she didn't feel it as much. She was still one of the main characters of the show so I don't think this applies.

[pervypig]

Does School Days count? Which one do you think Makoto-sama 'ended' up with? Sekai who literally 'ended' his life, or Kotonoha who 'ended' the show with a cruise-trip?

[RpR1337]

Originally Posted by pervypig

Does School Days count? Which one do you think Makoto-sama 'ended' up with? Sekai who literally 'ended' his life, or Kotonoha who 'ended' the show with a cruise-trip?

NO! Please no, oh God no, no, no, not that fkin nightmare of a series again! Anyway, he probably ended up with exactly what he deserved, so I'd vote it was "working as intended". Even then, I don't want that fkin crap haunting me in my sleep, with a situation that often happens in real life without the body count actually causing everyone to go Higurashi on each other.

Originally Posted by Devaki

^ OK then.


Anime : Walkure Romanze has unexpected "winner"

Spoiler for winner:

↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓

Well no kidding, but Celia actually wins in manga version.

Story wise it obviously based on her route from the game but the setting/starting plot still established and remind you that Mio also still the main heroine/cover girl for the series even though there is another manga for Mio's route.

That stuff is literally what happened in MajiKoi too (that was crazy fun). I think there it was hermit crabs maybe? And my big magnum, of course, with one hell of a huge wasabi?

Originally Posted by whiteshadow

Hey, what about chihayafuru? Doesn't the series qualify for this thread?

Stone me if I'm wrong, but I believe Chihaya Full isn't over yet. Though there won't be a hero×heroine, as simply tearing Chihaya off of Karuta is something neither Arata nor Taichi actually managed.
I do know that

Spoiler for later in the manga:

Arata confesses his love to Chihaya, and comes back to Tokyo, but that kind of died without Chihaya giving an answer - or actually registering all that happened ...

but I don't think there was a legitimate conclusion to that at all.

[Narberal]

hmm can Tegami Bachi considered in this list?

[Devaki]

Originally Posted by RpR1337

That stuff is literally what happened in MajiKoi too (that was crazy fun). I think there it was hermit crabs maybe? And my big magnum, of course, with one hell of a huge wasabi?

Exactly and I want to mention that too, the only difference....

Spoiler for in MajiKoi manga:

Momoyo won and she is the main heroine

[RpR1337]

Originally Posted by Devaki

Exactly and I want to mention that too, the only difference....

Spoiler for in MajiKoi manga:

Momoyo won and she is the main heroine

Actually, the one who shouted 'MAJI DE WATASHI NI KOI SHINASAI!!!' in the end (which also happens to be the title of the series, making a nice full circle) is literally all the girls, meaning as far as they're concerned, neither was anyone chosen, nor was anything over.

Of course, I didn't mention it either, though not because the 'main girl' won, but because nobody actually won in the end, as it was left open with the hermit crab pun.

EDIT: Oh, right. Manga. Yea, that conclusion suited me better too, though seeing the faces of the other girls made me remember the faces of the girls other than Rias in DxD when Ise finally confessed.

We all know how that will end (partially ended already, he's at 7 proposals, if I remember correctly).

[Tenzen12]

Castle town Dandelion?

[wuhugm]

^That has romance?

[Tenzen12]

That usually happens before marriage?

[Seiya0890]

Originally Posted by Narberal

hmm can Tegami Bachi considered in this list?

I was wondering the same thing, did

Spoiler for spoil:

Lag X Sylvette happened in the manga

?

[Devaki]

Originally Posted by RpR1337

though seeing the faces of the other girls made me remember the faces of the girls other than Rias in DxD when Ise finally confessed.

From DxD recent season? I didn't watch it because the art style from the new studio somewhat turn me off, but everyone already knew how it's going in the novel anyway.

@tiger Does Negima has been mentioned before? I think it's on par with Eyeshield 21 and Digimon where the MC didn't end up with anyone but the chance of him with the main heroine are close to zero (though in Asuna's case not because she is paired with someone else).