Rate That Signature!

[~Chakra-Chan~]

reith: 10/10 ~ I love this darkness shown in your signature ^.^

edit: the one in your signature, itachi and the red moon ^.^

I try out some of "Record of Lodoss War" The one at the avatar is Deedlit, the other one is named Pirotess

[The Chaos]

Icy ....Kawaii~Sig..9.5/10^^

[Reith]

Originally Posted by ~Chakra-Chan~

reith: 10/10 ~ I love this darkness shown in your signature ^.^

Which one Chakra?

[CXC]

Its been awhile since I last came here

cicido: 9/10

KasumiGirl: always like acrhery 9/10

[Mitsu Aoi]

It's been a while checking this thread
and Soo many great sigs =<
And heres my noobish comment (Dont bully me please )

cicido: For me I think too much gamma on the character =< (or is just my PC got high gamma) 7/10
Spectacular_Insanity: Dont have much to comment (I'm bad at making comments) I like the second one soo 8.5/10
KasumiGirl: No it isnt a failed one (brighten it up a bit) I like how the shadow effect sorround the character speaking of her she's cool looking one 9/10
Hijiroku: I lol'd watching at it soo true xD 9/10
Ice Climbers: wish I could know how to make such effects 9/10
Aya Reiko: For having a simple sig and a Touhou character you got a rigged score of 8/10
Faeyice: Agree with marina needs something more 7/10
Marina: Horo!! I like one color theme blends soo 9/10
Aoie Emesai: No its cute that way :O IMO isnt the pink color out of place? 8.5/10
Reith: Did you darken Itachi on purpose or thats just the way it should be? anyways the BG looks great 8.5/10
Chakra-chan: Cropped sigged? 7/10
The Chaos: Miku!! I love the background and how the character positioned for the sig
CXC: I like unique shaped sigs and this one looks great 9/10

Edit: Yike forgot to rate The Chaos 8.5/10

[The Chaos]

Mitsu Aoi...Nice Sig For The SOTM ..^^..8.7/10

[Marina]

Mitsu Aoi - agreed w/ Chaos-chan, your sig is very nice for the competition 9/10
Love the slight animation and the render positioning. Think you could make the text just a little easier to read though.
Also wondering what that triangular flap of clearness at the top is all about (sorta makes it look like an envelope! )

[Mitsu Aoi]

pcube19622: \(-o-)/ Hahi!! Needs border 7.5/10
Bakakami: As Ice Climbers says it really needs Blending 7.5/10

Thanks for the advice
Will this do?
I was testing if I could make a glass like effect I guess it didnt suit well =/
Here's the version 2



please visit my own topic page link at my Sig~

[Endrance]

Ice Climbers-10/10 i love the way everything is blended and im in love with that sword!

Faeyice-7/10-yeh her face is a lil faded but i love the purple

Marina-8/10-love the use of colors that blend with everything

Aoie_Emesai-8.5/10-I like those circles its a nice effect

Reith-8/10-I dunno what it is with me and the moons but they rock

~Chakra-Chan~-Nice-7/10

CXC- hmmm 7.5/10

Mitsu Aoi-9.5/10 love the sword infront of the face....Ohhh and love love love the shine

[Aya Reiko]

Marina = 8/10; Kinda hard to see the text.
Mitsu Aoi = 8.8/10; However, Yukarin is infinitely superior, followed closely by Aya-chan.
Endrance = 7/10; shrug

[Furuno]

Aya Reiko : 7/10
Endrance : 7/10 - Maybe better without animation, since the size limitation rule limit the size and so the frame number...
Mitsu Aoi : 10/10 - Great!
Marina : 8.9/10 - Nice color...

This is my temporary sig, i'm currently drawing a sig with 3dsmax, seem it'll take forever to complete...

[The Chaos]

furuno...I Think It Nice Sig..8.3/10

[Spectacular_Insanity]

furuno: Very pretty sig, I love it! (pts for ef, too. ) 9/10

[The Chaos]

Speci...Nice Saber Sig ...^^..9/10

[Ice Climbers]

@Furuno- Text might look a little out of place, but generally pretty ^^ 8/10

Updated version of my sig



Which one is better?

[Avantoe]

Speci: it looks good, backgrounds looks a bit blurry 7/10
Ice Climbers: For some reason i like your previous one more :S either way both of em looks really good 7/10 for both of em

[Spectacular_Insanity]

@ Avantoe: The background is supposed to be blurry. If it were completely opaque and in focus, it would throw off the main focus of the signature---Saber's face. You can't have a foreground image and a mid-level image have the same focus level because it looks too bizarre. Edit: Your sig is pretty as well, 9/10.

Ice Climbers: I really like the new one, but I feel it would be better if the colors on the right side were primarily red instead of purple. As it is, the red and purple are not very complementary and they clash (sorry for the harsh words). I really like the gradient on the left side, though. It merits a solid 8/10.

[DarthNicolas]

Ice Climbers : Both are awesome 10/10 (I prefer the updated one)
Avantoe : It's kinda blur 6/10
Spectacular_Insanity : n1! 8/10

[mxg]

Well as same as the Rate my Ava page I haven't posted here in forever

So judge as you may

Btw FFXI Character DRK 75 Fairy SEE ME !!! Thats my guy in the sig and ava

edit: Oh right i forgot I need to rate also...


DarthNicolas - I am not sure what anime that is from so let me know looks interesting. If I were to judge this looks good and the green glow around the guy who I am guessing is the pilot makes him seem like he belongs in the image. 7/10

Spectacular_Insanity - Simple and to the point with Saber looks good as most simple ones do border also seems to go well with it. 7/10

Ice Climbers - Your sig now is something above average and eye catching, the use of brushes and the bleding fit well especially with the color scheme of red and the border especially looks great a nice accent to the sig. 9/10

[Mitsu Aoi]

furuno: It needs more 8.5/10
Avantoe: Is my eye working well or is it just the character is blurry? 8/10
DarthNicolas: For some reasons I think the text didnt blend well with the image 7.5/10
mxg: The borders seem unclear and your sig size is over the rules 7/10