Rate That Signature!

[Cyz]

@ Ice Climbers: Too late, I already did 8/10

@ Miko Miko: It's a little plain. Not one of your best 6/10

[Zaku Hyuga]

cicido: cool drawing 8/10
Cyz: 10/10
The Chaos: It's seems really plain when compared to other sigs you've used 7/10
Ice Climbers: 10/10
Miko Miko: Not very good 6/10

[cicido]

Avantoe 9 I don't care if it is a simple sig, it is a big improvement from your previous ones and I loved it. :3


This is a failed experiment of the SOTM, I was really proud of it (and I still am), however, the AS sig limitation is merciless.

Spoiler for 333k:

[Ice Climbers]

@cicido- those kinds of animation usually takes a lot of space the whole scenery changed!!

well @ your current one- may be a bit empty on the left top, work on the text a bit it could be great 8/10

@the 333k- great image and great find, but over the limit (and wow you started ALREADY ) 8/10

[Spectacular_Insanity]

cicido: I agree with Icy. Move that text to top left (might wanna resize the text first), and you'ev got yourself a winner. It's still good, in any case. 9/10

Ice Climbers: I don't have to rate this one... but you know I'll give it a 10/10 anyway.

[Cyz]

@ genryou: the text seems a little too bright. It was a good sig and I like the render you used. 8/10

[genryou]

@Ice - epic win 9/10

@Spectacular - maybe you should try highlight it a little? coz the color look kinda plain...7/10

@Cyz - so, bright text is a big turn off huh?

i,ll keep that in mind..

and 8/10 for your sig... good lightning source

[KasumiGirl]

Speci: 8/10

Please rate this:

^^

[Avantoe]

KasumiGirl - It looks really nice the text is awsome! 9/10 still like your current sig more though

[Cyz]

Originally Posted by genryou

@Cyz - so, bright text is a big turn off huh?

i,ll keep that in mind..

and 8/10 for your sig... good lightning source

Well the text looks like it was glowing and it doesn't give the impression that it was blended to the sig.

@ KasumiGirl: The render itself seems to have a rather "funny" color 8/10

[Furuno]

@Avantoe - 7.09/10
@Cyz - 8.32/10

This is my first abstract sig...

[Simple1]

KasumiGirl : 8/10

Just realize that there is hair behind the c4d lol

[skyfirefly]

@ KasumiGirl: the sig is great but i think the render should have been
in other color i think >_<
but still great !! 9/10!!
please rate this two!!
first one:

second one:

[Deathkillz]

skyfirefly ~ wow, sooo much red >_< I like the first one but you should try to tone down the contrast on the second one. I'm not a big fan of monotone themes but it isn't too bad. 7/10 for the first 6/10 for the 2nd.

Simple1 ~ nice depth and nice used of render the white part could be a bit brighter though as it looks rather gray to me. 8/10

Cyz ~ You almost have it right! I would say erase whatever overlay you have on the right side so her colours aren't so diluted. You can add contrast also by smudging with the burn tool (on the darkish sides). 8.5/10

[Avantoe]

Deathkillz - o.O is that actually Gin-sama ? She looks so.. Happy . The signature emits a happy feeling coming from the photo. I really liked the sig. 9/10

[Marina]

dkz - 9/10 pretty nice there ^_^
skyfirefly - 1) RED! SO MUCH RED! 6.5/10 Too much open space on sides, text needs work, 2) If possible, MORE RED! 6/10 Sig looks squashed/stretched, 3) (current) 5/10
furuno - 8/10 Nagisa!

[konstargirl]

@Marina: Doggie. <3 9.5/10

@skyfirefly: I really love red.
-Text looks pretty but maybe work on it a bit. 7.5/10
- I don't think this one is that squash. gives out a nice red efect but too much red on the render looks awkward. Maybe have a little red effect but its cool. 7/10

@Cyz: Looks too bright but its nice 8/10

@Deathkillz: ITs nice I guess 8/10

New siggy for my entry for the contest. I don't know I think its not that elegant enough but I really like the outcome of it.

[Zaku Hyuga]

konstargirlretty 9/10
Deathkillz:really nice 9/10
furuno: it's nice 7/10
KasumiGirl: i like the flowers 8/10

[Cyz]

Originally Posted by Deathkillz

Cyz ~ You almost have it right! I would say erase whatever overlay you have on the right side so her colours aren't so diluted. You can add contrast also by smudging with the burn tool (on the darkish sides). 8.5/10

Almost had it right? With what exactly?

@ Deathkillz: Back to the old Suiginto sig hm? 8/10

[Ice Climbers]

@Cyz- not bad, seems just a bit too bright at the left and the font could be better ^^ 8.5/10
@Zaku Hyuga- a bit empty =/ 7/10
@kornstar- =o your entry for SOTM? Overall nice effects but blend her in more 8/10

Rate/Comments on this would be appreciated: