2007-10-13, 23:16 | Link #7262 | |
SUN faction member
Graphic Designer
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: F City, F Prefecture
Age: 38
|
I wasn't judging based on moe neither.
I was judging based on overrall character traits, personality twists and traits, plot strenghts and at which what extent they can reach the viewers. Runa and San certainly have all of them, while others not. I liked to get a little offtopic with this but I guess it was a hard thing to ask. Quote:
Now I'm off to play some Dungeon Siege II, later mates <3 |
|
2007-10-13, 23:33 | Link #7264 |
User of the "Fast Draw"
|
Then you aren't looking deeply and just judging based on genre. Just because the show makes you laugh along the way hardly means the characters don't have depth and there aren't important values there.
Anyways can't wait to get to the next stage of the tournament. Can finally see the finish line and just know there will be despair along the way.
__________________
|
2007-10-13, 23:35 | Link #7265 |
Hinagiku-ist
|
Well, good for you. You're entitled to like whatever kind of anime you want. But just because you don't find values in a harem comedy, doesn't mean that other people can't enjoy a popcorn anime with mounds of entertainment.
The rounds. They get shorter and shorter. I look on the calendar of matches and can see the end, but the question is what kind of epic matchups will be along the way. Especially after the randomizer for the Elite 8. |
2007-10-13, 23:50 | Link #7266 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Cape Suzette
|
Before this sweet 16 star i just want to have a little run down on your opinions on what were your favorite moments of the Tournament so far.
A few of may favorite moments were when Yue, Nodoka, and Asuna were all knocked out. None of the Negima!? girls should have even gotten past the prelims and seeing them get taught a lesson was very gratifying. Now if only Konoka had faced one of the Dolls earlier on none of the BS about Konoka making it this far would have ever happened. Another moment would be seeing Tsukasa take up the flag as leader of the LS army. She bravely took on the roll after her sister's (unfair and highly contested) demise and got past the 3rd round. To all the San fans be happy that San gave Tsukasa a good run for her money, you guys should be proud. And In my eyes the more wins Tsukasa gets the better it will make San look. Yutaka, although lost to Nanoha in the end of the 1st round, really gave the Nanoha faction a BIG scare. I can't imagine the shock it would have caused to the Nanoha legion if their White Devil had been taken down by a little sickly girl in the very 1st round, who at the time barely had any aire time to start with at that time. If the Tournament had started 2 weeks later after Yutaka had more aire time, the outcome could have been way different with Yutaka actually winning. Too bad i was forced to miss that match, otherwise Yutaka would have only lost by 7 votes. Seeing Gin murder Fate was a site that i will always remember. I don't like ANY of the Nanoha characters and seeing Fate get upended on my birthday for that matter was a great site. And finally Sayuri. Who would have guessed she would have come this far? She is the true Cinderella story here. And seeing her get revenge upon Eruruu for beating our poor Ugu! was very sweet. Lets just see if her Cinderella story can continue! And who knows! People love to cheer on the Cinderella character! Last edited by Mad Dog; 2007-10-13 at 23:58. Reason: Changed Desu to Gin. |
2007-10-13, 23:55 | Link #7267 | |
Ass connoisseur
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Florida
Age: 37
|
Quote:
You must have been watching a match in some alternate universe. Certainly it wasn't Desu who beat Fate this year... In any case, Fate crushed Suigintou in Koreanmoe and she will continue to do the same with Desu... So there!!!!
__________________
|
|
2007-10-13, 23:58 | Link #7269 | |
Style Über Alles
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: NYC/Chicago
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2007-10-13, 23:59 | Link #7270 | |||
Hinagiku-ist
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
|||
2007-10-14, 00:00 | Link #7271 |
Ass connoisseur
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Florida
Age: 37
|
Not true. K.Saimoe will inevitably become the international moe tournament, Saimoe is made up of fake voting and angry i.p. banned foreigners. Myself included.
__________________
Last edited by Demi.; 2007-10-14 at 00:35. |
2007-10-14, 00:07 | Link #7273 |
Seiza + Katana = Ai-daiyo
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Houston (Clear Lake), TX
Age: 44
|
Eh... I got in the mood to do a little reliving ... isn't turning out very good.. probably because I'm trying to stay too close to the last arc and somehow make it make sense.
Spoiler for It already doesn't make sense...:
|
2007-10-14, 00:18 | Link #7274 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2007
|
Quote:
Plz, let Yutaka rest in peace. She did good enough against Nanoha considering her screen time. If Yutaka had more screen time... it didn't happen; she lost by a thin margin and still means that she lost. She is not here anymore. I still don't understand how is Sayuri's journey through Saimoe related to Cinderella's story. Will her magical transformation end at midnight or a prince in white horse marry her by tracking down her slipper? Just kidding. To each his own i guess. For me Sayuri's success is due to a chain of coincidental and beneficial situations where Aria's vote was split and Eruru's support was dropped. Quote:
|
||
2007-10-14, 00:21 | Link #7276 |
I AM BOSS
Join Date: Oct 2007
|
My thoughts on the group finals:
As usual, bold indicates my picks, italicized indicates who I think will actually win: Group A: Shana vs. Nagi If you had asked me 2 weeks ago who was going to win this match-up, I would have said Nagi. However, all the close-calls that Shana has been going through in both J-Saimoe and K-Saimoe have surely rallied a large amount of fan support behind the character. Momentum is squarely on Shana's side, both with SnS season II starting and the backing of her votes. Personally, I'm voting for Shana because when i watched HnG I just couldn't stand Nagi. Group B: Konata vs. Konoka Konata has the fanbase support here, but this match is surely going to be a close one. Konata is by far my favorite character from Lucky-Star, so my vote wasn't difficult, but this match-up could very easily swing either way. In the end, I think the otaku-ness of Konata will help to win out over the anti-KyoAni out there, especially since it seems like Negima's fanbase's support is wavering down the stretch in the two tournaments. Group C: Nanoha vs. Vita I haven't seen Nanoha, so I'll probably abstain from voting in this group's finals. However, everything that I've read indicates that the fanbase will support Nanoha over Vita, boosting her into a second Top 8. Group D: Yuno vs. Rena I can't quite decide which way this match-up will go, but I'm definitely throwing in my vote for Rena. A loli psychotic yandere who can (and will) chop you up into tiny pieces? sign me up please! Group E: Shinku vs. Ayumu I'm honestly surprised that Hamster is still in the tournament at this point. Considering her character status in HnG, I would've expected her to lose to Teana, or at least Tamao. However, she's managed to persevere. I know there's a lot of talk regarding sacrificing Shinku in favor of Desu/Suigintou, but I think the right decision for Rozen Maiden fans would be to sacrifice Desu, since that outcome of that contest is much less certain. Group F: Suiseiseki vs. Tsukasa Sorry, I don't think there will be a repeat here this year. The match-up is very nearly 50-50, and it is very probable that when the day comes, Desu will defeat Tsukasa, but the correct decision here, strategically, is to allow Tsukasa to advance in favor of pursuing a Suigintou victory in the Top 8. Both of these characters are extremely moe, although in different ways. Personally, I think Suiseiseki has a lot more depth to her than Tsukasa, although what made me fall in love with Tsukasa in the first place was the fact that so many of the quirks about her character I could see inside myself and my friends. Group G: Sayuri vs. Rika This vote is purely based on the series for me, but I don't think that Rika has the power necessary to overcome Sayuri. Group H: Suigintou vs. Louise The most "sure" of the brackets, although if Saimoe has taught us anything it's that it can always leave us in despair with a few, nasty surprises. However, this is most likely the year that Gin wins it all. So what type of Top 8 does that give us? We'll have 3 KyoAni characters (2 from Lucky Star), 2 Dolls, 1 return champion, Shana, the dark horse, and either one Higruashi character or one Hidamari character. Unless they get favorable pairings, I'd expect all 3 KyoAni characters to be out in the Quarterfinals, although if one of the Lucky Star characters gets paired against Shinku, I'd say they'd advance over her. Nanoha won't lose to anyone except for Suigintou or Shana, but that means she could be out in any round, depending on her pairings. I think Suigintou is the most likely character to win at this point, although if she's paired up against Nanoha (and defeats her) in the Quarterfinals, that's going to create a lot of hate-votes from the Nanoha faction for defeating both Fate and Nanoha, which might relegate her to an early exit, especially if it's against Shana in the Semis. Most likely winner: Suigintou Also likely: Shana Possible but probably not: Nanoha repeat |
2007-10-14, 00:36 | Link #7277 |
Not Enough Sleep
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: R'lyeh
Age: 48
|
He is not quite at that level yet but mad dog reminds me of "rin-sama" form last year.
both of them seems to like to pick fights with people for no reason. As far as match ups. I like nanoha's chance against anyone but gin. Shana is the hot thing going right now but there is a lot of Nanoha fans over at the K.saimoe who are frothing at the mouth over nanoha's 1 vote lost to shana. This would be the time to avenge that match. As far as the sugintou match. it is going to depend on a lot of factors. if they meet in the finals Gin has a slightly better chance. but if they meet before the finals you might see a lot of tactical voting in Nanoha's favor in order to knock out Gin before Gin can knock their character. As it is Gin is currently the leader in the number of votes receive so far.
__________________
|
2007-10-14, 00:39 | Link #7278 | |
Reset, reset, reset...
Join Date: Jan 2006
|
Quote:
The Rika-supporter in me applauds you.
__________________
|
|
2007-10-14, 00:39 | Link #7279 | |
User of the "Fast Draw"
|
Quote:
Predictions beyond these matches can be pretty dangerous. For the reason we have no clue who will win or go up against who. Toss in tactics, revenge, the expected fake votes, and what is going on in K.Saimoe there are a ton of factors to wade through.
__________________
|
|
2007-10-14, 01:53 | Link #7280 |
Seiza + Katana = Ai-daiyo
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Houston (Clear Lake), TX
Age: 44
|
eh.... it's more like I just dont want to think about the things I am supposed to be thinking about.... i've needed a "break from reality" for awhile...
but took a break to watch some sky girls and seto no hanayome... hm. Spoiler for Next few matches of interest in my portraying of the story.:
Last edited by todkapuz; 2007-10-14 at 02:35. |
|
|