2013-01-20, 14:48 | Link #61 |
にこにこにー
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: 国立音ノ木坂学院
|
Bumping a little bit...since I finally go through the result just yesterday.
For Nova... 1. The KEY factor is still there. Little Busters (at least Kud and Rin) getting a good share even with the anime not being as popular as it could have if it's Kyoani instead of J.C. 2. Not many surprises on top. Maybe Rea still being THIS popular, Tsumiki actually getting some love. Knowing how Homu did last year and she's still 12th here, though, the pool is not exactly strong. 3. Toki and Kuro actually go through first cut. Not saying they'll go anywhere, though. On a side note, where in the world is Subara? 4. Koneko is falling hard... 5. No Garupan...not huge surprise for me with ISML demographics... 6. Bottom line = no matter what, Tier 1 is clear (Asuna + KYH + Rikka + Eru + Shirakiin), Niku / Kobato / Yui / Kud / Rin after that. After that it's almost irrelevant. For Stella: 1. Kanade still trumps everyone as expected... 2. Then there's Eu, wherever her popularity comes from. Quite frankly, 3 years later and I still don't understand how a no-name in Eu is THIS popular. 3. But then, Sora is 9th...
__________________
|
2013-01-20, 19:19 | Link #63 | |
にこにこにー
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: 国立音ノ木坂学院
|
Quote:
As far as Stella v. Nova, larger pool, people not remembering girls, people not filling in the form correctly. Unfamiliarity do comes in, as much as ISML voter are already more hardcore viewers compare to your average "Watch maybe one or two each year, if even that" crowd. And to be fair, all the top girls for Nova don't have to be nominated. LB gain some strength (Kud lose to Rikka in exhibition anyway, while Rin to Mashiro), Karen-chan lose quite a bit (She got close to Ririchiyo-sama). Still surprise Koneko drop THIS much (She beat Karuta in a 3-way with Tsukihi...), I guess she's being forgotten?
__________________
|
|
2013-01-20, 19:23 | Link #65 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
|
I believe Stella had only 110 total representatives while only 73 could be nominated. Nova has more of a variety of choices not including the 20 that were auto qualified (although Nova and Stella auto reps had quite a few nominations anyway.)
Until I see otherwise, Rika is 1-0 against KYH (exhibition match), although Rika just happened to be facing Hime at the right time with her series current at the time, just like with Eu facing Ruri during Aquamarine last year with Zombie also current at the time of the match. And seeing how Suguha (SAO) did in nominations, I wouldn't be surprised if both her and Yui cause trouble either in the prelims or regular season.
__________________
Last edited by hinakatbklyn; 2013-01-21 at 00:29. |
2013-02-01, 14:54 | Link #67 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
|
Time to review the first group of matches. Picking potential candidates for regular season either phase 1 or later)
Spoiler for Nova Groups contenders:
For Stella, avoid last place to have a second chance Spoiler for Stella Group Contenders:
__________________
|
2013-02-03, 10:31 | Link #68 |
Mishaguji-sama
Join Date: Oct 2010
|
ARENA 01: Inaba Himeko Kaname Madoka Sakai Wakana Shimada Minami [Toshinō Kyōko] [Nōmi Kudryavka] Hasegawa Kobato
ARENA 02: [Watashi] Misaki Mei [Natsume Rin] Kashiwazaki Sena Matsumi Kuro Yūki Mikan Okita Sawa ARENA 03: Kotegawa Yui Kirigaya Suguha Kamikita Komari Tōjō Koneko [Tsuyuri Kumin] [Roromiya Karuta] Yuzuriha Inori ARENA 04: Kanzaki H. Aria Nibutani Shinka [Akaza Akari] Gasai Yuno Kurasaki Fūko (Sky Raker) Tomoe Mami [Aoyama Nanami] ARENA 05: [Tōwa Erio] Dekomori Sanae [Natsume Asako] Hanekawa Tsubasa Kusaribe Hakaze Sakura Kyōko Chitanda Eru ARENA 06: Lala Satalin Deviluke [Shiina Mayuri] Oda Nobuna Takanashi Tōka Shiina Mashiro [Mizutani Shizuku] Oshino Shinobu ARENA 07: [Nakano Azusa] Nishizawa Ayumu Takamachi Nanoha Sengoku Nadeko [Ichinose Kotomi] Iwasawa Masami Kawasumi Mai ARENA 08: [Furukawa Nagisa] Index L. Prohibitorum Sonozaki Mion Kinomoto Sakura Hinamori Amu [Nagato Yuki] Senjōgahara Hitagi ARENA 09: Ryōgi Shiki [Kamio Misuzu] [Yui] Charlotte Dunois Sanzen'in Nagi Aragaki Ayase Teletha Testarossa ARENA 10: C.C. Shana [Katsura Hinagiku] Chii Shinku Katagiri Yūhi [Kotobuki Tsumugi] ARENA 11: [Sawachika Eri] [Kōsaka Kirino] Ryūgū Rena Suiseiseki Nakamura Yuri Konjiki no Yami Nymph ARENA 12: Komori Kiri Ikaros Saber Kōzuki Kallen [Hiiragi Kagami] [Suzumiya Haruhi] Suigintō |
2013-02-03, 10:46 | Link #69 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
|
ARENA 01: Inaba Himeko Kaname Madoka Sakai Wakana Shimada Minami Toshinō Kyōko [Nōmi Kudryavka] [Hasegawa Kobato]
ARENA 02: [Watashi] Misaki Mei Natsume Rin Kashiwazaki Sena Matsumi Kuro [Yūki Mikan] Okita Sawa ARENA 03: Kotegawa Yui Kirigaya Suguha Kamikita Komari Tōjō Koneko Tsuyuri Kumin [Roromiya Karuta] [Yuzuriha Inori] ARENA 04: [Kanzaki H. Aria] Nibutani Shinka Akaza Akari Gasai Yuno Kurasaki Fūko (Sky Raker) [Tomoe Mami] Aoyama Nanami ARENA 05: [Tōwa Erio] [Dekomori Sanae] Natsume Asako Hanekawa Tsubasa Kusaribe Hakaze Sakura Kyōko Chitanda Eru ARENA 06: Lala Satalin Deviluke Shiina Mayuri [Oda Nobuna] Takanashi Tōka Shiina Mashiro Mizutani Shizuku [Oshino Shinobu] ARENA 07: Nakano Azusa Nishizawa Ayumu Takamachi Nanoha [Sengoku Nadeko] Ichinose Kotomi [Iwasawa Masami] Kawasumi Mai ARENA 08: Furukawa Nagisa Index L. Prohibitorum Sonozaki Mion Kinomoto Sakura [Hinamori Amu] [Nagato Yuki] Senjōgahara Hitagi ARENA 09: Ryōgi Shiki Kamio Misuzu Yui [Charlotte Dunois] [Sanzen'in Nagi] Aragaki Ayase Teletha Testarossa ARENA 10: C.C. Shana Katsura Hinagiku [Chii] [Shinku] Katagiri Yūhi Kotobuki Tsumugi ARENA 11: Sawachika Eri Kōsaka Kirino Ryūgū Rena [Suiseiseki] Nakamura Yuri [Konjiki no Yami] Nymph ARENA 12: [Komori Kiri] Ikaros [Saber] Kōzuki Kallen Hiiragi Kagami Suzumiya Haruhi Suigintō |
2013-02-03, 11:02 | Link #70 |
Kana Hanazawa ♥
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: France
Age: 37
|
ARENA 01: Inaba Himeko Kaname Madoka [Sakai Wakana] Shimada Minami Toshinō Kyōko Nōmi Kudryavka [Hasegawa Kobato]
ARENA 02: Watashi [Misaki Mei] Natsume Rin Kashiwazaki Sena Matsumi Kuro [Yūki Mikan] Okita Sawa ARENA 03: [Kotegawa Yui] Kirigaya Suguha Kamikita Komari [Tōjō Koneko] Tsuyuri Kumin Roromiya Karuta Yuzuriha Inori ARENA 04: Kanzaki H. Aria Nibutani Shinka [Akaza Akari] Gasai Yuno Kurasaki Fūko (Sky Raker) Tomoe Mami [Aoyama Nanami] ARENA 05: [Tōwa Erio] Dekomori Sanae [Natsume Asako] Hanekawa Tsubasa Kusaribe Hakaze Sakura Kyōko Chitanda Eru ARENA 06: Lala Satalin Deviluke Shiina Mayuri Oda Nobuna Takanashi Tōka Shiina Mashiro [Mizutani Shizuku] [Oshino Shinobu] ARENA 07: [Nakano Azusa] Nishizawa Ayumu Takamachi Nanoha [Sengoku Nadeko] Ichinose Kotomi Iwasawa Masami Kawasumi Mai ARENA 08: [Furukawa Nagisa] Index L. Prohibitorum Sonozaki Mion Kinomoto Sakura Hinamori Amu Nagato Yuki [Senjōgahara Hitagi] ARENA 09: Ryōgi Shiki Kamio Misuzu Yui [Charlotte Dunois] Sanzen'in Nagi Aragaki Ayase [Teletha Testarossa] ARENA 10: [C.C.] [Shana] Katsura Hinagiku Chii Shinku Katagiri Yūhi Kotobuki Tsumugi ARENA 11: [Sawachika Eri] Kōsaka Kirino Ryūgū Rena Suiseiseki Nakamura Yuri [Konjiki no Yami] Nymph ARENA 12: [Komori Kiri] Ikaros Saber Kōzuki Kallen Hiiragi Kagami [Suzumiya Haruhi] Suigintō
__________________
|
2013-02-03, 11:35 | Link #72 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Where the Sky Touches the Sea
Age: 31
|
ARENA 01: [[Inaba Himeko]] Kaname Madoka Sakai Wakana Shimada Minami Toshinō Kyōko [[Nōmi Kudryavka]] Hasegawa Kobato
ARENA 02: [[Watashi]] Misaki Mei [[Natsume Rin]] Kashiwazaki Sena Matsumi Kuro Yūki Mikan Okita Sawa ARENA 03: Kotegawa Yui Kirigaya Suguha Kamikita Komari Tōjō Koneko Tsuyuri Kumin [[Roromiya Karuta]] [[Yuzuriha Inori]] ARENA 04: Kanzaki H. Aria [[Nibutani Shinka]] Akaza Akari Gasai Yuno Kurasaki Fūko (Sky Raker) Tomoe Mami [[Aoyama Nanami]] ARENA 05: Tōwa Erio [[Dekomori Sanae]] Natsume Asako [[Hanekawa Tsubasa]] Kusaribe Hakaze Sakura Kyōko Chitanda Eru ARENA 06: Lala Satalin Deviluke [[Shiina Mayuri]] Oda Nobuna Takanashi Tōka Shiina Mashiro [[Mizutani Shizuku]] Oshino Shinobu ARENA 07: Nakano Azusa Nishizawa Ayumu Takamachi Nanoha [[Sengoku Nadeko]] [[Ichinose Kotomi]] Iwasawa Masami Kawasumi Mai ARENA 08: Furukawa Nagisa Index L. Prohibitorum Sonozaki Mion Kinomoto Sakura Hinamori Amu [[Nagato Yuki]] [[Senjōgahara Hitagi]] ARENA 09: Ryōgi Shiki Kamio Misuzu [[Yui]] Charlotte Dunois Sanzen'in Nagi [[Aragaki Ayase]] Teletha Testarossa ARENA 10: [[C.C.]] [[Shana]] Katsura Hinagiku Chii Shinku Katagiri Yūhi Kotobuki Tsumugi ARENA 11: Sawachika Eri [[Kōsaka Kirino]] Ryūgū Rena Suiseiseki [[Nakamura Yuri]] Konjiki no Yami Nymph ARENA 12: Komori Kiri Ikaros [[Saber]] Kōzuki Kallen Hiiragi Kagami [[Suzumiya Haruhi]] Suigintō
__________________
|
2013-02-03, 11:38 | Link #73 |
┌(^o^)┘モリ!┌(^o^)┘モリ!
Join Date: Sep 2010
|
ARENA 01: [Inaba Himeko] Kaname Madoka Sakai Wakana Shimada Minami [Toshinō Kyōko] Nōmi Kudryavka Hasegawa Kobato
ARENA 02: [Watashi] Misaki Mei [Natsume Rin] Kashiwazaki Sena Matsumi Kuro Yūki Mikan Okita Sawa ARENA 03: Kotegawa Yui Kirigaya Suguha Kamikita Komari Tōjō Koneko [Tsuyuri Kumin] [Roromiya Karuta] Yuzuriha Inori ARENA 04: Kanzaki H. Aria [Nibutani Shinka] [Akaza Akari] Gasai Yuno Kurasaki Fūko (Sky Raker) Tomoe Mami Aoyama Nanami ARENA 05: [Tōwa Erio] [Dekomori Sanae] Natsume Asako Hanekawa Tsubasa Kusaribe Hakaze Sakura Kyōko Chitanda Eru ARENA 06: Lala Satalin Deviluke Shiina Mayuri Oda Nobuna [Takanashi Tōka] Shiina Mashiro Mizutani Shizuku [Oshino Shinobu] ARENA 07: Nakano Azusa [Nishizawa Ayumu] Takamachi Nanoha Sengoku Nadeko Ichinose Kotomi [Iwasawa Masami] Kawasumi Mai ARENA 08: Furukawa Nagisa Index L. Prohibitorum Sonozaki Mion [Kinomoto Sakura] [Hinamori Amu] Nagato Yuki Senjōgahara Hitagi ARENA 09: Ryōgi Shiki Kamio Misuzu Yui Charlotte Dunois [Sanzen'in Nagi] Aragaki Ayase [Teletha Testarossa] ARENA 10: C.C. [Shana] [Katsura Hinagiku] Chii Shinku Katagiri Yūhi Kotobuki Tsumugi ARENA 11: Sawachika Eri Kōsaka Kirino [Ryūgū Rena] [Suiseiseki] Nakamura Yuri Konjiki no Yami Nymph ARENA 12: [Komori Kiri] Ikaros Saber Kōzuki Kallen Hiiragi Kagami Suzumiya Haruhi [Suigintō] |
2013-02-03, 12:18 | Link #74 |
Senior Member
Author
|
I have misgivings with doing this for another year, but I'll see how it goes for a little while at least.
Arenas 1, 4, and 8 were tough. With Arena 4, Mami was my clear favorite, but there were a few other girls in it that I liked about equally for "2nd Choice", so I just voted for Mami here. With Arena 8, there are 4 girls in it that I like about equally well, so I voted for the 2 of them that I felt needed the votes the most. In Arena 1, I just made a tough call, sorry Wakana and Kud. ARENA 01: [Inaba Himeko] [Kaname Madoka] Sakai Wakana Shimada Minami Toshinō Kyōko Nōmi Kudryavka Hasegawa Kobato ARENA 02: Watashi Misaki Mei [Natsume Rin] Kashiwazaki Sena Matsumi Kuro Yūki Mikan [Okita Sawa] ARENA 03: Kotegawa Yui Kirigaya Suguha [Kamikita Komari] Tōjō Koneko [Tsuyuri Kumin] Roromiya Karuta Yuzuriha Inori ARENA 04: Kanzaki H. Aria Nibutani Shinka Akaza Akari Gasai Yuno Kurasaki Fūko (Sky Raker) [Tomoe Mami] Aoyama Nanami ARENA 05: Tōwa Erio Dekomori Sanae Natsume Asako Hanekawa Tsubasa Kusaribe Hakaze [Sakura Kyōko] [Chitanda Eru] ARENA 06: Lala Satalin Deviluke [Shiina Mayuri] Oda Nobuna Takanashi Tōka [Shiina Mashiro] Mizutani Shizuku Oshino Shinobu ARENA 07: Nakano Azusa Nishizawa Ayumu [Takamachi Nanoha] Sengoku Nadeko [Ichinose Kotomi] Iwasawa Masami Kawasumi Mai ARENA 08: [Furukawa Nagisa] Index L. Prohibitorum Sonozaki Mion [Kinomoto Sakura] Hinamori Amu Nagato Yuki Senjōgahara Hitagi ARENA 09: Ryōgi Shiki Kamio Misuzu [Yui] [Charlotte Dunois] Sanzen'in Nagi Aragaki Ayase Teletha Testarossa ARENA 10: C.C. [Shana] Katsura Hinagiku Chii Shinku Katagiri Yūhi [Kotobuki Tsumugi] ARENA 11: Sawachika Eri Kōsaka Kirino Ryūgū Rena [Suiseiseki] [Nakamura Yuri] Konjiki no Yami Nymph ARENA 12: Komori Kiri Ikaros [Saber] Kōzuki Kallen Hiiragi Kagami [Suzumiya Haruhi] Suigintō
__________________
|
2013-02-03, 13:38 | Link #75 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2009
|
Quite a few matches where I had to pass on one or two favorites for another.
ARENA 01: Inaba Himeko Kaname Madoka Sakai Wakana [Shimada Minami] Toshinō Kyōko Nōmi Kudryavka [Hasegawa Kobato] ARENA 02: Watashi Misaki Mei Natsume Rin Kashiwazaki Sena [Matsumi Kuro] [Yūki Mikan] Okita Sawa ARENA 03: Kotegawa Yui [Kirigaya Suguha] Kamikita Komari Tōjō Koneko Tsuyuri Kumin [Roromiya Karuta] Yuzuriha Inori ARENA 04: Kanzaki H. Aria Nibutani Shinka Akaza Akari Gasai Yuno [Kurasaki Fūko (Sky Raker)] Tomoe Mami [Aoyama Nanami] ARENA 05: Tōwa Erio Dekomori Sanae Natsume Asako [Hanekawa Tsubasa] Kusaribe Hakaze Sakura Kyōko [Chitanda Eru] ARENA 06: Lala Satalin Deviluke [Shiina Mayuri] Oda Nobuna Takanashi Tōka [Shiina Mashiro] Mizutani Shizuku Oshino Shinobu (* Double Shiina) ARENA 07: [Nakano Azusa] Nishizawa Ayumu Takamachi Nanoha [Sengoku Nadeko] Ichinose Kotomi Iwasawa Masami Kawasumi Mai ARENA 08: Furukawa Nagisa [Index L. Prohibitorum] Sonozaki Mion [Kinomoto Sakura] Hinamori Amu Nagato Yuki Senjōgahara Hitagi ARENA 09: Ryōgi Shiki Kamio Misuzu [Yui] [Charlotte Dunois] Sanzen'in Nagi Aragaki Ayase Teletha Testarossa ARENA 10: C.C. Shana [Katsura Hinagiku] Chii Shinku [Katagiri Yūhi] Kotobuki Tsumugi (* One of the few time I don't have to second guess on votes) ARENA 11: [Sawachika Eri] Kōsaka Kirino Ryūgū Rena Suiseiseki [Nakamura Yuri] Konjiki no Yami Nymph (* Too many to choose from. But I wouldn't miss an opportunity to vote for Eri) ARENA 12: Komori Kiri Ikaros Saber Kōzuki Kallen [Hiiragi Kagami] [Suzumiya Haruhi] Suigintō
__________________
|
2013-02-03, 14:36 | Link #77 |
One PUNCH!
Administrator
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
ARENA 01: Inaba Himeko Kaname Madoka Sakai Wakana Shimada Minami [Toshinō Kyōko] Nōmi Kudryavka [Hasegawa Kobato]
ARENA 02: Watashi Misaki Mei [Natsume Rin] [Kashiwazaki Sena] Matsumi Kuro Yūki Mikan Okita Sawa ARENA 03: [Kotegawa Yui] Kirigaya Suguha Kamikita Komari Tōjō Koneko [Tsuyuri Kumin] Roromiya Karuta Yuzuriha Inori ARENA 04: Kanzaki H. Aria [Nibutani Shinka] Akaza Akari Gasai Yuno Kurasaki Fūko (Sky Raker) Tomoe Mami [Aoyama Nanami] ARENA 05: Tōwa Erio [Dekomori Sanae] Natsume Asako Hanekawa Tsubasa Kusaribe Hakaze Sakura Kyōko [Chitanda Eru] ARENA 06: Lala Satalin Deviluke Shiina Mayuri Oda Nobuna [Takanashi Tōka] [Shiina Mashiro] Mizutani Shizuku Oshino Shinobu ARENA 07: [Nakano Azusa] Nishizawa Ayumu Takamachi Nanoha Sengoku Nadeko Ichinose Kotomi Iwasawa Masami [Kawasumi Mai] ARENA 08: [Furukawa Nagisa] Index L. Prohibitorum Sonozaki Mion Kinomoto Sakura Hinamori Amu Nagato Yuki [Senjōgahara Hitagi] ARENA 09: Ryōgi Shiki [Kamio Misuzu] Yui Charlotte Dunois Sanzen'in Nagi [Aragaki Ayase] Teletha Testarossa ARENA 10: C.C. Shana [Katsura Hinagiku] Chii Shinku [Katagiri Yūhi] Kotobuki Tsumugi ARENA 11: Sawachika Eri [Kōsaka Kirino] [Ryūgū Rena] Suiseiseki Nakamura Yuri Konjiki no Yami Nymph ARENA 12: Komori Kiri Ikaros Saber Kōzuki Kallen [Hiiragi Kagami] [Suzumiya Haruhi] Suigintō |
2013-02-03, 14:43 | Link #78 |
He Without a Title
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: The land of tempura
|
Spoiler for Votes:
Damn, there were some really tough calls over there starting right with Arena 01 where I had to drop Madoka to give my votes to two lovely 2D ladies who I feel just might not have enough moe power to carry through on their own strength. Arena 03 on the other hand had me struggling. 4 really cringe worthy choices for me and only one really interesting one. And right next I had to drop Shinka to give my vote to my favourite Yandere of the year (Yuno). Then Arena 07 just had to make me not vote for Kotomi-chan nor Mai-chan. Azunyan is just too damn cute not to vote for and with the completely criminal levels of moe of Nadeko-chan my votes were set. And then a three way match between Yuki, Nagisa-chan and Senjogahara-sama? Are you trying to kill me here? At least I managed to drop a vote for Mugi-chan in there. Playing so much Houkago Live lately has really made me realize how cute she can be. Damn you Sega!
__________________
|
2013-02-03, 14:49 | Link #79 |
User of the "Fast Draw"
|
ARENA 01: Inaba Himeko Kaname Madoka Sakai Wakana [Shimada Minami] [Toshinō Kyōko] Nōmi Kudryavka Hasegawa Kobato
ARENA 02: Watashi Misaki Mei Natsume Rin [Kashiwazaki Sena] Matsumi Kuro [Yūki Mikan] Okita Sawa ARENA 03: Kotegawa Yui [Kirigaya Suguha] Kamikita Komari [Tōjō Koneko] Tsuyuri Kumin Roromiya Karuta Yuzuriha Inori ARENA 04: [Kanzaki H. Aria] Nibutani Shinka Akaza Akari Gasai Yuno Kurasaki Fūko (Sky Raker) Tomoe Mami [Aoyama Nanami] ARENA 05: Tōwa Erio Dekomori Sanae Natsume Asako Hanekawa Tsubasa [Kusaribe Hakaze] Sakura Kyōko [Chitanda Eru] ARENA 06: [Lala Satalin Deviluke] Shiina Mayuri Oda Nobuna Takanashi Tōka [Shiina Mashiro] Mizutani Shizuku Oshino Shinobu ARENA 07: Nakano Azusa Nishizawa Ayumu [Takamachi Nanoha] Sengoku Nadeko Ichinose Kotomi [Iwasawa Masami] Kawasumi Mai ARENA 08: Furukawa Nagisa Index L. Prohibitorum Sonozaki Mion [Kinomoto Sakura] [Hinamori Amu] Nagato Yuki Senjōgahara Hitagi ARENA 09: Ryōgi Shiki Kamio Misuzu Yui [Charlotte Dunois] Sanzen'in Nagi Aragaki Ayase [Teletha Testarossa] ARENA 10: [C.C.] [Shana] Katsura Hinagiku Chii Shinku Katagiri Yūhi Kotobuki Tsumugi ARENA 11: Sawachika Eri Kōsaka Kirino [Ryūgū Rena] Suiseiseki Nakamura Yuri Konjiki no Yami [Nymph] ARENA 12: Komori Kiri [Ikaros] Saber Kōzuki Kallen Hiiragi Kagami Suzumiya Haruhi [Suigintō] Well some of those were fairly tough. Though naturally an equal amount where I thought for a good amount of time. Only a couple where I thought "god I can't pick three!?"
__________________
|
Tags |
isml, saimoe |
|
|