2007-11-19, 20:33 | Link #881 | |||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
Yuri = Love/Romance between girls. You were complaining about the yuri on strikers so I told you that adding yuri don’t means removing the plot, and I gave you good examples. No one was talking about romance in strikers. And isn’t fanservice, is plot, because it’s transcendental for the history. Quote:
Quote:
I accept StrikerS as the crappy series it is. Quote:
Quote:
Yeah, nothing happened in that bed… nothing happened at all… they just slept on it… because the beds are used for sleep... yeah, only for that... You really believe that? If you don’t know Japanese you can read any of the many translation of that track, in hongfire there is one translated line by line. Is always better to read something translated by people who actually know the lenguage than inventing your own ideas of what was going on the track, Chaos-chan Quote:
I always look for plot in the series I watch, that’s the principal factor that will define if I will follow it or not. Please stop making such declarations if you don’t know the subject. Saludos, Haru |
|||||||
2007-11-19, 21:44 | Link #882 |
Random Translator
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: New Brunswick
|
I have a wondrous proposal! We should set up an off site forum where the members of the animesuki nanoha forum may blast away at each other for their respective ships! (pun intended)
On one side Fate/Nanoha, the other anti-Fate/Nanoha and finally a faction that doesn't care about shipping but likes to watch the flame war get almost as heated as fujoshi shipping hatefest! Let the best navy triumph! No but seriously, so much hate people. I much rather talk about my favorite pairing Signum/Fate rather than hear you guys argue again about whether Fate/Nanoha is real or not. Remember the MST3000 slogan: it's only a show, I really should just relax.
__________________
|
2007-11-19, 22:28 | Link #883 | |
Blazing General
Join Date: May 2006
Location: CA
Age: 38
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2007-11-19, 22:53 | Link #884 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2006
Age: 38
|
@Chaos: By now we should already understand that the ones who support the series' merits(in their eyes) take strong hints and eat them up, since they are already sick and tired of the producers not expressly showing it. We don't decide the income of the producers, they(those bloggers I've looked at) do. So I guess we don't have much of a point trying to convince them, prove them wrong, when all it does is to cut the supply of big bucks to the producers.
Guess it's somewhat like GSD, where flaming about the series continues, but the makers just play Jerry Maguire in the office. This is how I see StS's performance. @Kikaifan: Well we don't know whether that site(it's a webring I presume) is representative of the part of the Japanese blogosphere posting about StS, or about NxF, so meh. [There are so many sites not using unicode!!!] @BPHaru: Regarding that bed statement, any and all intimate activity in a military installation is liable for at least a court-martial. This is definite, everywhere. [If I'm reading your implication correctly that is, I apologize if I'm not] |
2007-11-19, 23:06 | Link #886 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
And remember who is their superior, Hayate, so there is no problem with that kind of issues xD You should read more doujins and fics Saludos, Haru |
||
2007-11-20, 00:19 | Link #889 | |
The Asian who's Malaysian
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: B.C. Vancouver
|
Quote:
@Nagumo who do you think would be the "male" role in the relationship with Signum/Fate. My opinion Signum would be the "male" role in the relationship. Sorry if this was discussed before.
__________________
|
|
2007-11-20, 00:30 | Link #890 | |||||||||
物語は、もう、おしまい……?
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: In the Horizon
Age: 43
|
Quote:
I mentioned that in my previous posts that romance is not needed in StrikerS if we are to stick the Vivio-as-Sei-Ou plot. The most important factor here is a close bond between Nanoha and Vivio, aka a pure mother-daughter relationship. Including anyone (Fate, Yuuno, Vita, Subaru, whoever) else into that relationship is imho redundant, and it weakens the impact. Quote:
Quote:
What's wrong with her just being a family friend? It works just as well, if not better. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I'm sorry that you only see more training time to fill up the space that was rudely robbed by meaningless hints. What I mean by "precious plot development" is something like these: Spoiler for How to rewrite StrikerS: Example 1:
Spoiler for How to rewrite StrikerS: Example 2:
While you're at it, I suggest you read that entire thread as well, since it contains a good discussion on how to improve your StrikerS. Without the fluff. Quote:
Quote:
And while we're at that, I would say, speaking from first-hand experience, sleeping with just your undergarments is a very bad idea when your unit is supposed to be on the ball 24/7. Not to mention it helps you catch a cold much easily. Quote:
Hmm... Though fanning the hate is fun, I think I'll prescribe to Nagumo's suggestion. And yeah, Signum-Fate is fun to watch, I would say . Especially if it's done like in the manga. @Nightengale: Would changing language settings or using appocale help? @narmi: Imho Signum should be the guy. Unless she goes dere-dere .
__________________
|
|||||||||
2007-11-20, 02:40 | Link #892 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2006
Age: 38
|
Quote:
Sigh the doujins and fics I'm supposed to read goes against real world logic in terms of military administration. Amirite, arkhangelsk? Suspension of disbelief ENERUGI ZENKAI *back to real world* If anything, THAT is one area that Regius could find fault in when he was conducting the investigation... ----------------------- Regius is still peeved from finding out that an SS-class mage existed in RF6. Auris: We've found out that two of their senior officers with the potential for a romantic relationship share a room! Regius: Time to invoke Da Rulez muahahaha Quote:
@thread: Awww, no love for Vinoha? *Makes hamster nest in the corner of the room* @Nighty & Estavali: Well changing your backslash to the yen sign is the only way out I can think of, sorry. @FRS: At least civility is conserved in this one. |
||
2007-11-20, 03:46 | Link #893 |
Lurker on the threshold
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: France
Age: 47
|
Yes but ships wars are one of the best way to sour the ambiance of a forum, the sad thing is that i dont think we can go back to the cohexistence/ignore others phase we are deep into the "one true way" phase.
|
2007-11-20, 04:35 | Link #894 | ||
Adeptus Animus
Author
Join Date: Jan 2007
Age: 36
|
Quote:
Quote:
If doujins and fics ruled the animeverse, then Naruto and Sasuke would be madly in love by now. And lets not get started on shows like Gundam Seed or heavens forbid Code Geass. *raises hand* I care... |
||
2007-11-20, 06:14 | Link #895 | ||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2006
|
Quote:
There is no reason to maintain such archaic rules in an advanced world like theirs. Quote:
I said that since chaos-chan made the contrast between anime involving a good plot and anime with romance, and I was telling him that those 2 genres are not exclusive, indeed. That way an anime where romance is the main element, like Nana would be the better example for this case, since it has a very well written plot. And BTW in most of the KEY novels romance is not the centre of their plot, but drama and the problems of the girls, just look at for example Air. Quote:
Also if you remove yuri from StrikerS, you left nothing on the series, and you could say good bye to most part of the ratability if this franchise, so don’t even think about it, the problem here is the plot, not the genre. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
There is nothing to discuss about it, listen to it again, my friend, It was supposed to be the Yuuno track, but suddenly instead of develop his relation with Nanoha in her bad moments he started telling her friend that Fate-chan care for her, and Nanoha was all happy Quote:
People here has given the same pointless example countless times before, is not the same to sleep that way occasionally for necessities than doing it daily by the decision of the two involved parts. Quote:
I’m not stupid enough yet to confuse canon with fan made universes, I only said that to have a more open mind of possible scenarios for the series. Saludos, Haru |
||||||||
2007-11-20, 06:27 | Link #896 | ||||||||||||||
We're Back
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Redgrave City
Age: 35
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
There is almost no chance of anyone posting the same comment in 100 blogs. But without a doubt, a large number of people would post in maybe 2-3 blogs minimum? And within that group, you have people that visits different combinations of blogs. Quote:
My very first statement as posted here was in response to your earlier post which seems to support the studio for putting more yuri fanservice to ‘appeal’ to more yuri fans. Quote:
Simplification: "Sacrificing plot for fanservice of any kind, yuri or otherwise, is a stupid and horrible idea." But somehow or another, you read it as "Sacrificing plot for Romance of any kind, yuri or otherwise, is a stupid and horrible idea." Quote:
After which, I tried to get you back on track... Quote:
Simplification: "Fanservice NOT equal Romance development. PERIOD. Nobody should be satisfied like that" And now... Now I have this in front of me. Quote:
NO. I was complaining about Yuri FANSERVICE on StrikerS, because there's hardly any other kind of fanservice! NO. You said ROMANCE. Which then I pointed, THERE ISN'T ANY! Yes. YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT IT ! Quote:
History will remember Nanoha as the Coolest Magical girl show turn just another yuri series. Quote:
Hey, I'm talking about normal people here. Quote:
1. Nanoha and Fate are not married. 2. Nanoha, Yuuno and Fate are all good friends. 3. Due to a lack of evidence, no one can truely determine if Nanoha and Fate did anything unmentionable in bed. 4. Fate-mama had not contributed anything important and irreplacable for Vivio. 5. Nanoha and Fate's relationship had not made progess in any direction, not even for one bit. ...And this is just for starters. Quote:
... In the physical plane, not the imaginary line. ... Saying random lines doesn't mean you have a point you know... Quote:
Nonexisting evidence is nonexisting. Quote:
I'm very sure Nagumo or Thisguy wouldn't mind... And they have the reputation as well. EDIT: Nevermind, off-topicness that would definitely be nuked.
__________________
Last edited by Chaos2Frozen; 2007-11-20 at 06:51. |
||||||||||||||
2007-11-20, 06:43 | Link #898 | ||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Gaf's Room
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Dere-dere Signum = DOES NOT COMPUTE Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||||||
|
|