2018-05-11, 16:37 | Link #87 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2012
|
Quote:
This chapter...you need to see it to explain it, at least Aragaki burried the hatchet and now we're coming the highway to megalonia. |
|
2018-05-13, 07:11 | Link #90 |
Me, An Intellectual
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: UK
Age: 33
|
I wasn't much of fan of this arc. I think the whole idea of Nanbu being at fault because he decided to believe a news report was a bit lacking. The whole root of the problem didn't seem to make a whole lot of sense really.
I think it would've been far better if Aragaki had managed to return to Nanbu after the war but ultimately Nanbu decides to give up on Aragaki early when he sees the limitations of Aragaki's prosthetic legs (and the further damage it could do to Aragaki if he continued). That kind of parting would've had a lot more weight to it and would've made a lot more sense imo. Aragaki's grudge and feeling of betrayal would've felt a lot more justified and it would've explained Nanbu's descent to a scummy match fixer. The match would've also forced them to see each others viewpoints better what with Nanbu's giving up attitude being on full display with Joe, and Aragaki ultimately realising that Nanbu was right about his prosthetic legs holding him back. That said, I think the fight between Aragaki and Joe was still a pretty great spectacle in its own right. They both need to follow through with their punches more though.
__________________
|
2018-05-13, 17:56 | Link #91 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
|
That was my problem with this arc as well, or rather, Nanbu's role in the story in general. I mean... Aragaki was reported as dead and Nanbu had zero reasons not to trust that report. Aragaki was a soldier, he went to fight in a war, there was nothing weird about him dying in that war. And then Aragaki comes back and is distraught to find his "home" aka Nanbu's gym closed and abandoned, and that is somehow on Nanbu, because... how dare he ruin his business when unbeknownst to him Aragaki is still out there?
I think the story piled waaayyy too much responsibility on Nanbu without giving enough justification for it. They want us to buy that they had a close, almost father-son like relationship, and we got a strong sense how Aragaki viewed Nanbu and boxing as his only emotional crutch. But we never really saw the full extent of what made this relationship so strong for Nanbu - what we did see wasn't exactly convincing me that it was the kind of relationship where he'd basically dedicate his life to Aragaki to the point where losing Aragaki made Nanbu lose his way. And I'd have been fine with it if it was treated as an unhealthy attachment/unreasonable expectations on Aragaki's part, but the story kept suggesting that Nanbu was at fault for giving up on Aragaki. And I wasn't really buying that, actually I'm not sure I would even with an extended version of the story to play out. For these two to have this sort of codependent relationship I think there needs to be an entire gaiden on its own that explains what Aragaki was to Nanbu and more importantly why. ...or, more realistically, they should have just written a more believable scenario for Aragaki to be justified in feeling betrayed and abandoned, and Nanbu to feel at least somewhat realistically guilty about it. I mean hey, maybe Nanbu did actually just forget about him. Or maybe Nanbu knew that he survived, went to visit him, looked at his missing legs, and never returned. And so on, so many possibilities. (Although I think that just because a person holds you dear it doesn't make you obligated to hold that person dear. I think this story might have overall worked better if they didn't try to turn it into an angsty Nanbu backstory as well, and just had Aragaki be unreasonably angry over Nanbu seemingly betraying him.) That said, the Aragaki side of the story and the Aragaki vs Joe part were really great, and I loved the end with Aragaki accepting that he needs to move on with his life instead of (quite literally) tearing himself apart over the past. Last edited by kuromitsu; 2018-05-13 at 18:20. |
2018-05-13, 20:21 | Link #92 | |
Waiting for more taiyuki!
Join Date: Jan 2004
|
Quote:
2 episodes was enough for me.
__________________
|
|
2018-05-17, 14:17 | Link #94 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2012
|
Part of me was tell me that optimist would backfire but what Mikio do was low, heck he feared that much Joe and his onee-sama? Damn at least give the chance duke it out in the ring, at least he would have been a more sore loser.
Hope next week we've that deadline of a dream, the last chance... |
2018-05-17, 15:26 | Link #95 |
Corrupted fool
Join Date: Nov 2012
Location: I'm everywhere
Age: 33
|
Damn, that cliffhanger. I doubt Joe can fit into the door like Sonic but now I wanna know if he will try to do something :X
Also, about Joe's wounds, was there a brief timeskip to heal them all? I think he could get chronic traumatic encephalopathy similar to the original Joe based on previous fights. |
2018-05-17, 16:58 | Link #97 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Somewhere on Earth
|
They did a neat job at getting me hyped for Joe's match but then the ending happened....
I feel really bad for Joe tbh. The boxing world is already a tough place but that made it much worse, especially for him. I'd love to see him step into the ring again and prove everyone in the world what he is capable of. To see a match end that way...ouch.
__________________
|
2018-05-17, 17:51 | Link #99 |
New Age Badass
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Charlotte, NC
|
Joe popularity might be the key for next week because currently he's the people champion and the masses want him in Megalo Mania. That dick blackmailing will come back to bite because people might talk and call him a lair.
__________________
|
Tags |
boxing, sports |
|
|