2013-01-19, 21:49 | Link #11681 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Somewhere
|
@Clarste Who says they're meaningless victories? I admittedly have to revise my perspective a bit. Zenkichi's fights have never really been about sheer power or amazing abilities.(mentioning those fights was more in response to Guernsey's comment about him getting stomped all the time).
I remember you making a similar post about this on tv tropes, but Zenkichi, despite not being the main victory still has an important role in the support. Perhaps I'm just looking at his same contributions optimistically. Yes, you can look upon the Medaka II instance as morally ambiguous, but without improving upon the character which was there for nearly half the series, it's a meaningless victory. Medaka's character(influeced by Zenkichi's childish ideals) goes through an arc where the students gradually don't need to rely on her. It's not that Medaka was completely wrong(that's why Zenkichi wanted to point out the "too right"). We've got people who think Zenkichi's role is too small, that he's too weak, others who feel that is precisely his role in commentary. |
2013-01-20, 14:49 | Link #11682 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2012
|
Zen a great character who has human motivation.
He naturally can not be idiotic protagonist "Shounen manga". He did not come to save the world, and something like that. The perfect hero "Shounen manga" - Iihiko. Or rather parody to main character. I believe in the idea of the manga, Zen must now save Medaka-chan. Not because it is important to save the world or another idiocy. And because he needs to save a girlfriend (Medaka) and friend (Shiranui). |
2013-01-20, 16:02 | Link #11683 |
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2012
|
You do know that this is basically a run-down of, mostly, with some disagreements here and there, of how I view his character, right?
And yet, on what contention those any of this mean that Zenkichi has lived a life of pointless accomplishments, like Clarste is stating? I also directly said that he gave-up all the privileges of main-characterization, so I agree on that point. I don't expect Zenkichi to be an overpowered badass who saves the day, I don't expect him to hog all the screen-time, and I don't expect him to be a hero. You're misunderstanding. It's not that people want Zenkichi to take-up the flak. It's that people want Medaka gone. Why? Well, because she's boring, life-less and extremely annoying. And yet, even in an alledged Devil Style world, she's still the main-character, and main-characters still exist, and that's something which people didn't want. That's the inconsistancy from the Flask Plan Arc that fans hate, and leads tons of people(from what I've seen) to think that Shiranui simply ate Devil Style into a skill that "literally does nothing at all". And, it's true, Nishio can't fully escape the concept of a main character, even if he metaphiscally does so in the story, because in the end, Medaka Box still falls into tropes, despite it's alleged deconstruction of them. And yet, nothing of this bears anything on the thought of Zenkichi being a character of meaningless victories. I don't think you can, or should, definite him by victories, like you do Medaka or Kumagawa, because he's not really about that, unlike them.
__________________
Last edited by Wolfenstein; 2013-01-20 at 16:20. |
2013-01-20, 16:27 | Link #11685 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2012
|
Quote:
~~ I'd also like to add that, while me, and several others thought and hoped that Zenkichi would take up the flak, for the possibility of substituting God-awful Medaka, and because Anshin'san described the guy as the type of new-world main character the manga would have(i.e not aided by the fickle hand of fate) the main motivation for wanting the dude as main-character wasn't about that(well, it was about Medaka, but...). It's simply that people like the character, and he seems(still does) to be the logical choice to follow around in new, less dangerous, less grand adventures(maybe ones that focus more on the characters) - because people like that human side. So, you see, it's a blend of both Anshin'san's words, and Medaka's terribleness, in the end. And, honestly, neither are truly bad reasons for wanting the manga to have followed something different after 140. Hell, we thought it did, at first. The Student Council going on a rescue mission, everyone getting character development and screen-time in fights. That is, until Medaka showed-up, and just did her usual routine(trump everyone effortlessly - Medaka style!).
__________________
|
|
2013-01-20, 17:05 | Link #11687 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2007
Age: 35
|
Quote:
The only exception to this was the conclusion to the Not Equals arc (which you brought up). But things like that entire period in the Jet-Black Wedding arc which followed him eventually fell back into the original pattern. The point is that this is entirely correct/natural because Zenkichi basically made a decision which by definition devotes himself to that pattern. Quote:
In any case, I have no interest in completely subjective complaints about Medaka being lifeless or "boring". Thematically, from a literary or storytelling perspective about what Medaka Box ultimately wants to say, Medaka has as much significance as any other character in the story, period. (Since when is using tropes or narrative conventions wrong in the first place? No matter what, it would be completely retarded for any story to try to be a deconstruction of everything. Besides that, simply criticizing random storytelling tropes as if to say "this isn't totally accurate" is completely pointless if you don't actually have something new to say in place of it. Medaka Box has been very consistent about the tropes it actually intends to deconstruct. Complaining that "oh, it still uses tropes in other places" is completely dumb and doesn't say anything.) Quote:
|
|||
2013-01-20, 17:25 | Link #11688 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2009
|
There we go again with the Medaka hate. Geez, you guys are hopeless...
And to who said Shiranui ate Zen's Devil Style, think about that twice and try to discern what's wrong with that statement of yours. Devil Style, in case you still haven't noticed, killed Medaka. |
2013-01-20, 18:18 | Link #11690 | |||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2012
|
Quote:
Zenkichi's victories were never supposed to be the climax of any arc(save the one), and I fail to see why you think the way you do, other than a gross over-analysis of the story, but hey, it's your opinion to have. I can respect it. Quote:
Instead, a relatively normal thing happened(one with a much higher probability). And this unnamed arch-enemy hasn't even met Zenkichi or Medaka yet because of the skill. What I mean is, Devil Style's barriers are rather ambiguous, because it's definition is, too. Not going to say I'm right or you're wrong, but I got a different vibe from it's exposition. One must remember Anshin'san's wording, after all. "(...)My new world(...)" Quote:
Quote:
Pre-Defeat Medaka: A pompous, self-absorbed, generally just unlikeable Mary Sue. Post-Defeat Medaka: A pompous, self-absorbed, generally just unlikeable Mary Sue. I honestly fail to see the point of Nishio's deconstruction of her Mary-Sueness to just repeat the same arc. Quote:
Personally I think it's a rather depressing and cynical way to view the acheivements of a character, and again, I have no understanding of how you reached this conclusion reading the manga, but no-one is alike in this world, there'll always be disagreements. Quote:
I mean, have you seen other Medaka Box forums? There was practically a world-wide celebration by the fans when Medaka's nre Box became a coffin. Quote:
And I agree, that's a theory. Albeit, an unlikely one. I think Anshin' offered a much better explanation to the dilemma of "Hero vs Hero".
__________________
|
|||||||
2013-01-20, 18:48 | Link #11691 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2009
|
Quote:
To do that is fine, but I don't see any need to remind us constantly how much you dislike her. But this is probably because I don't dislike any character in this series. |
|
2013-01-20, 21:53 | Link #11692 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2007
Age: 35
|
Quote:
The point is not necessarily that Zenkichi's achievements have no meaning. However, one thing that is true about Medaka Box's narrative is that Nishio tends to tell the story as if Zenkichi is a main or important character (or that he did something important), only later to reveal that he isn't/didn't really. This is the main point to be made. Medaka Box/Nishio has a habit of pretending that Zenkichi is more impressive or important than he really is (and then deliberately bringing the story/readers back to reality). Quote:
Also, the result "the performers with the most professional mindset appeared" isn't in itself something that actually has high probability. In fact, if you just picked a bunch of performers at random from a list like Medaka did, normally you would just get a bunch of average performers. It was hinted (more like, Zenkichi directly stated) that it was because it was Medaka picking them that she got the most highly skilled performers which made a huge success for the school cultural festival. So in this sense, it's pretty clear that Devil Style did not interfere with Medaka's goals for the school festival (i.e. "have a highly enjoyable festival which makes the most people happy", I guess). I'm not sure what Ajimu exactly meant by saying that running into a long lost brother or archenemy "might" have happened, but I think that, if Zenkichi had been given traditional main character powers, those coincidences would have turned out in favour of Zenkichi. Like I dunno, that archenemy could've ended up seriously injuring/disabling Medaka, or awakening her dark side or something, thus giving Zenkichi an advantage in the elections. That might've been the idea. In any case, the fact that Devil Style didn't effect Medaka's luck in causing her to draw the three most famous entertainment performers does pretty blatantly portray that Devil Style does not universally disable main character powers. Well, if this was not made clear enough by the continuing story from that point onwards anyway. So my main point, that there has never really been a reason to stop assuming Medaka is the main character, is still there. Quote:
However, in the first place, Medaka was never a Mary Sue so she could be deconstructed. Rather, her Mary-Sueness is the deconstruction. By being a Mary Sue, Medaka deconstructs the shounen manga illusion that victory is about anything besides (main character) power. Ideals, effort, determination; none of that actually matters. It is the sheer injustice of simply being a main character, which grants you victory. But beyond that, the story has long moved past the point of just harping about main characters. The entire "main characters == always win" theme was already finished by the end of Kumagawa's battle with her. At the present stage, Nishio is exploring the concepts of Ajimu--a being who is above main characters by being aware of Medaka Box as just a manga universe--and Iihiko, a being who is higher still. |
|||
2013-01-21, 03:32 | Link #11693 |
Human
Join Date: Aug 2004
Age: 38
|
For the record, I'm pretty sure the long-lost archenemy who failed to appear at the school festival was referring to Sukinasaki who failed to meet Kumagawa. Well, not specifically since it's something that didn't happen (along with everything else that didn't happen), but it was meant to poke fun at the manga's own dramatic introduction of them, which led to an anticlimax of sorts when they didn't really do anything. Sukinasaki was used as an example of what didn't happen, by showing a close call.
|
2013-01-21, 08:26 | Link #11694 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2012
|
Quote:
Sorry, I just forget that this is one of the most neutral Medaka Box forums ever when it comes to Medaka. I forget that I'm in different company, so sorry for that. Quote:
I think you're a bright guy, but it's clear to me that you're way past the point of overanalyzing the manga when you write that much text. What I mean is...it's really hard to keep reading that uncondensed stuff, it's too long. I really don't have the dispositon to read and reflect on all that. Quote:
Spoiler:
I don't think she fits the description for that. The life-long archenemy or the long-lost brother simply weren't required by fate to show-up and produce a plot-line. I'm also curious as to if Kumagawa was drawn away by Devil Style, or if Suki was drawn in by it. But I think Kumagawa just abstained for his own reasons, and Suki appearing was just normal(hiring professional musicians). Mainly, I don't think Devil Style negates a coincidence from ever happening, just dosen't make them nescessary and certain to happen. The two options mentioned by Anshin'san will probably never appear to us now. Which is a bummer. Regardless, it's pretty vague at this point, and without even a mention of Devl Style, all that's left for us now is speculation.
__________________
Last edited by Wolfenstein; 2013-01-21 at 09:25. |
|||
2013-01-21, 12:19 | Link #11695 | |
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Spoiler for st:
So by your logc OP is a deconstruction of shounen by itself despite being a rolemodel of most of shounens nowadays and responsible of creating a lot of shounen tropes. |
|
2013-01-21, 12:24 | Link #11696 | |
I never hid my hurts.
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Where the wild things are--Hell.
|
Quote:
|
|
2013-01-21, 13:10 | Link #11697 | |
Homo Ludens
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Canada
Age: 34
|
Quote:
It's also notable that neither OP nor any of the currently-running shounen manga are mentioned here, either: Last edited by Tyabann; 2013-01-21 at 13:45. |
|
2013-01-21, 13:43 | Link #11698 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2012
|
Quote:
What do you folks think of this?
__________________
|
|
2013-01-21, 14:21 | Link #11699 | |
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Its like talking about pebbles on the road without actually talking about the road. |
|
2013-01-21, 14:28 | Link #11700 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2010
|
I think at this point Nisio needs to move on from the deconstructing shounen tropes/following them almost to a T storyline. Anyone can deconstruct a common cliche, that take an amazing writer to do that, the most successful deconstructions tend to be those that had an underlining point behind, an easily but typically not truly considered by the reader. E.g Lord of flies where the deconstruction of the typical young's boys adventure story leads to horrifying results, or romance novels such as great expectations where the typical story of boys meet girl, and pauper to riches, leads to a circular development, the young man and the girl aren't shown happily ever after at the end and boy loses his riches. They both end up right back at where they started except not quite right back.
If he reallys wants to continue this deconstruction he should follow a more realistic with an easy identifiable message and ideally not one where it's MC characters don't really work hard, everyone already knows this, but why is it idealized that they do work hard, because the ability to put your effort into achieving something you want through your own hard work is admired by society. Why? As it is a way for humans who may only live once to die saying, I didn't waste this life, I achieved what I wanted on my own terms and I can be proud I lived the way I did, as regardless of the end result I know I truly tried and that's one regret I didn't have. it doesn't have like that but a story can hit hardest when interwoven with a single consistent poignant theme. And I think Medaka box lacks that. |
Tags |
action, comedy, harem, nishio, romance, shounen, student council |
|
|