2010-03-02, 12:18 | Link #101 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
|
I am actually really happy about this chapter, since it dispelled a lot of the worries I had over the next few chapters.
1. Priscilla probably will not die due to Claire pulling out some powerlevel-hax. At least there is a reason to like Jean (okay I am exaggerating). 2. Deneve and Helen using their heads (using the hellcat spikes, etc) and using the destroyer to annoy Priscilla rather than pulling any techniques out of no where. 3. Although short, Yuma's dialogue was actually very nice since it had something to say about the Ghosts (would it be strange call it family-like?). 4. It also seems Helen and Deneve were a little hurt /betrayed by Claire's actions (Helen: "to save that monster" pg 13). However, that could be interpreted as sarcasm, calling back to the conversation Helen and Deneve had over if Miria and Claire were in a fight who would win. ] <---mistranslation from what Yoko Takeo said. 5. I would like to see where Raki is coming along, I just hope he does not die, else the manga would lose another perspective to coin in on. Last edited by Nixl; 2010-03-02 at 12:34. |
2010-03-02, 12:28 | Link #102 | |
Disabled By Request
|
Quote:
|
|
2010-03-02, 12:40 | Link #104 | ||
Spoilaphobic
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: USA
Age: 37
|
Quote:
Quote:
Deneve's whole spiel is all mixed up. I am hoping someone else scanlates this.
__________________
|
||
2010-03-02, 13:25 | Link #107 |
Proud Yuma Lover.
Join Date: Apr 2007
|
I too wonder what that piece of Cloth Dietrich has is. It could be a cape fragment is supose.
Too bad Cynthia didn't lose a little more of her outfit. No, get your minds out of the gutter. The reason I say that is a little more and we would have seen her stomach, and maybe found out what the stigmata on a Claymore looks like. Seems like we had a few shots focusing on asses this chapter. At least Deneve and Dietrich had one each. Nice touch with Yuma going through how all her comrades would react to her learning those skills. It's rather touching to see her start crying because she won't get to see them again. Another nice touch was Cynthia's being upset she couldn't move. I figure she wanted to go help Yuma, but can't, and that torments her. Those Hellcats were lucky they imobilized Yuma's arm. Clearly she was about to Yumapunch them all to oblivion.
__________________
Last edited by Negativedark; 2010-03-02 at 13:27. Reason: added Yumapunch. |
2010-03-02, 13:52 | Link #109 |
NYAAAAHAAANNNNN~
Join Date: Nov 2007
Age: 35
|
As far as I know, PE/TSD (Post Embitterment/Traumatic Stress Disorder) that causes phobia involves the sufferer to put mental "barriers" inside his/her head, not wedges. I think it is more of a direct translation instead of what Yagi was trying to put forward....he ran out of words.
I'd hate to see Dietrich die or get controlled in the next chapter. She is the cutest-looking Claymore with her twintails <3 (a shared opinion unless you are a lolicon ).
__________________
|
2010-03-02, 14:16 | Link #110 | |
Angriest Angel
Join Date: Nov 2007
|
This is not against wells chinese - japanese - english translation. I hopep that francky house would use a translation from an japanese raw or will replace it with a good translation.
Quote:
The begin is very strange. Did helen clare really call "a monster" or wanted she clare to save her FROM that monster? -The fight with rigardo can be used as analysis in the battle with priscilla. My old computer science prof would say syntactically correct but semantically wrong What the hell does that mean? Probably that she thought that the fight against priscilla would become a similar one because both aren't using strong armor but rely on speed? -I never realized that during the fight with rigardo my body size, speed and offensive abilities are unconsciously replicated into my current battle with priscilla until the fight was over. So she was fighting rigardo but thought of fighting against priscilla? -At that time i thought jus having an average warrior strength to wield my claymore was enough to defeat her. At WHAT time? When she fought rigardo or when she was a little girl. And has she still this opinion? I think so.
__________________
Last edited by irvinethearcher; 2010-03-02 at 14:42. |
|
2010-03-02, 14:40 | Link #111 | |
Resident Lurker
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Western NY
|
Quote:
It was still a good chapter none the less. |
|
2010-03-02, 14:47 | Link #112 |
Junior Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
|
I think it's a very good chapter, a combination of typical explanatory chapter(reversal awakening accident), main characters action(Clare,Helen,Deneve,Priscilla), and supporting characters follow-up(Yuma,Cynthia,Dietrich).
About Clare's conclusion in page 2, that one did not need powerful strength, but the speed and skills to rival Priscilla, then i think Miria is the one perfect one to fight her, plus in chapter 85 page 9, "No matter how you which you choose, Miria is superior, speed, stamina, physical strength, and swordsmanship." I think there's a possibility that Miria and Tabitha will come to rescue Clare's party, since page 21 said "From now on we can only pray... To the Goddess of fortune to help." which means they can't do anything else more, Clare's beaten up and on a mental breakdown, and it's simply impossible for Deneve and Helen to use those war tactics anymore because it's clearly not working and they surely know it's not a good idea to piss off Priscilla. In addition, on the last page cliffhanger line "Miria's main squad is finally here?!" has got to mean something, plus it's been a long time they haven't showed up, i think it would be a great idea to show some Miria action, since only she and Tabitha dan hasn't released their youki after seven years, i think her speed would be far above Rigardo and half-awakened Clare because Clare seems to focus more on her arm speed. And if with Tabitha's sensing skill, Miria would have a good chance avoiding Priscilla's attacks. And while they fight, Deneve would put a sense to Clare and Helen would say a blunt but supporting things, and when Clare finally come to her senses she would ask Miria to step back and but Miria would probably use her charismatic leadership and command Clare to work together as a team, and the chapter would end there with two page illustrating their readiness to fight Priscilla till the end. About Yuma and Cynthia, i won't worry too much, most likely Dietrich will have a bit of hard time but then suddenly Cynthia came, already recovered and synchronize her youki with Yuma and act as sensor like Tabitha and finally they got out of the mess and joined Clare's party and finally all of them took out Priscilla. As for Galatea, there may be a really small probability that she will met with Raki because she sensed a weird youki(maybe from the retrieval unit that brought Raki or even from contaminated Raki himself), and she will brought Miata and Clarice to figure what it is, following him using Miata's sixth sense, and finally save him, and they will wait and pray for Clare's safe return in Rabona while tending his parasitic wounds. And the destroyer, once they finished up Priscilla, Clare will surely put a good use of Rafaela's memory, and maybe that one grave mistake that Rafaela mention Clare did is, the organization finally succeeded in making that continent "A test ground for creating the awakened" as Miria said in the last page of chapter 79. Surely Rafaela knows everything about the organization and the other continent since she's older than Teresa and Rubel's pupil, plus Rafaela and Luciela was their trump card in the past, the should-be-ultimate weapon of the organization, and now they are, as Dae-sama said at chapter 96 page 2-3 "The ideal, perfect weapon" Well its all just my speculations, i don't even know why i'm posting this, i just love Claymore, one of the best manga ever made. |
2010-03-02, 14:56 | Link #113 | |||||
Spoilaphobic
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: USA
Age: 37
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||||
2010-03-02, 16:23 | Link #114 | |||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2009
|
Quote:
My main concern with this was that Clare was watching. I mean how was she watching? How could she even follow what was going on? And jsut after the person she cared about the mosd got behaeded? I think my mind would have gon completely blank at that point and I wouldn't be able to understand what I was seeing let alone analyze who was doing what and how. It's just wiered Quote:
Quote:
Either way her plan was based on an assumption that sort of contradicts itself. I mean Irene(way faster than Clare with the qucksword or at least faster) couldn't touch Prissy. Noel (her forte was agility not speed and she was slower than Irene in terms of attacks) cut Prissy while Sophia's (her forte was strength) strike got blocked. At best Clare could consider that a lucky shot. Or what she has to be fast but not that fast (Irene>Noel>Sophia)? Really doesn't make sense if you ask me And as I said earlier from Clare's standpoint Prissy could blcok only one of the attacks since they were coming from completely different sides at the same time (meaning neither was really faster). One could be blocked but the other either had to connect or be avoided. If one was avoided the other would have been avoided as well so that attack had to connect simply because it had no where to go and this had nothing to do with speed. Besides if Sophia's strike was stronger it's more logical to block that one if you had to choose one since it would deal more damage. Quote:
Best bet was yoki reading since it was way more obvious Teresa (who was exceptionally good at that) could hold off Prissy 1 on 1 without any problems. Now remember Clare had no real reason to think that Teresa at 10% was stronger than an AO.... Basically in Clare's mind Teresa at 10% should be weaker than QofB mode but again Teresa wasn't winning with speed or strength. Quote:
Oh and guess I wasn't the only one who didn't see those little lines since in the anime Noel's symbol was changed And as I said earlier I still can't see how Jean could be the real reason why Clare can't awaken since it's just not possible...imo of course . (if you wonder why I already said why I think it's not). I really won't like it since it's bassically going into the "ultimate elite form" and we have our first Claymore that's just a really small stap away from going full AB and back.. so to avoid that (which in the previous thread I called "lame" development) I vote it was Raphaela's doing! |
|||||
2010-03-02, 16:43 | Link #115 |
Former # 47
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: In the forgotten past
|
I rather liked this chapter but I don't understand why so many people are against the whole wedge thing. It makes sense. Rather then some convalted Raphalia soul link theory or Teresa influense, Clare stoped herself.
Clare couldn't bring herself to awaken and abanden her humanity. (that might change if she has to save somebody and not simply attacking Priscilla futilly) I am proud of her a bit. This I think is a major develoment in her character. Many people were upset when Clare descided to throw away her humanity. It seemed like Clare had not changed despite of all that had happened, that she would give up her humaity at the drop of a hat even is this was exactly contrary to all of Clare's comrades, raki ,and Teresa herself's ,wishs. But in Fact Clare couldn't do it. Her friends have affected her to much. In paticuler Jean dying to perserve her humanity was to much for her to ignore. I like it. Clare has grown as a character. Before Clare would not have stopped herself. She has changed On a side note : I think Helen called Clare the monster. I can't remeber the chapter it was when Helen was talking to Deneva about Clare and Miria, but Helen called Clare 'that little monster' in an affectionate way I think. I personally think that Deneva and Helen (and possibly the other ghosts as well) have come to regard Clare sort of as a little Sister that they have to look after so that she doesn't do anything stupied. (IE Like training in a certain way for so long and then awakening in order to stop the most powerful AB only to fail fail and drop the ball) Though they were relieved, they natuarally called her an Idiot. But Like Deneva said. She's an idiot but she is are Nakama, or in other words She(Clare) is their idiot. And Whoever it was who said it first; Yes, Yumis farwell was sort of family-ish I think. Clare's the youngest While Miria is everybody's Onee-sama in verying degees.
__________________
Last edited by Torri_fay_torren@hot; 2010-03-02 at 17:01. |
2010-03-02, 16:43 | Link #116 | |
Fanfic Writer
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2010-03-02, 17:03 | Link #117 | |
Angriest Angel
Join Date: Nov 2007
|
Quote:
We don't know if rafaella was or wasn't involved. Even when clare has a wedge it is normally not that easy to revert back this way. I think she used subconsciously rafaella's suppression skills to realize her hidden wish to stay human.
__________________
|
|
2010-03-02, 17:14 | Link #118 |
Thread Hijacker
Join Date: May 2009
Location: In a hole, I just need to dig myself out
|
I'm not upset nor was I surprised that Claire wanted to give up her humanity to kill Priscilla - who honestly didn't see that coming? - what Deneve said however, is just a very underwhelming choice in comparison to all the other theories that may have explained why Claire de-awakened.
Again, while I'm not bashing Jean, I'm just amazed that she supposedly had a bigger effect on her then all the others that have influenced Claire. I, personally, hoping that, after reading Weird D's latest fic, that it would be a mixture. I would like to point out though Torri that all this growth you're talking about never happened - Claire wanted to give up her humanity, the fact that she can't wasn't something she wanted. The fact she has apparently stopped herself wasn't something she wanted. She HAS grown, but not to the degree you're saying. And besides, it's not like Claire herself has heard Deneve's theory and admitted it as truth, or denied it, nor does she know details about Claire as much as we do. Claire is right now wondering "why why", instead of "I'm sorry, I can't do it" or some sort of regret that she's not as strong as she thought she was. She wants to awaken. I just can't see this "mental block" Claire has supposedly put on herself as fact, I just can't. Claire has made it her life's purpose to avenge Teresa - she has come a long way since then, and has indeed grown since she held her head in her arms....but I just can't see her giving up on her revenge because of something like this, something she unintentionally put on herself. Maybe she's secretly scared of awakening truly - but we heard right now, her plans and ideas on awakening and how she planned to kill Priscilla. She's been planning to awaken to kill her since Day 1 when she convinced Rubel to take her in. While we all hope Claire would give up on her revenge and live for herself like Teresa, Irene, Jean, Raki and everyone else wants too....I just can't see it being done like this. She is right in front of what she has been training for and I can't see her walking away from it right now. Obviously whether or not she can beat Priscilla or not is a whole different matter entirely, but my point is, I can't see Claire basically giving up like this. Maybe if she was convinced verbally or some other moment of signficence touched her that she would give up on her revenge, or Priscilla is killed by someone else, who knows...but I can't just see it being done like this. It feels so....their is a word I'm looking for(underwhelming perhaps), that I can't find. Hopefully someone gets what I'm going on about. --- What really stinks Gangsta, is that this is a prime example of one person(or in this case, a group), ruining the fun for everyone else. Maybe though it's a good thing, because now they can at least take this as some sort of lesson and actually wait for good translations before rushing to work. Doubt it. |
2010-03-02, 17:26 | Link #119 | |
Angriest Angel
Join Date: Nov 2007
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2010-03-02, 17:40 | Link #120 |
Miria's #1 Disciple
Join Date: Apr 2007
|
I think a lot of people underestimate how much Jean's death effected Clare.
Clare broke down in tears in THE MIDDLE OF A BATTLE and was utterly devestated when Jean died saving her. If it wasn't for Deneve, she may well have well sat there until an AB decided to take advantage. We haven't seen Clare that devastated since Teresa's death, and Clare likely holds herself directly responsible for Jean's death. That is some pretty powerful stuff, which I'd put on the level of Teresa's death for Clare. So Clare, who is seeking vengeance for Teresa no matter the cost, is being held back by the memory of Jean, and what happened the last time she was about to awaken. ---- As for this supposedly being a one-up for Clare/Priscilla comparison, not really. This actually enhances the comparison and the point I was making previously. Priscilla also had a mental block on her own abilities, this was brought up in the data books. That mental block still existed even after her awakening, up until her encounter with Isley. The first time we ever saw her use her true strength after being knocked around so much she regressed to a child-like state, which probably removed that mental restraint. This only difference between Priscilla and Clare is that Clare has people watching out for her well being, while Priscilla did not. Even in this chapter, we are once again shown that Clare's friends are the only thing keeping her alive/human. This is the reason Priscilla is a "tragic" villain; she and Clare are so similar, but their individual circumstances are what led them to were they are now. Clare has people constantly helping/saving her, while Priscilla never had such a comfort/convenience. So Clare remains human, but Priscilla fell and became a monster.
__________________
|
|
|