|
View Poll Results: Nisemonogatari - Episode 08 Rating | |||
Perfect 10 | 166 | 75.45% | |
9 out of 10 : Excellent | 22 | 10.00% | |
8 out of 10 : Very Good | 10 | 4.55% | |
7 out of 10 : Good | 3 | 1.36% | |
6 out of 10 : Average | 4 | 1.82% | |
5 out of 10 : Below Average | 3 | 1.36% | |
4 out of 10 : Poor | 3 | 1.36% | |
3 out of 10 : Bad | 2 | 0.91% | |
2 out of 10 : Very Bad | 1 | 0.45% | |
1 out of 10 : Painful | 6 | 2.73% | |
Voters: 220. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools |
2012-02-26, 21:47 | Link #342 | |||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: California
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I think it is because 5 people gave this episode the lowest score possible. If you compare the other low scores given, there's an interesting polarizing effect going on there.
__________________
|
|||||
2012-02-26, 22:01 | Link #344 | ||||||
Bittersweet Distractor
Join Date: Nov 2007
Age: 32
|
Thoughtful replies get thoughtful answers.
Quote:
At least when I say this had zero interesting character development or plot I'm saying it probably contains nothing more than a tease or fetish fuel. Let me first explain how I saw the Shinobu scene and then I'll get back to this one. The Shinobu scene was charged and was more explicit overall about everything in general. That's pretty much true. However, the conversation she had with Koyomi did many things. Oshino's existence was officially replaced in a suitably believable manner. Shinobu's personality was officially established in the anime, we knew next to nothing about her previously. The nature of her relationship with Koyomi was revealed. A bit of a begrudging acceptance of each other, though they seem to share affection. It also touched up further on a little bit of Koyomi's existential crisis. How is he as a vampire going to live out his life, will he outlive everybody? To me this was all meaty characterization and guess what? The entire time the dialogue was crisp, lively and fun, as you would expect from Monogatari. Now compared this long drawn out episode with Karen and Araragi. They seem to be establishing sexual tension between the two. However, will this story ever truly go that route? I doubt it, and if it did, this would be instantly dropped for crap plot development (Just because it's development, doesn't mean it's particularly interesting or good development). In the end I can't know, but I am pretty assured from my experience of watching shows that this will never amount to more than a tease. But OK, they established sexual tension and they established she admires Kanbaru. Maybe this will have some bearing on the plot, and Nisio will try to be "clever," but Nisio's cleverness does not simply earn the story points as a matter of fact for me. If the things he later brings into relevance were uninteresting and stupid to me to begin with, well damn I am not going to care. Believe me I respect Nisio in general especially after what I saw of him in Katangatari and Bake in, but to me he's just messing around way too much now. Though I still think Shinbo amplified the issues here with his usual egotistical style. Quote:
I'm pretty sure Nisio had fun with this. I'm not so cynical to believe that he wrote this little skit with the only thoughts in his mind being, "Damn how can I get people's money... I know the most ridiculous and absurd fanservice possible!" There is probably genuine thought and passion into the craft he has. If you notice the whole time I've been attacking Shinbo more than Nisio because while I disagree with what he tried to do here, I hardly doubt he delivered it with such an egotistical sense of direction that Shinbo employed in this episode. And believe me, Shinbo milked this for all its worth (He explicitly said in the past he makes anime for the money, I am cynical when it comes to him). However, authors may have intentions and they may genuinely try to do something they think is interesting, and in the end... I might not like it. Does not matter if I don't get it or not, I just thought it was a bad idea. To be honest, I thought part of the problem with this scene besides employing it with the wrong characters, drawing it out too long in a grandeur manner, and establishing little to no plot was the fact that I thought it wasn't absurd enough. I'm not talking about directing here, but content. The grandeur and egotistical nature of Shinbo's directing this episode just did not match the content. It simply wasn't as racy or titillating as one would expect for fanservice. It was just boring, the worst kind of bad to me. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||||||
2012-02-26, 22:05 | Link #345 |
Spoilaphobic
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: USA
Age: 37
|
What did I just watch!? My god... brushing her teeth.... I am in shock........
........Eri Kitamara was perfect too. Damn.... using a toothbrush........ LOL at the poll. This will go down in anime history forever.
__________________
|
2012-02-26, 22:10 | Link #346 |
Pedestrian
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Sweden
|
I think the complainers are underestimating just how important the toothbrush scene was. It is without a shadow of a doubt the absolute best scene in the entire novel series, and every Nishio fan knows that the only reason to produce a Nisemonogatari anime would be to animate that specific scene. Giving it anything less than an episode would have been sacrilege, and everyone would have boycotted the blu-rays.
__________________
|
2012-02-26, 22:25 | Link #347 | |
Knowledge is the solution
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: St. Louis, MO
Age: 39
|
^
*can't stop laughing my ass off* Oh Nisemonogatari. You just make my day every time. Now on serious mode Quote:
__________________
|
|
2012-02-26, 23:06 | Link #349 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2009
|
Quote:
Spoiler for From Bakemonogatari:
|
|
2012-02-26, 23:25 | Link #351 |
Pretentious moe scholar
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Vancouver, Canada
Age: 37
|
First time I watched this episode I hated it. However, as with several other cases of subpar scenes in Bake/Nise, I enjoyed it far, far more the second time through.
If I had to cite a culprit, it would be Koyomi's internal monologues, which I paid less attention to the second time. I know that Shaft was probably trying to remain true to the source (always a big deal for otaku-oriented productions), but I think the scene would have been far, far better if they had cut all of Koyomi's lines after "Kanbaru-sensei's fetishtic ideas will lead to your defeat" until the Tsuhiki shows up. Show don't tell, and let the viewer wonder if it's "really happening" and "Koyomi couldn't possible be that much of a creep, right? He always resists Nadeko, after all.". Besides, Koyomi's interactions with girls are always full of teasing/trolling - I'd go so far as to say the teasing/trolling interactions are the special sauce that makes Bakemonogatari's fanservice so great. Plus, the monologues were kind of squicky too, which honestly ruined some of my enjoyment. I mean yeah, we know Koyomi has groped Mayoi before, but there was always this tongue in cheek "it's just a bit of roughousing gone too far" element to it. Here, not so much. I guess my general opinion could be summed up as "could have been great, but due to some bad decision it's not nearly as good as most of the service in the show". Mainly because it doesn't nail the teasing nature of most Monogatari fanservice.
__________________
|
2012-02-27, 00:43 | Link #353 | |||||||||
Senior Member
Author
|
Quote:
Quote:
If you're going to start a new fetish, the way it's executed should at least be half-way plausible, imo, and it wasn't here. Quote:
The way a lot of the 10/10 folks have talked on this thread, this scene is the reason why they gave 10/10. So if one scene alone can warrant the highest score possible, then why shouldn't one scene alone warrant the lowest score possible? If you're going to criticize 1/10 voters for this shouldn't you also criticize 10/10 voters who made that vote due to one scene? Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||||||||
2012-02-27, 00:52 | Link #354 | |
Senior Member
Author
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Philippines
Age: 47
|
Oh, man, even Gen has a reaction:
https://twitter.com/#!/Butch_Gen/sta...56966801297408 Regaining my sanity enough to work after Nisemonogatari 8 is going to be very difficult His followers reacted: Quote:
__________________
|
|
2012-02-27, 01:23 | Link #356 |
Logician and Romantic
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Within my mind
Age: 43
|
Now that we know this chapter was created not for mass market, but for the author's personal pleasure, the question is this;
Which is selling out, and which is art? To create something you genuinely personally enjoy creating? Or to make something that gets high acclaim by adhering to social demands? I can't help but feel some of the rage is similar to those generated in Haruhi's infamous Endless Eight incident. Sometimes, people take a risk. They create something they wanted to make, something unorthodox, and with not a care about public opinion. The question is, would you like that to cease? Would you like anime and novels to be written according to the whims of opinion polls? Does the author's vision mean so little, that one should over-ride their wishes and demand something else?
__________________
|
2012-02-27, 01:34 | Link #357 | |
On a mission
Author
|
Quote:
And if they don't care about public opinion, this is pretty moot anyways. False dilemma is false dilemma. Things don't justify themselves. I won't play that game.
__________________
|
|
2012-02-27, 02:15 | Link #358 |
Yuuki Aoi
Join Date: Jul 2004
|
It's great to hear so many differing shades of opinion. For what it's worth, here are some of my shades:
1. In general, I think Nise is at a lower level than Bake. But maybe that's because doing a similar thing a second time has less impact. In any case, it seems to me that the fanservicey surface is a bit stronger and the character/interaction depth a bit weaker. But what a surface! And the characters and their interactions are still pretty great. 2. The toothbrushing scene is among the most erotic I've seen in anime. I disagree completely with the idea that it is less effective than other fanservice in this show. This is a classic. Of course, so was the Shinobu/Koyomi bathing scene, although it was not particularly erotic. 3. For me, it is certainly possible for an unoriginal premise to be presented in an original way. However, I think you have to be pretty general to define anything unoriginal about this scene. Like "erotic feelings between an older brother and a younger sister." Everything else seems original. 4. I think there is usually meaning in the supposed silliness that people call "Shaft being Shaft." And even when the meaning is less obvious, I think of the "silliness" as "absurdity," which is a conceptually higher thing. 5. Even though there is no chance that Koyomi and Karen will really hook up, that does not detract from but contributes to the erotic tension of the scene, for me. 6. Shinbou may have said that he does it for the money, but that is just Shinbou being Shinbou. Most artists do all their best work for money. Money is only part of the motivation. Once you start to work, your creativity takes over.
__________________
|
2012-02-27, 02:30 | Link #359 | |||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2007
Age: 35
|
Quote:
Now, one might well feel that there is no good reason to attempt to "understand" racists. But anime is a matter of entertainment; and in Nisemonogatari's case, mass entertainment, representing the enjoyment of a very sizeable audience. All human perspectives deserving at least some level of base respect and dignity, at least on trivial matters such as these regarding fiction and entertainment, I do not feel there is any meaning in criticizing the enjoyment of that majority. That is to say, like another poster said, I do feel regret that some people were not satisfied with this episode. However, those people who were not satisfied should also try to balance their own dissatisfaction with the enjoyment of so many others over this episode. Quote:
Quote:
One prominent example of this which I do now have knowledge of regards a previous example of fanservice which I remember you noted as seeming ill-fitting as an introduction to the series--namely Hanekawa's panty-shot. I think certain posters (such as Malkuth) might be able to provide a better summary of why that event actually has a surprising degree of significance, but if you are interested I would be willing to make an attempt myself in explaining it, perhaps over PM as you suggested. Quote:
In the same way it could probably be said that the *monogatari series as a whole is simply a trivial story regarding Araragi and his relationships. The narrative simply records Koyomi and his journey, the only two finite possible end points apparently being an eternity of solitude together with Shinobu, or a "proper" life as a redeemed human together with Hitagi. As an intermediate step on this journey, comes Koyomi's current entanglement with Karen (who has now twice openly stated she is in love with him). Even if this romantic/sexual tension never leads to an actual relationship, it must still at the least receive a resolution by narrative necessity (for example: what sort of developments will result upon Karen discovering that Koyomi has a girlfriend in Hitagi?). Quote:
|
|||||
2012-02-27, 02:31 | Link #360 |
Senior Member
Author
|
Given how far the originality vs. unoriginality argument has gone, I just searched for "toothbrush as a sex toy" on Google. I'd link to some of what I brought up, but I'm not sure it would be appropriate given AS rules. So I'd just encourage other people curious about it to try it themselves.
Based on my search, toothbrush as a sex toy is a lot more common than I had ever imagined.
__________________
|
|
|