2009-02-06, 01:14 | Link #1441 | |
Is Neither Goth Nor Emo
Join Date: Feb 2007
|
Quote:
Something about how the free peoples of the world got fed-up with the looming relic of the past that arbitrarily decided that the humans in it weren't pure enough. It's basically Fallout racism serving as an antagonist, with some commentary about how irrational dogmatism rejects the secular world as being impure and instead pins its hopes on an distant and nebulous "promised land." It's not just saying that nihilism is bad. It's saying gullibility and rigid dogmatism isn't a good reason to reject what you have on-hand. Self-denial in the pursuit of a foolhardy abstraction is nihilism -- a rejection of life. Salvation is generally a scam. (Fredrich Nietzche!) Which, I can kind of see in Xam'd. What with the despairing pilgrims killing themselves off and the good-for-nothing clergy propping up a corrupt system involving a God Emperor. But I never really expected them to take it that seriously, I just thought that the art and some of themes was really just a fanfiction tribute towards Miyazaki's manga. It was undeniably cool to see, but it still felt like they were trying to rip-off material instead of finding their own voice. You see, this raises a number of confusing contradictions: Sannova's followers are clearly fanatics, but they're really not the bad guys. They oscillate between being sympathetic humans to being utterly unlikeable nut-jobs that will justify any crime in the name of their ideal. It's not undoable to do both of those things, but I'm not sure Bones knows how to handle it. Eureka Seven generally treated their religious-ethnic types as positive figures. For my part, I hated Sannova and her lot. I wish Nakiami would have gotten over her awe and admiration of Sannova. It would have really brought her full-circle. Needless to say, watching Isshu shoot one of them was a rather cathartic moment. Last edited by Twisted Reality; 2009-02-06 at 01:44. |
|
2009-02-06, 02:04 | Link #1442 |
Delightfully lost...
Artist
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: All over the place...
|
Xam'd is not good.
It's the first time I've genuinely hated a BONES production. The only things keeping me from rating this show as "bad" are the animation and music. Oh, those two elements are as good as they can be. Everything else, stank. The story made little sense, the storytelling became increasingly putrid as the show went on, and the message, assuming there is a coherent one, was blurred beyond recognition. I'd never thought I'd say thing about a BONES original, but Xam'd is comparable painstakingly decorated garbage bag. It looks nice and makes one feel nice looking at it, but it's designed to hold absolutely nothing of substance and value. Last edited by [DOT].L; 2009-02-06 at 04:34. Reason: grr... typo |
2009-02-06, 02:18 | Link #1443 | |||||
Moving in circles
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Singapore
Age: 49
|
Quote:
So, what is Sannova really? The matriarch of a doomsday cult? If so, why is she being portrayed in such positive light? Am I misunderstanding something here? How could something so vile be seen as something "good"? I remain unconvinced by how she was so easily persuaded by Nakiami's pleas to change her mind, as though it were all "part of the plan". Is that how it's supposed to be? That she had deliberately adopted the Tenjo of the Tessiks because of some 1000-year-old prophecy, knowing well in advance that the Cloud Rider would eventually rebel? If that's the case, the story did a very poor job of portraying it. The "explanations" offered in Ep25 ended up feeling like a highly contrived deux ex machina instead. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I dare say that Xamdou's writers were trying to portray the value of that "struggle" which Akiyuki spoke of but, somehow, they just couldn't handle it — they didn't fully appreciate the tragic irony of the human condition as expressed by Camus and Miyazaki, so they opted for the flawed but easier-to-understand sacrifice that Nakiami undertook instead. Last edited by TinyRedLeaf; 2009-02-06 at 02:52. |
|||||
2009-02-06, 02:56 | Link #1444 | |
Lets be reality
Join Date: May 2007
|
Quote:
|
|
2009-02-06, 05:57 | Link #1446 | ||
Is Neither Goth Nor Emo
Join Date: Feb 2007
|
Quote:
So I don't think it's entirely accurate to say that Miyazaki was shaped singly by one person. I'm well aware of the story of Sisyphus and it is a commonly used metaphor for existentialists (although Camus apparently denies being one). Existentialism and "deep writing" tend to inevitably end up together, so I don't find it particularly odd that it's come up in this instance. What I'm trying to drive at is that, a core issue towards the climax, insofar as I care to judge, was that the past traditions and legacies were stagnating. They were held sacred for no good reason at all. I can see where "Absurdism" fits in, but I was thinking more close to Nietzche, who viewed Christianity of his day as a death cult. I'm not claiming that these are core influences, but it's still an unavoidable influence nonetheless. Quote:
Again, you are referring to existentialist themes, but I'm going so far as to characterize Nausicaa as a struggle against oppressive relics and traditions of a bygone age and a ludicrously insubstantial, even bigoted, ideal which is the source of much conflict in the setting, if only by virtue of having seeped into the culture. Remember, the humans that currently lived in the "corrupt" world were going to be exterminated so that the "pure" strain could replace them. (Which is very Fallout.) It is a rejection of these ideological "mummies" that allows the characters to move on with their lives. Xam'd doesn't even bother to set up the oppressive government as a believable or stagnant enemy, so borrowing themes kind of falls flat here. |
||
2009-02-06, 06:35 | Link #1447 | ||
Beautiful fighter.
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: England, UK
Age: 37
|
Quote:
Quote:
I'm sorry if what i said didn't play well with people, though from my view it just looked like people where hoping for more explanation on some aspects, though with this shows track record in that department, it was very un-likely that we'd get that.
__________________
|
||
2009-02-06, 07:28 | Link #1448 |
I can has drinks?
Join Date: Mar 2006
|
Hmmm, kind of have mixed feelings about the end of it. Kinda like how I felt about the end of Darker than Black - it just didn't have the impact I was expecting. Also, quite a bit was left up in the air. Oh well, I guess we'll know in a thousand years :V
Still, the series gets some points from the usual great animation from BONES. Even more for the "What they are doing now" end which I am a sucker for. BTW, can anyone clarify: I heard this thing is getting another season. Is that true? Last edited by fict_ticious; 2009-02-06 at 07:48. |
2009-02-06, 07:32 | Link #1449 |
Yozora
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Germany
Age: 37
|
Well, after watching the last episode yesterday I feel the need to express my disappointment. I was well aware, that though this show showed similarities to my beloved Eureka Seven it just wouldn't be the same.
I don't want to repeat now, what others said about the inconsistent plot or the ending. I just question myself, why the plotwriters couldn't come up with something different. What especialy displeased me, was the very end and Akiyuki's ressurection. No word why he turned to stone, no word why he suddenly lived again. If it was for unanswered questions I could make a long long list. In short - the biggest disappointment for me in the 2008 anime season (after that the a bit unlucky ending of Macross Frontier). |
2009-02-06, 08:37 | Link #1450 | ||
Naysayer?Fanboy?Wiseacre?
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
It's not that I hate the show, I am not even much of a fan of BONES, so it was definitely not a case of impossibly high expectations, it just could have been so much more with more consistent writing. It felt as if one writer wrote an episode, another one wrote the next - which in itself is not bad and I believe it's very common, but this next writer didn't seem to care about what the first one had writen, put his own ideas in the episode without bothering about consistency. And then first writer returns and effectively nullifies what second guy has done. For example in the end - on the one hand we have well executed glorious sacrifices, on another Spoiler for ep.26:
__________________
|
||
2009-02-06, 11:37 | Link #1451 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2009
Age: 35
|
hey I completely agree, the build up of the story leaves the impression that there is some sort of over looming flaw with the current society, but as things build toward this anti climatic end, those ideas never fully develop. On one hand I can understand why somethings don't get developed, usually this is due to budget, but I think bones definitely made the mistake of making this series only 26 episodes. It felt like at the beginning of the show as we watched we striving for something but once we hit the later ideas the writers seemed to have lost focus. The idea many have already talked about is not fleshed out at all, but I still don't fault bones for making a mediocre product, considering choices such as akikan and what not. It's character designs where fairly originally, the animation was great as usual, and a great ost made the show watchable. I'm not saying that its forgivable to create meaningless dialogue and leave plots unfleshed but then again I rarely put each anime I watch on a pedestal. Bones wanted xamdou to be an epic tail and it fell flat but it sure as hell doesn't mean I didn't enjoy the soundtrack. Looking back on this expierence the end really was a let down, but truly to build those ideas, very few anime have the vision or the budget.
The idea that japanesse have a different view on war is quite absurd, through history we see this long history of conflict, it really doesn't matter what type of person you are, what country you come from, conflict is part of history, our nature. Each individual has a different philosophy about conflict but in this series there is no clear philosophy no tangible portrayal of conflict. We know we have the southern and northern forces but why does this manifestation of conflict occur, we know the northerners uses "humanforms" but still whoever wrote this portion of the story never truly reveals the roles of sannova and the two countries. This loss of identity in the conflict, the actual purpose of the conflict is then pushed onto the hiruken emperor that is revealed only much latter in series which doesn't leave time to flesh out why these things occur which ultimately leave the series feeling flat and very one dimensional. It felt like climbing up a large mountain only to reach a plateau where there was no fall and no climax. |
2009-02-06, 12:16 | Link #1452 | ||||||
Moving in circles
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Singapore
Age: 49
|
Quote:
Quote:
Spoiler for Nausicaa the manga:
Quote:
To me, it seems that the creators wanted to point out that even if friends, family and loved ones get separated by war and death, they can still stay connected through their emotions, their hiruko, their souls — their tamashi. Hence the letters motiff, hence the idea behind Haru and Akiyuki's relationship and hence, most importantly, Nakiami's final decision (influenced strongly by her memories of the Zanbani crew). It's a different perspective on how to deal with mortality — versus Miyazaki's concept of struggle — set against the backdrop of a world war and a doomsday event. But: Quote:
========= Quote:
Spoiler for Episode 26:
========= Quote:
The number of episodes available to a show is not a limitation. The only limitation is the writer's talent: Is he creative and disciplined enough to find a way around his given constraints? That is the challenge of good storytelling. |
||||||
2009-02-06, 12:46 | Link #1453 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2009
Age: 35
|
Quote:
|
|
2009-02-06, 16:01 | Link #1455 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2008
|
Ok I'm glad that I'm not the only one who seems to think that the story is poorly put together.
I'm usually good at understanding a 'deep' story line, but throughout the series I just kept seem to be getting lost. I thought maybe the point of the story went over my head or else it just had to be poor writing. There are just too many times I was asking myself "Why is this happening" with no answers at all. IDK I don't wan't this to turn into a rant. The more I try to understand the story line the more questions I get. I had a weird feeling at the begining of the series because the storyline seemed to be progressing in an odd fashion. I enjoy the series much more when I take it for what it was: eye candy. And What beautiful eye candy it was The BGM and voice acting was very well done. I'd make the excuse that given more episodes they could have filled in missing plot holes because it obvious the story could use a little more explaining. . However, I agree with an above poster: when writing an original story for an anime, you should already know ahead of time how many episodes you have to work with your story. I think its a little different when you take manga material and have to cram it into too a set number ofepisodes then when you write anime-original where you should know ahead of how much time you have to tell the story. Random note: Messy haired Nakiami is hot. (is that wierd to say? lol) Might be my favorite 'wierd girl character' in an anime series lol. Spoiler for For Size:
Also for another above poster. Don't be afraid to check out Eureka 7. They have some similarities like "Boy gets stuck on a giant flying ship with a weird girl, some annoying kids, and a stubborn captain." But it really does end there. Eureka 7 wasn't great but it was defiantly very good and worth the watch. Eureka 7's story is muuuuch better then Xamd's |
2009-02-06, 23:18 | Link #1457 | |
Is Neither Goth Nor Emo
Join Date: Feb 2007
|
Quote:
My personal favorite segment from the show was the showdown between Ray+Charles versus Holland. A personal feud stacked with tragedy happening concurrently at the cusp of the romantic pay-off between Eureka and Renton. Plus, you know . . . jumping out of your vehicle for a free fall scene in the middle of an airship battle should be done for the sheer inherent awesomeness. You'd be morally obligated to do it. Everything after that point never quite managed to capture the vision of the show as fully. And the execution was generally varied up until the nonsensical and excessively saccharine happy ending. The ending was still a non-sequitur since I'm still not exactly how the climax tied into the themes they were setting up. Or for that matter, why the Coralians even mattered if they could always have chosen to *poof* into a parallel universe on a whim. Anemone and Dewey just didn't get enough attention, which is bad when you're setting them up to be the main villains. Spoiler for Meh:
Last edited by Twisted Reality; 2009-02-06 at 23:32. |
|
2009-02-06, 23:48 | Link #1458 | |
Is Neither Goth Nor Emo
Join Date: Feb 2007
|
Quote:
Nakiami isn't weird. She's just unusually mature and assertive for her age. So if anything, your tastes are predictable and your attraction inevitable. |
|
2009-02-07, 06:08 | Link #1459 | |
A blast from the past
Artist
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Fortaleza-CE, Brazil
Age: 46
|
Quote:
Anyway, I'm quite fond of how this series ended. The mysteries remain and I don't really mind them much. The final scene between Akiyuki and Haru had me literally shedding a single tear. Not many series do that. So, I'm glad I stuck with it 'till the end.
__________________
|
|
2009-02-07, 12:34 | Link #1460 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: NYC
|
Finally got around to watching the last episode. Basically, it was a decent ending for this series. Did it resolve the tons of questions we have? No, unfortunately. But I have to agree with Shiroth to a degree on this point...with one episode left did we seriously think they were going to resolve things? When you consider the series as a whole and how it progressed, it doesn't make sense to expect that. But I can't blame anyone for wishing for explanations. When you put time in to watch a series, you hope for something (even just a few answers) to satisfy all those questions and it's frustrating to be left hanging. However, we just have to accept it for what it is. While I'm not happy that they left so much unexplained, the series was fun to watch and I don't regret spending time on it. It'll never be a favorite of mine though, too many flaws.
Spoiler for ep 26:
__________________
|
Tags |
bones |
|
|