Rate That Signature!

[Klashikari]

huh... lot of sigs recently ~~

Ice Climbers : the BG and the girl don't really match (surely because the Bg is actually a photograph, right?), thus rendering the girl quite too outstanding. the size might be reduced (it looks a bit empty), and it might give you more frames to add for the animation. keep going, your sigs get better and better recently. 7.5/10

darkjester : nice style. i'm just concerned about the outlines. they are quite nice, but it reveal some problem with the edges of yoko pic (hair at the bottom left is jagged, giving obvious impression it was smudged to extend the hair). slightly too cluttered, i think you can remove the far left yoko, and slightly move the center one on the left.
good improvement for the cut here. 8/10

KiNA : main yoko isn't greatly cut (especially the left edge). the color choice doesn't really strike me positively. (it gives some wash out burn impression, at least to me) i feel like the left part is really confusing, due the random elements at the left, and BG. 7/10

SweetSpring : really look like an avatar, errr... good animation, though the loop wasn't really smooth. 7/10

Sephi : impressive BG (the color mix is pretty smooth and neat). however, i feel the BG doesn't really suit eri. watch out with eri hair, they are almost too blurr ^^"
also, the fonts of the 2 text lines are a bit... too plain.
nice blending mode, *thumb up* 8/10


well then... after 3 months, i guess it is time to change sig once again
Yuiko, from Little Busters! (another swordmaiden XD)

[Solace]

@ice climbers - nice animation, but the bg doesn't seem to match the character. Peaceful though. 7.5/10

@darkjester - I read your "making of" for the yoko sig in your thread, I think it looks really nice for being an accident. 9/10

@Kina - the foreground yoko blends in a bit too much, but otherwise it looks good. 8/10

@Cyz - the pink! It burns!!!! Clean and fun. Poor Euphi. 9/10

@Sephi - the hair is a bit blurred and the text is kind of hard to read, but it still beats my attempts at sigs like that. 8.5/10

@sweetspring - trying to fit so much animation into the small file size and still have it look good can be a pita. Cute scene. 7/10

@klashikari - cute girl, I like the overall look to the sig. 8/10


New sig below, it's Kate from Red Garden. Took a screen from the show, and tweaked it up a bit. Shame there aren't more pics from the show to make sigs from.

[Cyz]

Originally Posted by Sephi

@Cyz soo pink!!! But looks good 8/10 Did you blurred it out again or is something wrong with my screen or my eyes:P ?

Yep, I put the blur on purpose....though I think I'll tone down on putting one (or maybe not at all) on my next one).

@ Ice Climbers: Chikage ne? It's a little plain but I like the animation. 8/10

@ KiNa: Not too sexy Oh and you seem to be over using that pic from the right...or maybe it's just me. 8/10

@ Sephi: Nice sig. 8/10

@ Klashikari: She's quite mysterious and charming isn't she? 9/10

@ ankoku: aaw, I like the scenery. Simple yet nice. 8/10

[CrowKenobi]

Switched from Kona-chan to Kagami-sama...

Cyz: It's pink! And maybe a bit too bright, but really nice! 9/10

Klash: Nice source pic, and what was that "specific radiance" you were trying to keep? 9/10

SweetSpring: An Ice Climbers hair-pulling special! 9/10 (but check the bytes before a mod notices...)

Ice Climbers: People complaining about the cloud bg? I like it and don't see what all the fuss is about... and I agree with KiNA: make the butterfly come out of her hand. 10/10

[Shana]

~ Me: Noumi Kudryavka from Little Busters!

~ Klashikari: Aww, nicely done - 10/10

~ Sephi: Good bg's color blend - 8/10

~ Cyz: Too much pink, but Euphie love :3 - 7/10

~ CrowKenobi: too much images... - 7/10

[krysinello]

Havent really been bothered with trying with photoshop but though I finally needed a sig hence that quick attempt, I'll make a better one or improve it when I can be bothered. Was going to add a better border but couldnt be bothered lol.

Shana 7/10
CrowKenobi 7/10
DarkJester 9/10

only sigs that loaded, sorry for not rating the others but I have a damaged phoneline limiting my net connection.

[HashiriyaR32]

CK: 8/10
Shana: 9/10

[Cyz]

@ Shana: If you could make it a little brighter then it will look much better. 8/10

@ CrowKenobi: Now how 'bout some Tsukasa? j/k. Kagami is okay too. 7/10

[krysinello]

Cyz, too pink for my liking but well done 7/10
ankoku 7/10
Klashikari, great work, love the colors, 9.5/10
Sephi, 9/10
Kira_Naruto, 8/10

I fixed the border on mine, rather simple but it looks decent enough.

[celcius]

krysinello: Chidori!! (that's Chidori right?) I think I'm going blind cos' I can't see the border you speak of. o.o 8/10
Cyz: Hmmm, too reddish? I think I'd like it better sans the reddish hue on her. =/ And I think there's too much sparklies on her hair 8/10
~Shana: Noumi!! Little Busters!! But I think I like Rin more, but Noumi comes a close second The small snppet of her face is kinda weird. 8.5/10
CrowKenobi: Kagamin!! But there's too many Kagamis in there... 7/10
ankoku: Totally love that crop. So calm... *_* 9.5/10
Doesn't quite match with your avatar though

[krysinello]

Its only a very faint border, see through, I think I'll add a harder blue line on the edge pixels though just to make is stand a bit more. 8/10 for yours.

[saphyre]

ankoku - Very nice crop, calm and peaceful.
CrowKenobi - Too many images
celcius - She looks familiar, where is she from?
krysinello - Didn't notice the border at first, but once I started looking closely I manage to see something that resembles a border, just barely.

[Cyz]

@ celcius: lol! it's pink not red . Your sig...I already rated it but I'll rate it again. 9/10 --> The BG really reminds me of AIR.

@ krysinello: a little plain no? 6/10

@ saphyre: rated...too bad it's not Tsukasa-chan 9/10

[HashiriyaR32]

@ Saphyre 9/10 Somehow I'm seeing misalignment.
@ cyz 9.5/10

[Deathkillz]

cyz ~ i like pink...but the hue is just too much it really offsets her natural skin tone >.< 7.5/10

krysinello ~ how sad...would be great if that was animated 6/10

celcius ~ wow i really like it for some reason...must be the painful memories ;heh: 8/10 (and the series is called Iriya no Sora, UFO no Natsu btw to saphyre )

[Shana]

~ saphyre: Sexy loli tsundere = teh win :3 - 8/10

~ celcius: Love the crop! good job - 9.2/10

~ krysinello: nice, but I have to force my eyes to see the border ~_@ - 6/10

[Cyz]

@ Deathkillz: It's not as great as your last one. The left side is a little empty maybe because it's so whitish. 7/10

[Areguzanda]

HashiriyaGDB: well what to say... a little to plain =/ 5/10
Deathkillz: Nice one. pretty. I like it. 9/10
~Shana: Cute and blurry 8.5/10
Cyz: sweet and a nice sig. 8/10

[saphyre]

Deathkillz - Where is she from? I seem to be missing out on alot of anime or something lately, so many new characters.
I really like the left picture, black and white with the red eyes. It really stands out.
The font you used for the word 'dreaming' is really good, though I don't think it was too good using it for 'DKZ', maybe because the font size is too small.
Overall a really nice sig with a little bit of animation too good job. (Oh and thanks for answering my first question )

@HashiriyaGDB - Really? Where abouts? :O

[felix]

~ Areguzanda 11 - 11

--
Saphyre, she's from Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha, currently at season 3.
Yup, you missed a hole lot.