The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya - Episode 15 Discussion / Poll [2009 added ep. 5]

[OverMaster]

Originally Posted by fish eric

There is over 45 pages of i hate it I love it. The same as the last 2 weeks. This was actually an entirely new episode animation and VO wise.

But plot-wise, the thing that matters the most? The same old thing. And as long as they don't supply new material, we can't discuss anything new.

And besides, aren't all discussions, at their core, hate it-love it exchanges? I'm not sure how could we reinvent the wheel on that.

[risingstar3110]

I haven't read the novel yet and don't know the loop will ended. But isn't what Itsuki (instead of Haruhi) said is the biggest clue to end the loop here: wispering "I love you" into her year the loop ended at 31st not 30th, so he have to do something in the last day when Haruhi's melancholy built up.


But oh well, he may tried that but it didn't work. Wondering if he have ever done something so crazy that it scared his unconscious self for eternity (and never be dared enough to attempt to do it again). Wearing the frog suit and praise Mikuru on Haruhi's roof perhaps

[Rice_slayer]

^^ Not anything to do with the solution. The solution is soooo easy it makes this build-up almost not worth it, but the "solution" has been mentioned in every E8 episode thus far...

[Takamura Mamoru]

I don't know why people still didn't figure it out yet, either.
Okay, the reasoning of it might not be obvious, but it's mentioned in every episode. It should kinda be obvious by now.

People who think this will have some romantic solution will be disappointed.
Because beyond the kiss in Season 1, there's... No explicit romance. None.

(Does that count as spoilering?)

[Da~Mike]

Just like the sentiment voiced by Kristen of Chihiro, really kyoto animation should F%^& themselves up the A&$# for making what was just one chapter in one volume into 4+ episodes.

God I feel so sorry for all the sub groups for having to translate the same S#!* 4 times over already...

Does the milking of the Haruhi fan base have no respite?

[risingstar3110]

Originally Posted by Takamura Mamoru

I don't know why people still didn't figure it out yet, either.
Okay, the reasoning of it might not be obvious, but it's mentioned in every episode. It should kinda be obvious by now.

People who think this will have some romantic solution will be disappointed.
Because beyond the kiss in Season 1, there's... No explicit romance. None.

(Does that count as spoilering?)

If you haven't read the novel then there is no way that you can know for sure what is the loop-breaker event. Even so i can make a "guess" what should be the solution:

Spoiler for ...just in case it happens to be right and be a spoiler....:

It's the homework, isn't it?
Haruhi has done it, Kyon didn't. Haruhi loves to make universe scale problems/solutions out of tiny unimportant things, this is one of them. Everything didn't end at 30th but at 31st, the day when Haruhi bored the heck out of herself wishing tomorrow didn't come and Kyon's desperate at the "haven't done homework".

...either that or something good came up and Haruhi spent the 31st rolling on her bed wishing the 1st will come

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by risingstar3110

Spoiler for ...just in case it happens to be right and be a spoiler....:

It's the homework, isn't it?
Haruhi has done it, Kyon didn't. Haruhi loves to make universe scale problems/solutions out of tiny unimportant things, this is one of them. Everything didn't end at 30th but at 31st, the day when Haruhi bored the heck out of herself wishing tomorrow didn't come and Kyon's desperate at the "haven't done homework".

...either that or something good came up and Haruhi spent the 31st rolling on her bed wishing the 1st will come

Well,

Spoiler for End of Eight: Are you sure?:

Spoiler for Are you really sure?:

Spoiler for Really really lemon squeezy?:

Yes, it's the homework. BUTTTTT SINCE this is one out-there anime adaptation, they could end it completely differently. They're airing the story arc differently than what we expected, and they could end it differently than what we expected.

[Zwei]

Will episode 6 be the same? I'm tired this arc.

[Justin Kim]

Episode 6 will have painful votes over 9000!!!

[Jill-Jênn]

http://wakarimasenlol.com/2009/07/14...time-soon/2961

In a recent inteview for Voice Newtype, Hirano Aya mentioned that she just finished recording the Endless Eight arc. Considering that it can take about a month for a recorded anime to finally air, does that mean we are stuck in that loop for another 4 weeks?
OH SNAP!

Edit: Hey that was my 42th!

[Emerald Emblem]

That's pretty much all 13 episodes taken by a 1 chapter volume? Haruhi fans prepare to abandon ship.

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by Emerald Emblem

That's pretty much all 13 episodes taken by a 1 chapter volume? Haruhi fans prepare to abandon ship.

That's not gonna happen, gtfo.

[Tyabann]

Originally Posted by Emerald Emblem

That's pretty much all 13 episodes taken by a 1 chapter volume? Haruhi fans prepare to abandon ship.

It was a short story, actually.

[Jill-Jênn]

Hey Kaisos, like in your avatar:

What do you think she is saying? Maybe that's the means to get away from the loop?

[Tyabann]

Originally Posted by Jill-Jênn

Hey Kaisos, like in your avatar:

What do you think she is saying? Maybe that's the means to get away from the loop?

You have no idea how much I wish my avatar was THAT shot of her, looking at the viewers (Kyon) and smiling slightly.

Anyway, it probably doesn't mean anything and was more there for the WTF factor than anything else.

[donoghu]

What's even more funny is that, from the start of the arc, once people have seen the <classified informations> starting, they mostly told 2 time the same things. If we take the <classified informations> into account, it's like if they wanted those who watch to feel like <classified character> which can see throught the <classified informations> which has <classified informations> so many time.

Ok...

Spoiler for <classified informations>:

Replace every <classified informations> for "loops" and <classified character> for Nagato.

[aulzon]

Spoiler for what she is really saying:

Nice plane

[nojay]

After much diligent research I have discovered just why episode 5 was just like episode 4 and episode 3 and episode 2...

Spoiler for Powerpoint presentation:

Limited edition figurines! They'll make a mint.

[synaesthetic]

A friend of mine continually claims that Endless Eights will go on for... eight episodes, being resolved on the eighth episode of the arc (or broadcast episode #09).

I'm not entirely convinced he is wrong.

p.s. I voted 10 out of 10 for the epic lulz

[Vexx]

Though this is getting the crap beat out of in the votes ... I actually enjoyed this version the most... the realization in the park with Nagato of the time loop actually got hackles on my neck raised.