Rate That Signature!

[Jze0]

ganbaru - Good but not as good as mine haha... j/k 8.5/10
fallschirmjager - Dunno know who the ladies are but nice 9/10
Evil Rick - Extremely cute like your ava 9.5/10

[Kitsune]

I've a new siggy done by my aniki Kato-chan wich needs to be rated ^^

[ganbaru]

Kitsune 8,2/10 something's bothering me

[Kelisidina]

Evil Rick: 8/10. It's too pinkish to match with the stocks and your text could use some work

[The Chaos]

Evil-kun...Look So Cute!!..9.5/10
Kitsune..Cute figure..9/10

[KongZilla]

Kitsune - 9.5/10 (cute!)

The Chaos 9/10 (nice!)

[Kelisidina]

Mai Tokiha; 6/10. Rendering is good but the stocks are too blurred. Text takes up too much space and is way too bright. Background is a little dull, try adding more colors/shades

[The Chaos]

Kelisidina..look Nice..7/10

[Kelisidina]

Guys, maybe you could give comments on rendering/colors/blending so that everyone knows where to improve... Comments like "Nice" or "I dont like it" doesn't help.

The Chaos: 6/10 again

[KimmyChan]

apatpower - 9/10
ayu-smepai - 10/10
Kelisidina - 10/10
The Chaos - 10/10
Katocchi - 10/10
Evil Rick - 10/10
Jze0 - 10/10
Kitsune - 10/10
ganbaru - 10/10
Mai Tokiha - 10/10

[Evil Rick]

Originally Posted by Kelisidina

Guys, maybe you could give comments on rendering/colors/blending so that everyone knows where to improve... Comments like "Nice" or "I dont like it" doesn't help.

I would say that that's a good sugestion exept for the fact that many of the people here have sigs made by other members as you will see in the Signature Request thread.

But if you want...

Kelisdina: The render is well cut exept for the hair at the left side, the placement of it on the sig leaves a big empty space on the left side that makes the sig looks very simple and not that atracting, the blending is fine but the render still looks a bit jumping in comparation the the background that also looks a bit simple, a text would be nice tbh. There, my 2 cents. 7.5/10

[M!rage]

evil rick 8\10

[The Chaos]

M!rage..The Design don't look bad just what that about ?..8/10

[Hs Vi Germania]

Evil Rick: Wooooooah lovely Roen Maiden sig. I am jealous. 9/10
M!rage: I dunno .... this signature could be the background for a real sig. The persons you insert there cannot be seen very well and effects are middle-rate. 6.5/10

[Kelisidina]

Thanks Evil Rick: <3

His vi Germania; 6/10 I like the coloring on his eye but the sketchy lines are hard to the eyes. Not much was done with it, it seems

[Emerald Emblem]

kelisidina: 8.1/10

[Chaho-Chi]

Kelisidina: 8.4/10 You've made good inprovements with color contrast beetween the render and background, but try putting some text.

[ganbaru]

Originally Posted by Kelisidina

Guys, maybe you could give comments on rendering/colors/blending so that everyone knows where to improve... Comments like "Nice" or "I dont like it" doesn't help.

I usualy put at least a comment with my rating but for comment about who improuving a sig it's trickier for many reasons, the most obvious one could be the difference in taste betweem every individual ( when someone may see something boring, someone else may see something peacefull )
Kelisidina 8,7/10 as good as a background is, too much of it might create a impression of emptyness, a text could be the solution ( I am not talking about a text like I use ,a few words would be enough ) And BTW the limit on animesuki is 50000 bytes, not 104529
Emerald Emblem 8,6/10 the background is quite colorful
Ayu-smepai 8,4/10 I am not much interested in that kind of artwork

[Kelisidina]

Oh ok! I understand now guys <3

Mai Tokiha: 6/10 again

[grylsyjaeger]

Kelisidina: Interesting design. I quite like how the overlay affect has been applied to the clothing too. 8/10