2012-04-19, 14:51 | Link #141 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2009
|
Quote:
beam =/= normal slash beam > normal slash beam = powerful enough to kill him 7 times over normal slash = can only kill him once is this clear enough? Quote:
Quote:
|
|||
2012-04-19, 14:59 | Link #142 | ||
阿賀野型3番艦、矢矧 Lv180
Graphic Designer
Moderator Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Belgium, Brussels
Age: 37
|
Quote:
At very best, the only conjuncture possible is the following: damage can be substained completely, so long the condition is fulfilled (A Rank, unrelated to damage), so even property wouldn't enter in the equation, as only raw damage (and as I stated above, damage nature/attribute shouldn't be factored, otherwise the whole distinction of Rank makes even less sense). But it goes back to the first point: the live stock concept being... a common pool for weird reason, which we both agree being a plot hax. In a layman term, that's like as if a boss hit you for 7000 damage while your character has only 1000 and you have to use like 7 phoenix down, because for some reason, the extra damage remains. That's the main complaint why the whole scene doesn't make any sense to begin with. Afterwards, grasping such explanation that isn't even hinted to begin with is hardly convincing. Quote:
Urgh, always the same problem with such kind of discussion: No proper lore material to explain things that are off the loop. I guess I'm done with this, being in the end, a plain plot hole, assumption being solid or not.
__________________
Last edited by Klashikari; 2012-04-19 at 15:25. |
||
2012-04-19, 15:31 | Link #143 | |
Senior Member
|
Quote:
|
|
2012-04-19, 20:02 | Link #145 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2009
|
argh, no, again, you misunderstood my point.
what i'm saying is, caliburn does that damage because it's caliburn, not because of its rank. To make an example, Excalibur is A++ in rank, but a simple slash from it doesn't have the same power as excaliblast. With caliburn, it's a similar case. And Arondight doesn't have any such special attack, it boosts its wielder's stats by one rank, and that's it Quote:
as for why saber was needed...one theory is that caliburn is tied to her and only she can activate it(kinda like avalon) @TwilightsCall: it's correct. It doesn't mean anything as far as the current discussion is concerned though. A+ is still A, B+ is still B... |
|
2012-04-19, 23:54 | Link #146 |
Senior Member
|
I was aiming my post more at GDB and Klashikari's discussion of if a C+ weapon could hurt berserker, not so relevant to the current conversation. Though on that note, I'm pretty sure I read somewhere that its not the strength of the attack, its the Rank that matters, so even a B rank attack multiplied by 4, while could be much more than triple the attack power of an A rank attack, couldn't even scratch Berserker while a much weaker A rank attack could potentially kill him.
As far as the current discussion goes, as I just stated my impression was that the nature of the attack is irrelevant. As long as its A rank, its capable of harming Berserker. That means that Excalibur and Arondight should both be more than capable of injuring Berserker. As to why Caliburn killed Berserker 7 times...the only somewhat plausible explanation I can think of, considering the information that was given, was that Berserker was killed once, reanimated while the sword was still in him, so he died again, rinse and repeat til he has no lives left. Kind of a weak theory I know but thats what I've got lol. As for a more practical explanation of why it killed him 7 times, I'm pretty sure Nasu just didn't want the scene to have to extend any longer. Having to defeat Berserker 7 times in a row would have just made the scene feel too long and dampened the triumphant victory feel of the scene. |
2012-04-20, 01:15 | Link #147 | ||
阿賀野型3番艦、矢矧 Lv180
Graphic Designer
Moderator Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Belgium, Brussels
Age: 37
|
You miss my point again it seems.
The nature of the damage is completely irrelevant as explained by the fact even a C rank world rending attack wouldn't leave a scratch (which can be said, totally different league than a slash or excalibur). Damage is another story, but again, simply because it is a "beam" doesn't mean it it will suddenly be 7 times stronger to beat Herakles, even if we factor ++. To begin with, I see that you bring this portion as a "damage nature/ability" but that's the very latest part I don't agree (and the whole rank discussion was to explain why it could -connect- on Herakles, it has nothing to do with the damage dealt). I never stated a A rank will definitely deal more than a single 1 life damage, however, I simply disagree to the fact it is "just because a beam similar to excalibur" that clear the whole matter, that's an even more inconsistent plot hole than simply "can be considered for every NP, depending of their own damage modifier after bypassing the rank limiter". By the way, I really doubt Arondight "just" boost the wielder parameter without anything else. Reasons stated above: sister sword to Excalibur, -and- it is a A++ as well. Which means: it has the same quality (and ability to go X3), and while Excalibur is anti fortress, Arondight is anti personal, which would be even more effective against a single target. Quote:
Quote:
__________________
Last edited by Klashikari; 2012-04-20 at 01:28. |
||
2012-04-20, 01:18 | Link #148 |
Crax
Author
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: MY
|
How should I explain this...
Let's put it this way: When it comes to the battle of Servants, the strength of its Noble Phantasm is determined by the power of its concept. I don't believe practicality can be used here. The strength/stats of a Servant is determined by his/her fame, but the strength of a NP is determined by the strength of its concept. The reason Excalibur wasn't up to par with Ea was because Excalibur's strength came from the concept of the World (the people's strength), whereas Ea's concept is the World's killer. And to the discussion of Caliburn. So, supposedly whenever Shirou traces a weapon through projection, the weapons will always be inferior to the original because there's no way to complete replicate a weapon's memories. Something will always be missing and thus making it weaker. But that is only if he created those weapons for someone else other than Saber. Unlimited Blade Works is undoubted Shirou's magic. But the magic reached its peak potential - or its original power - only when it is used to create a weapon for Saber. From the very beginning, UBW was not just a reality marble where Shirou can pull weapons out from his mind's world, but a place where he wished with all his heart to be come Saber's strength. For her ideals of a perfect world. He believed that Saber will never be defeated, will always forge on no matter what obstacles lay before her, and that he wished to become part of her strength and walk together. He learned that he will never become a good mage, nor someone as powerful as her, but at the very least, he wished to lent her his strength, that is to make her a weapon strong enough to defeat all enemies. I personally believe the true concept of UBW, or at least its starting point is a place where Shirou lents his strength to Saber and Saber alone, in the form of creating weapons. He had always wanted to be a hero, and his magic was always there, but it was only truly 'born' whole when he met Saber. After Saber left, he can no longer create weapons on par with the original, because the only weapons whose concept he memorized utterly and every grain was Saber's. Hence all the NP he created after are inferiors, and there is no reason for him to create Saber's weapons because he did not believe he can wield them as well. After he died and become a cleaner, he didn't even have a human's 'possibilities' anymore - he belonged to the world, and he cannot go beyond his limits. It is a concept true only for those who are living (mentioned somewhere I cannot remember). As for why Caliburn can kill Berserker - Shirou had always felt guilty that because he was an inferior mage, Saber could not get the magic supply she needed to continue fighting and thus rendered into a miserable state. He believed Saber to be undefeatable if she was at her full strength. He wished with all his heart to help her, and at that time, he wished to create the sword from Saber's memories, Caliburn, the sword that became her strength when she first became a king, that is, the origin of her resolution when she pulled it out of the stone. He believed that Saber won't lose no matter what, and that her light will cut through anything. With such a concept to forge Caliburn, and to wield it with her together, seven lives or seventy - there is no way Berserker could've lived through that one strike. Eh... yes, sentimental reasoning. >_>
__________________
|
2012-04-20, 02:42 | Link #149 | |||
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
|||
2012-04-20, 04:12 | Link #150 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2009
|
Quote:
if you still don't understand my point after this, i'm going to drop the discussion entirely Excalibur is an A rank NP that can shoot an A++ beam of light Arondight is an A rank NP that can temporarily give a +1 rank boost to all STATS Caliburn is, let's say, an A rank NP that can explode an A+ beam inside his opponent yes, i know we don't know caliburn's rank, i'm just arbitrarily assigning it one for the purpose of my example what kills berserker 7 times over isn't the A rank slash, it's the A+ rank beam. The special ability proper of the weapon Quote:
Quote:
|
|||
2012-04-20, 08:07 | Link #151 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Age: 38
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
||
2012-04-21, 11:19 | Link #152 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
|
Well, it seems like episode 16 went beyond my expectations and became episode 11 Mk 2. A lot of content in the episode which will most likely be expanded more in the BDs.
Although with that done, episode 17 looks like it's going to finish off Vol 3. |
2012-04-21, 22:36 | Link #155 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
|
Quote:
That's probably Nasu's reasoning when he said that Lancer stood a chance of beating Berserker if he used his runes to increase the rank of his Noble Phantasm during the tought fight (he has an anti-army mode for his spear).
__________________
|
|
2012-04-21, 22:42 | Link #157 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
|
Yes, I was hypothesizing about Caliburn honestly. But anti-army would work too: whatever isn't anti-unit I mean. Anything that says: "this kills over certain number of people."
Of course that Lancer would need time to rise the rank of the Noble Phantasm and aim at Berserker who would be probably roaring and trying to hit him (anti army mode isn't auto-sure hit like normal gae bolg). That's why there's a low chance. He could technically beat him, but needs some circumstances on his favor.
__________________
|
2012-04-22, 01:50 | Link #158 | |
Not Enough Sleep
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: R'lyeh
Age: 48
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2012-04-22, 04:52 | Link #160 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
|
Quote:
But poor Berserker actually dies before him in 2/3 routes. He's a sorer loser. At least Lancer didn't get killed by Shirou twice. Probably the ideal circumstances is having Bazett has Master (Master compatibility influences luck).
__________________
|
|
|
|