Rate That Avatar!

[NoLongerSane]

ganbaru- 9.1/10. Enjoyed the shape of your avatar. Is the character Stocking?
RadiantBeam- 8.8/10. Great portrait avatar.
Crimson Cloud- 8.9/10. Very cute avatar.

[Butter Fly]

NoLongerSane : 8.2/10 U really don't look sane anymore ^.^

[HasuMasu]

Tsuyoshi: Oh God, now THAT is awesome. - 9/10

[ganbaru]

NoLongerSane 8,3/10 Yeah It's Strocking

[Roduigez]

ganbaru: 9.3/10 - I like the different shape to it rather than a square
Crimson Cloud: 8.4/10 - Simple and cute
NoLongerSane: 8.3/10 - 0_0 that is all...
Triple_R: 8.8/10 Love the character and the pose

[NoLongerSane]

Butter Fly- 8.7/10. Really like the kitty avatar.
Roduigez- 8.8/10. Neat animation avatar.

Lol, I find it intriguing that my avatar can be somewhat disturbing. I could switch back to the Hinoki or Forte avatars.

[RadiantBeam]

@NoLongerSane: Most interesting. 8/10

[calorie]

RadiantBeam 9/10

Noticed the new avatar immediately (outside this thread). Love the clean lines in the artwork and the lighting.

[Triple_R]

Radiant Beam - Nice new avatar! I think I like it a bit more than the previous one, so I'll give it 8.8/10
NoLongerSane - Your avatar lives up to your handle, and makes me laugh. 8.5/10
Buttery Fly - Can never go wrong with cute kittens. 8/10
Roduigez - Catgirl Nagato wagging her tail? Priceless. 9/10


As for myself, I just updated my avatar a bit based on some suggestions from this thread. Ratings are welcomed, but I'm also interested in if people prefer this to what I had yesterday, or if they preferred the one I had yesterday.

[Kogetsu Shirogane]

I prefer a 5-point system to the standard 10-point. To be honest, I'd actually prefer not using one at all, but people tend to like having numbers.

The previous statement was bolded, in an effort to avoid any potential problems.

Butter Fly - Cute kitten with a nice hat. I like it. 4/5
Roduigez - "Nyaagato" seems to have caught a mouse. Fun little animation, as well. 4/5.

Triple_R - Rather creepy look, yet I'm finding myself oddly drawn to the image. In a way, it almost gives me a "Persona series" vibe.
Of course, given the fact that that I'm actually the one who made the avatar in question, I don't exactly feel right about rating it. I hope you understand.

[Triple_R]

Originally Posted by Kogetsu Shirogane

Of course, given the fact that that I'm actually the one who made the avatar in question, I don't exactly feel right about rating it. I hope you understand.

Just to confirm, Kogetsu did do this avatar for me (but not the original artwork it was taken from). Thanks a lot for that, Kogetsu.

As for your own avatar... 4/5 since you like that grading scale, and your avatar looks neat and suits you.

[NoLongerSane]

Kogetsu Shirogane- 4/5. Nice avatar. It that from an anime or of an original content?

[Haladflire65]

Beamers: Good one 8.8/10
Kogetsu: Could do with a border. 8.6/10
Triple_R: Could use more contrast and a thinner border, 8.5/10
NoLongerSane: 8.4/10

[ganbaru]

Triple-R 8,4/10 the background might have more worked
Kogetsu Shirogane 8,3/10 a border might help
Haladflire65 8,9/10 great artwork

[RadiantBeam]

@Halad: Oooh, very nice. 9/10

[Rennir]

RB-9/10 Cute

[hinakatbklyn]

@Haladflire65 - Very cool looking 9.2/10
@ganbaru - Nice quality 9/10

[ganbaru]

hinakatbklyn 8,5/10 not bad

[Roduigez]

ganbaru: 8.6/10 - Cheeky

[delorean2200]

Halad: 9/10 nice quality.
RB: 9.5/10 love Minna.
hinaka: 9.4/10 love the theme and colors.
Ganbaru: 9.5/10 love the angle .