AnimeSuki Forums

Kagatob · 2011-01-01, 19:12

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lilith

While I'm glad Yosuga no Sora is good enough to ignite such arguments and comparisons, I'm not fond of Ascaloth's attitude (your insults of "comprehension" or whatever smart ass lines you throw).

I'm inclined to agree, though I am quite touched that someone decided to waste that much time with their nose in their Thesaurus on little ol' me!

YaminoSeigi · 2011-01-01, 19:21

Well FYI the Inchou get her own route in the VN Sequel fandisk. I would say she is pretty cute and Haru is pretty compatible with her too

Malkuth · 2011-01-02, 18:10

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lilith

While I'm glad Yosuga no Sora is good enough to ignite such arguments and comparisons, I'm not fond of Ascaloth's attitude (your insults of "comprehension" or whatever smart ass lines you throw).
I'd like focus to another point other than a review (which's teetering over being a troll). For example... me whining about how little pics there are for Haru compared to the girls.

Please don't ignore the fangirls who like the edible bishie~

@Ascaloth, Nihon Reviews, and review(er)s in general ... writing a review is sharing a subjectional opinion, hence however hard you think you try, by definition you have a shorter perspective, then any collective of critics (of the review). So it is paradoxical to claim that we miss the point that only you managed to figure out. Discussing and sharing your thoughts is constructive, but stubbornly defending your opinion is pointless (in between, this works both ways)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lilith

For a second I even forgot who is Yahiro.

It's a shame we didn't see her at all (initially I thought she might be Akira's true mother ^^)

Yeah, I guess being a guy, my attention is naturally drawn to different members of the cast with more assets

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lilith

And I definitely won't watch class-rep OVA. >_> I still dislike her... She should pair up with Ryohei.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nikanoru

Oh come on... you'd watch it.

Aww but my opinion of her improved after that last line of hers in ep 12, showing that she isn't just some hater of incest, but that she merely has deep unrealized dreams of her own.

Dunno, I also hated Sora with a passion during Nao arc, even during her own ... still it made a wonderful story. Kozue arc is going to be interesting, but also unpopular, and let's face it, if there is no potential for revenue, there will be no product

Nikanoru · 2011-01-02, 19:28

Oh, I didn't know she was unpopular.

Is she really though? I mean, apparently she was popular enough to get her own story in the fan disk...

But like I said, I'd be happy with anything at all, as long as it's in the same anime canon and done by the same team, so.... Do you think there'll even be any sort of OVA or extra material?

Malkuth · 2011-01-02, 19:57

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nikanoru

Oh, I didn't know she was unpopular.

Is she really though? I mean, apparently she was popular enough to get her own story in the fan disk...

I am just making an educated guess about Kozue's popularity

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nikanoru

But like I said, I'd be happy with anything at all, as long as it's in the same anime canon and done by the same team, so.... Do you think there'll even be any sort of OVA or extra material?

Look ... on one hand, I really want more stories with the cast (even as side characters); but on the other, the story arcs were conclusive, and this fact is one that appreciate in any show. Milking the cow is always bad in my book, unless it's just a service show ... say Amagami, Ore-Imou, and this kind of trash ... than I don't mind as long as it's free

Forsaken_Infinity · 2011-01-21, 03:18

Really really well done show. Well fleshed out scenarios, characters and what not really. Not to mention the visuals and the music were top notch too. This was definitely up there among Last Year's best. I would say Tatami Galaxy, House of Five Leaves and Yosuga No Sora were top class followed by Shiki followed by some decent shows that did what they set out to do, like Amagami, then all the trash.

While I can certainly see why some people would find Sora annoying during the final arcs, you have to be inhuman to not understand why she'd hate Nao with a passion. I respect the way she kept her cool actually. And not to mention how she acted with a purpose during her own arc. A girl with attitude that also has the spine to go through what she says. There are very few girls who don't break down and start whining about fate and world and what not when faced with as much adversity as she was. Haru is very very lucky to have such a girl for his sister (and lover). Despite the anime making it a point to make it clear that she is physically much weaker than Haru or for that matter any average person, the courage she displayed was monumental to say the least.

And then there was Nao who deserves an applause for the level head she displayed. I really didn't expect her to be such a strong character going into the final two arcs but boy did she manage to surprise me. She was as cool as women can get in my honest opinion. The only that stops me from saying she was the most fleshed out character ever was her rather quick recovery from her guilt when Haru said he forgave her. But that most definitely had more to do with the constraints for the show than her character.

Haru was indecisive to many's annoyance towards the end but really, who wouldn't be indecisive if put in his shoes. Unlike the mass majority of leads, Haru actually displayed guts, wasn't dense as fuck and actually respected the relationships he was getting into. I really can't think of a better protagonist than him for these stories.

And then there are the step sisters. Their stories were really well done too. I wouldn't have disliked a more conclusive ending to Akira's story but really no other complaint whatsoever. And both those girls stand out from the mass majority as well.

I went into this anime expecting very little but it genuinely surprised me right off the bat. The first episode was appealing but cheesy >.> but it took off with such maturity from the first arc and never looked back. From the moment Haru pulled Kazu-chan into that kiss, this series displayed a level of maturity and development that I wasn't expecting at all. Not to mention the subtle touches.

I am really thankful for this anime, it reminded me not to get conceited and underestimate a series just based off the premise and character designs.

As for whether or not I would enjoy something with the class rep, I most definitely would! Her reactions were exactly what her reactions should have been. And I get the sense that she has a big enough heart to forgive and befriend the incestual duo when she has had some time to settle her own emotions down anyway.

Spoiler for offtopic and @Malkuth:

MAX_COLA_POWER! · 2011-01-23, 18:15

Well, the anime site has been updated with the BD/DVD pic of volume 2. And I think there's a special treat for you Sora fans who order the blu ray for volume 4. You'll get a Sora plushie, according to what the site says I think^^;;.

Essa Maneira · 2011-01-24, 06:12

i want Sora plushie, is there any pic on that?

MAX_COLA_POWER! · 2011-01-24, 11:54

Ask and you shall receive:

http://www.starchild.co.jp/special/y...uct/bddvd.html
http://www.starchild.co.jp/special/y...uct/goods.html

Sorry I can't upload the pics here guys.

***relentlessflame*** · 2011-01-25, 19:13

But, I will say, if you want to order the version of vol. 4 with the plushie, you'd better act soon, as almost all the major retailers that ship internationally have already sold out of pre-orders. I managed to order my copy the other day through Sofmap and will have it forwarded... but yeah. Order soon if you were thinking about it.

Kanon · 2011-01-27, 12:37

Eh, Akira's sex scene got upgraded. No more still shots, it's actually animated now.

Peanutbutter · 2011-01-27, 17:34

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kanon

Eh, Akira's sex scene got upgraded. No more still shots, it's actually animated now.

That's what I thought. Can't wait for Sora's arc BD.

EDIT: Saw the animated scene. Delicious.

MAX_COLA_POWER! · 2011-01-27, 18:11

Wonder how long it'll take for someone to stream them? I don't think episode 5 got anything taken out.

Shinji103 · 2011-01-29, 06:10

Spoiler for Megami/Nyantype NSFW Scan:

Kameruka · 2011-01-29, 06:13

Spoiler for No pics here but still very NFSW description:

Peanutbutter · 2011-01-29, 06:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kameruka

Spoiler for No pics here but still very NFSW description:

Spoiler:

***relentlessflame*** · 2011-01-29, 12:55

I don't believe Kameruka's "rumour" at all. I'd bet anything that'll be proven false on the fourth BD. The whole point of that scene was that Haru was fantasizing about it and had been fully enticed by Sora's charm. There was no actual "scene" in the classroom (which is obvious because they're in class).

And by the way, what are you talking about "much like in the VN"? There is no scene at school while class is in session. This sounds like another bout of stupidity from someone who looked at the CGs and think they know how the game went.

Please don't make stuff up.

Slayn · 2011-01-29, 16:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by relentlessflame

I don't believe Kameruka's "rumour" at all. I'd bet anything that'll be proven false on the fourth BD. The whole point of that scene was that Haru was fantasizing about it and had been fully enticed by Sora's charm. There was no actual "scene" in the classroom (which is obvious because they're in class).

And by the way, what are you talking about "much like in the VN"? There is no scene at school while class is in session. This sounds like another bout of stupidity from someone who looked at the CGs and think they know how the game went.

Please don't make stuff up.

What he said

Only people who actually played the eroge (I'm one of them) would know that never happened in the game... heck it's obvious that was Haru's imagination at work (they will have a hard time trying to give a plausible explanation on how she might stay hidden from people under Haru's desk... during class no less

Essa Maneira · 2011-01-29, 18:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kameruka

Spoiler for No pics here but still very NFSW description:

i thought it was real in anime version!

***CrowKenobi*** · 2011-01-30, 00:05

Are they are getting the wrong impression from a one second flash of an image from the second ending again.

Spoiler for NSFW image in question:

2011-01-01, 19:21	Link #2142
YaminoSeigi Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2009	Well FYI the Inchou get her own route in the VN Sequel fandisk. I would say she is pretty cute and Haru is pretty compatible with her too __________________

2011-01-21, 03:18	Link #2146
Forsaken_Infinity Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: United States of America Age: 32	Really really well done show. Well fleshed out scenarios, characters and what not really. Not to mention the visuals and the music were top notch too. This was definitely up there among Last Year's best. I would say Tatami Galaxy, House of Five Leaves and Yosuga No Sora were top class followed by Shiki followed by some decent shows that did what they set out to do, like Amagami, then all the trash. While I can certainly see why some people would find Sora annoying during the final arcs, you have to be inhuman to not understand why she'd hate Nao with a passion. I respect the way she kept her cool actually. And not to mention how she acted with a purpose during her own arc. A girl with attitude that also has the spine to go through what she says. There are very few girls who don't break down and start whining about fate and world and what not when faced with as much adversity as she was. Haru is very very lucky to have such a girl for his sister (and lover). Despite the anime making it a point to make it clear that she is physically much weaker than Haru or for that matter any average person, the courage she displayed was monumental to say the least. And then there was Nao who deserves an applause for the level head she displayed. I really didn't expect her to be such a strong character going into the final two arcs but boy did she manage to surprise me. She was as cool as women can get in my honest opinion. The only that stops me from saying she was the most fleshed out character ever was her rather quick recovery from her guilt when Haru said he forgave her. But that most definitely had more to do with the constraints for the show than her character. Haru was indecisive to many's annoyance towards the end but really, who wouldn't be indecisive if put in his shoes. Unlike the mass majority of leads, Haru actually displayed guts, wasn't dense as fuck and actually respected the relationships he was getting into. I really can't think of a better protagonist than him for these stories. And then there are the step sisters. Their stories were really well done too. I wouldn't have disliked a more conclusive ending to Akira's story but really no other complaint whatsoever. And both those girls stand out from the mass majority as well. I went into this anime expecting very little but it genuinely surprised me right off the bat. The first episode was appealing but cheesy >.> but it took off with such maturity from the first arc and never looked back. From the moment Haru pulled Kazu-chan into that kiss, this series displayed a level of maturity and development that I wasn't expecting at all. Not to mention the subtle touches. I am really thankful for this anime, it reminded me not to get conceited and underestimate a series just based off the premise and character designs. As for whether or not I would enjoy something with the class rep, I most definitely would! Her reactions were exactly what her reactions should have been. And I get the sense that she has a big enough heart to forgive and befriend the incestual duo when she has had some time to settle her own emotions down anyway. Spoiler for offtopic and @Malkuth: While I can't speak for OreImo, Amagami isn't trash and isn't just a service show. You'd be surprised. Especially with some of the girls there. That series doesn't have anywhere near the maturity and depth Yosuga no Sora had but it was still way better than your average trash fan service show and it really did well what it set out to do, which was to adapt the game, in my honest opinion. It just so happens that Yosuga No Sora's story is just that much better than Amagami's, for the most part (Tsukasa's arc is pretty close ) anyway. Besides, it has good humor. Nishishi.

2011-01-24, 06:12	Link #2148
Essa Maneira Tsukiko! ♥ Join Date: Nov 2010	i want Sora plushie, is there any pic on that? __________________ HALA MADRID!

2011-01-25, 19:13	Link #2150
*relentlessflame* 　 Administrator Join Date: Dec 2003 Age: 41	But, I will say, if you want to order the version of vol. 4 with the plushie, you'd better act soon, as almost all the major retailers that ship internationally have already sold out of pre-orders. I managed to order my copy the other day through Sofmap and will have it forwarded... but yeah. Order soon if you were thinking about it. __________________ [...]

2011-01-27, 12:37	Link #2151
Kanon Kana Hanazawa ♥ Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: France Age: 37	Eh, Akira's sex scene got upgraded. No more still shots, it's actually animated now. __________________

2011-01-02, 19:28	Link #2144
Nikanoru Member Join Date: Dec 2010	Oh, I didn't know she was unpopular. Is she really though? I mean, apparently she was popular enough to get her own story in the fan disk... But like I said, I'd be happy with anything at all, as long as it's in the same anime canon and done by the same team, so.... Do you think there'll even be any sort of OVA or extra material?

2011-01-23, 18:15	Link #2147
MAX_COLA_POWER! Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Puerto Rico	Well, the anime site has been updated with the BD/DVD pic of volume 2. And I think there's a special treat for you Sora fans who order the blu ray for volume 4. You'll get a Sora plushie, according to what the site says I think^^;;.

2011-01-24, 11:54	Link #2149
MAX_COLA_POWER! Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Puerto Rico	Ask and you shall receive: http://www.starchild.co.jp/special/y...uct/bddvd.html http://www.starchild.co.jp/special/y...uct/goods.html Sorry I can't upload the pics here guys.

2011-01-27, 18:11	Link #2153
MAX_COLA_POWER! Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Puerto Rico	Wonder how long it'll take for someone to stream them? I don't think episode 5 got anything taken out.

2011-01-29, 06:10	Link #2154
Shinji103 Crazy Devout Fanboy Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: 1st Ra Cailum-class battleship Ra Cailum, port-side officer's bunks	Spoiler for Megami/Nyantype NSFW Scan: __________________

2011-01-29, 06:13	Link #2155
Kameruka Hen-Tie Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: Hen-Tie pen	Spoiler for No pics here but still very NFSW description: According to some rumors that I heard from other forums, there are two fellatio scenes in episode 11. The second one which take place in Haru's class was censored so that can be shown in DVD/BD instead. There is hint that Sora was not satisfied with the first oral sex because Haru didn't ejaculate, as she said "You kept it in". So she sneak into Haru class to do it again, but this he will ejaculate for real, much like in the VN. The omake ED also gave us hint that this scene actually happened in the story itself. There is some changes though, instead of Haru ejaculate all over Sora's face like in VN, she will swallow it instead, as hinted in omake ED where she blushed and putting her hand on her mouth below Haru's table. That's why we heard Sora's voice echoes "its alright" when she disappears. The director were smart enough to censor the scene and it created an illusion that Sora's presence in that scene is Haru's perverted imagination.

2011-01-29, 12:55	Link #2157
*relentlessflame* 　 Administrator Join Date: Dec 2003 Age: 41	I don't believe Kameruka's "rumour" at all. I'd bet anything that'll be proven false on the fourth BD. The whole point of that scene was that Haru was fantasizing about it and had been fully enticed by Sora's charm. There was no actual "scene" in the classroom (which is obvious because they're in class). And by the way, what are you talking about "much like in the VN"? There is no scene at school while class is in session. This sounds like another bout of stupidity from someone who looked at the CGs and think they know how the game went. Please don't make stuff up. __________________ [...]

2011-01-30, 00:05	Link #2160
*CrowKenobi* One PUNCH! Administrator Join Date: Dec 2005	Are they are getting the wrong impression from a one second flash of an image from the second ending again. Spoiler for NSFW image in question: