Rate That Signature!

[Thingle]

@Crystal Requiem
7. It's nicer if the borders were white instead
@Matra
Yes. Bright because of the brush

Please rate this

[TakutoKun]

@Mr.Incest: Ara!!! That one is so cool. 10/10

[Spectacular_Insanity]

@Ice Climbers: It is a .gif. I've given up on trying to find sigs that fit the strict AS requirements. Avies are way easier (not to mention no chance of accidentally going over dimension requirements - all i have to worry about is filesize. )

Crystal Requiem: Really weird, but equally cool. 8/10

crazyhorse: Very cool effect with the wiggling text. Very nice work. 10/10

Mr. Incest: For the first sig, an 8/10. It's very pretty, but kinda empty - i guess the seals make up for it tho.... Are those Alchemy seals I see?
For the second, 10/10. It just seems to fit your username well, IMO. Lol. .... and more alchemy seals.

[Faeyice]

Ice Climbers: It's beautiful. 10/10

[TakutoKun]

@Ai Suzuki: Kawaii!!! I like the eyes! 9/10

[bigdave]

IC>> hehe nice sig man. ^^
ur definitely getting better at making ur sigs have depth =D
and good color choices, it matches ur render =]

the only thing i can think of is maybe next time try using more diverse colors, IE like using analgous colors(in ur current sig) is a nice color choice. I also mean like using Complimentary colors and triad colors. XD (lol don't worry if u don't know) I didn't get it for a little while cuz i had to take in all the different patterns.
well i say 8.7/10

Ai Suzuki>> Nice simple effects, the white bg goes well with it, but still i feel like its kinda empy =/ 7/10

Mr. incest>> I think thats one of the few sigs i have seen where using two ppl renders came out nicely XD, is the bg the same from the sig be4?

although in the second one its way better suited for it. ^^ 7.4/10

CrazyHorse>> nice animated text ^^
we have a budding new Riker in the house now XD

animation usually makes the simplest of sigs look nice =] good job 8/10

Crystal>> hmmmm can't tell whats ur sig about o.o?
although i would say make ur text more visible. very interesting pic 6.9/10

now for my current creations, its of Miria of claymore =D
i know a couple of u have already seen it but i would like a critque of it ^___^

[Cyz]

@ bigdave: Nice. I never seen Claymore (actually, I gave up watching waaay back ep. 4). Anyway, you certainly picked up a good img there. The BG matches to her dark....should I say pretty? personality Hm, the font doesn't seem to be quite blended to the sig itself. I don't know if it's just me anyway but that's just my opinion 8/10

--> *sigh* I guess it's time to make another sig

[bigdave]

Cyz>> yea im kinda having trouble blending in the text with this one =/
I don't remember ever commenting urs here so, I give it a 8/10

I like the whole bg and it fits the renders colors, but i suggest using more colors to enrich the sig ^____^
and can't wait for ur new sig, any ideas on who its going to be of? =D

[TakutoKun]

@bigdave: For your first one:

I like the 3d effects. The font really seems to stand out. 9/10

Your actual signature is neat. I would have to agree with Cyz about the font. Perhaps you could burn it in. 9.5/10

[l3lueMage]

I like it o-o though I think the border is too thick D: 7/10

[TakutoKun]

@l3lueMage: Haruhi!! 9/10

[Faeyice]

bigdave: For the sig you want to be rated, I'd give it a 8/10.

[Deathkillz]

bigdave ~ I really like how you blended the BG with the stock but imo its lacking a bit of flare though thats minor ^_^ 9/10

l3lueMage ~ oh the colours are nice ^_^ only problem is that haruhi is too "burnt" and her arm isnt extracted properly 8.5/10

matradley ~ nice and simple, but the BG colour doesnt fit 7/10

Ai suzuki ~ really cute! i just love the mood! 9/10

might as well get one of my recent ones rated :3



*fixed the hand as well xD*

[Sephi]

@matradley. Looks cute, but the combination of saber and rin is a bit strange along with the blue bg 7.5/10

@Ai Suzuki. I think it reeks of awesomeness. Don't see sigs like that very often. 9.5/10 for the creativity. Very nice use of colors.

@your Suigintou. Looks nice, very clean. But somehow the bg still feels a bit to clean . And the animated text is a bit err random. But overall it looks very nice. 8.5/10

your other one 8.5/10. Don't see anything wrong with it. But somehow it doesn't do much to me.

[TakutoKun]

@Deathkillz: I like the "Ready? Go! Ready?" I also like the image quality. 9.5/10

Your current sig is interesting too. I like the subtle animation of the "Silence" and the transition to "empty." 9.7/10

@Sephi: Your's is neat. Like a washout of a photo. 9/10

[Shana]

My sig's Shana, lol yeah, Shana XDDD.

~ Deathie: GIN SAMA FOR THE WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!! - 10/10

~ Ai Suzuki: Do like it. Nice colors - 9/10

~ Sephi: Loli? If she is... - 9.5/10

~ Mat: Tsundere-sama~ oh, wait, I mean, Rin, yeah, Rin and chibi Seiba. Though the border is a bit thick ^^b - 8/10

[Ice Climbers]

@DKZ- like i said, i love the simplicity feel of the sig 9/10
@Sephi- love the dreamlike feel (hence "dream" eh?? ) 9.5/10
@Shana- Shana, shana? lol 9/10 very nice sig

[GunBladeKid09]

Sephi 9/10 I like how it slowly fades out great job.
Mat 8/10 Simple and to the point.
Shana, I like the use of the effects.
9/10 Ice Climbers, I like the feathery things nice and bright ^-^.

<-- That one xD.

[TakutoKun]

@GunBladeKid09: The first one with Ayu is kind of plain, but cute. I can always appreciate the emboss, glass effect. 8/10

[Cyz]

@ GunBladeKid09: It was plain but I do appreciate the shiny-ness of the sig. Oh and points for having Ayu in it. 8/10
@ matradley: The little Saber pic is a little off from the theme. IMO, having Rin by herself will look better. Border is a tad thick how 'bout thinning it a little? 8/10