AnimeSuki Forums

wuhugm · 2017-11-11, 20:39

^But the only male student is MC... The heck?

Akiraa · 2017-11-11, 21:43

^Yeah, I agree. The plot seems flawed, why would you summon a whole class that is mostly females into a world where only males can use magic as heroes? Okay, I get it, earthlings have special bs powers, but seems moot considering the heavy restriction on them and males have the same unique bs power. Maybe they intended to summon just the mc and class came with him as error?

sasuke706 · 2017-11-11, 21:54

There only being one male student and the rest female was intentional during the summoning.
Some nobles wanted some exotic sex slaves. They were able to peek at the location beforehand, so yeah.

So it's a plot point.
If you mean it's bad class balance, the guys and girls in his class chose different electives and most of the guys were doing sports at the time.

wuhugm · 2017-11-11, 22:50

^I mean you said the girls have boyfriends, but all of them boyfriends are left back on earth, then what's the challenges? Also, all girls with boyfriends' arc would just be a repeat of each other, about how they cheat their boyfriends when they are not around -__-

sasuke706 · 2017-11-11, 23:24

Quote:

Originally Posted by wuhugm

^I mean you said the girls have boyfriends, but all of them boyfriends are left back on earth, then what's the challenges? Also, all girls with boyfriends' arc would just be a repeat of each other, about how they cheat their boyfriends when they are not around -__-

Spoiler for :

wuhugm · 2017-11-12, 00:32

^MC is trying to NTR his best friend? What an asshole

Garn · 2017-11-12, 18:29

For some reason I feel that class is a pain in the ass, and if in the end the harem is of the whole class (as you say the author said), it means that the story will have ntr/netori, based on what you said one that became a queen, making room for the class to be tasted before they reach the MC :P.

Akiraa · 2017-11-14, 13:20

Recently been reading a lot of trash and dropping fast, from the few ones that I kept reading past the first volume

その能力は無敵！～けもっ娘異世界転生サバイバル～
Female mc gets reincarnated into a dog-cat like beast and tries to survive, most character members are the companions of her group. Plot is nothing to be amazed, but the author writes decently and I enjoy the battles/shinka parts, albeit in the later parts gets a little too much...

「あなたの人生、ロードしますか？」「はい／いいえ」
Basically a dungeon crawling story. Protagonist has load power where he can load to the beginning of the day 27 times per day, aside that he does not have any special power and is actually average into ability compared to almost every other character, but due to his massive experience with repeating the days he has considerable mastery with the bow.

Spoiler:

sasuke706 · 2017-11-14, 13:38

^There's actually a (dead) thread for the second one.

Akiraa · 2017-11-16, 07:30

^Oh, didn't saw that, finished reading up till the last volume and put on hold. I didn't like the route the series is going, maybe I'll catch up later when they stop forcing uninteresting plot. That aside, he put a chapter on noc last month with the oyakodon, he didn't snu snu the dark elf, but he did Meiha while she was on top.

Spoiler about the story

Spoiler:

I was searching for the いずれ最強 something, that I've seen people recommending, but I wound two, the one from Narou is pure trash:

Spoiler:

The other one I found, was the number one ranking on alphalopolis いずれ最強の錬金術師？
Mc can do anything he wants type of cheat basically, akin to death mage/kumo desu ga?, where they train a little and get skill/job while everyone needs to that 10x, but does not have the interesting plot or characters to back it up.
Really average novel, but at least the mc snu snu his harem.

@モンスターがあふれる世界になったので、好きに生きたいと思います
This the new novel from the author of hetare earth dragon. Sincerely I've only finished reading because the setting is entertaining in itself for me, but the story, despite the great idea, it still weak and he didn't improve much the mc compared to the one from the hetare dragon.

Spoiler:

@世界最強の後衛　～迷宮国の新人探索者
The protagonist is basically a white mage, he buffs people. Most of the story feels like a D&D campaign into the dungeon, but the mc buffs are really, really unbalanced, hence the title.

This is the best novel from the ones mentioned in this post, but It's really slow, I've read near 50 chapters and didn't pass even a week since they died, while I don't mind the parts where they spent building the characters and such, yet the time they spent trading equipment (4 times already! despite going 4 times into the dungeon) and introducing things like a trap master to open boxes feels like wasting time when the author spends a lot of time into the preparing into the dungeon, but doesn't update often.

Images

Spoiler:

Heroines

Spoiler:

Valky · 2017-11-16, 07:55

Oh, so the rear guard one also got published.

The art is quite good actually.

wuhugm · 2017-11-16, 08:00

I skimmed that Rear Guard before
Still childish interactions, like Death March
Can't see it go close to serious romance anywhere soon

Valky · 2017-11-16, 08:07

Right, the reason why I put it on hold currently .. not to mention, update speed is not exactly the author's strongest point. I'd still read it later though since although there's some part that bothers me, overall it's not bad.

wuhugm · 2017-11-16, 08:12

I wish those novels that only put many girls around MC but not in romantic way would stop giving harem tag to them. Kinda misleading.

Valky · 2017-11-16, 08:20

It's still fair game as long as it's not completed yet, I guess. lol.

But yeah, I also think so. Another thing I wish is for the author to stop spoiling the next story on the bottom author's note. Kinda kill half the expectation when the author does that. There are quite a lot of author that does that.

Rasty · 2017-11-16, 08:23

^^ I would say something like 真ハーレム tag or something similar clearly stating that the works harem is real might have a better chance of succeeding.

As for the Kouei one... I read it quite far once (which means it is not unreadable), but I have to say it was kinda boring. Romance is almost DM level, drama nonexistent as everyone survives (not only main characters) and MC going around saving people "because it's the right thing to do" and such... just boring.

wuhugm · 2017-11-16, 08:29

^I really want it to be good because I like the illustration of that masked girl though

Hoping it'll get better.
Agree for 真ハーレム

^^If we accept that excuse, they can just do the "By the last chapter, do time skip and show that everyone is married to MC" happily ever after bullshit.
Which actually being used quite many times already. Like that Netoku, Ikai Majutsushi, and probably, no, definitely Death March.

Akiraa · 2017-11-16, 08:43

I think the problem with class transfer and shit harem just happen if it's revenge story or nocturne. It's rare for a history to cover time passing in a fast pace, therefore most of them still hold their japanese precepts of hetareness to make a move, especially if there's clearly a lot of girls that like them.

The mc is aware that lizard girl and miko are into him but he wouldn't make a move into a party with 6 girls.

wuhugm · 2017-11-17, 06:12

^Ugh

Browsing narou again
Nothing good found yet
Many with status system still make the same mistake, that is sudden stats jump like from 100 > 100000000. Making the system itself meaningless
Hetare MC still dominant
Haaa...

Akiraa · 2017-11-17, 07:13

^It's like taking HxH, goes ham on explaining the nen system, then later ignore it. What was the point?
Yeah. I like the concept of skills and stats, especially when the author can't write battle scenes, so it helps me visualize the battle, but ít's rare to get them right.

On Narou these days I filter from the get go hetare, doukan and 主人公最強 just don't have to deal with these bs, doesn't matter anyway.

Browsing a few vrrmo novels lately and just getting 1- production skill only, 2-has some cheat that you even wonder why they don't ban the mc, 3- don't actually play the game, spends most of the time on 2ch board and meme about stalker, lolis, etc.

2017-11-11, 20:39	Link #6721
wuhugm Confused Shark Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Atlantis	^But the only male student is MC... The heck? __________________ ------------------------------------------ [SPOILER] Manga, Anime, & LN Where The Girl MC Ended Up With Is Not The Main Heroine All My Threads

2017-11-11, 22:50	Link #6724
wuhugm Confused Shark Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Atlantis	^I mean you said the girls have boyfriends, but all of them boyfriends are left back on earth, then what's the challenges? Also, all girls with boyfriends' arc would just be a repeat of each other, about how they cheat their boyfriends when they are not around -__- __________________ ------------------------------------------ [SPOILER] Manga, Anime, & LN Where The Girl MC Ended Up With Is Not The Main Heroine All My Threads

2017-11-12, 00:32	Link #6726
wuhugm Confused Shark Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Atlantis	^MC is trying to NTR his best friend? What an asshole __________________ ------------------------------------------ [SPOILER] Manga, Anime, & LN Where The Girl MC Ended Up With Is Not The Main Heroine All My Threads

2017-11-14, 13:20	Link #6728
Akiraa rc Join Date: Jan 2014 Location: SP	Recently been reading a lot of trash and dropping fast, from the few ones that I kept reading past the first volume その能力は無敵！～けもっ娘異世界転生サバイバル～ Female mc gets reincarnated into a dog-cat like beast and tries to survive, most character members are the companions of her group. Plot is nothing to be amazed, but the author writes decently and I enjoy the battles/shinka parts, albeit in the later parts gets a little too much... 「あなたの人生、ロードしますか？」「はい／いいえ」 Basically a dungeon crawling story. Protagonist has load power where he can load to the beginning of the day 27 times per day, aside that he does not have any special power and is actually average into ability compared to almost every other character, but due to his massive experience with repeating the days he has considerable mastery with the bow. Spoiler: Does he have a harem yes Does he snu snu yes, by the end of the first volume he did with all members of the party, has noc chapters Characters Nameless Mc: Nameless Archer (as the end of volume 2) ミミ子: White Fox race loli petanko, lazy most of the time, but also the sharpest character in the series (also surprisingly a good technician, sexually wise) キッシェ: Half Dragon People mixed blood. Has nice boobs and big ass, One-san type popular with the younger kids and most calculative. リン: Half Minotaur mixed blood. Cool type, kyoniu モルム: 只の人間. Cute imouto type

2017-11-16, 07:30	Link #6730
Akiraa rc Join Date: Jan 2014 Location: SP	^Oh, didn't saw that, finished reading up till the last volume and put on hold. I didn't like the route the series is going, maybe I'll catch up later when they stop forcing uninteresting plot. That aside, he put a chapter on noc last month with the oyakodon, he didn't snu snu the dark elf, but he did Meiha while she was on top. Spoiler about the story Spoiler: So the nameless archer from which the protagonist takes him title from, was actually his previous life and the fox girl pettanko has memories of her previous life, therefore she knows. They found in the 4th layer a hidden path were they kill 4 guardians (the tests of the 4 great gods) and gets to the yellow river that lead people souls to the realm of the dead. Turns out that the whole god trial was bullshit and monster/levels and artefacts are just bait to lure people to die on the labyrinth (who would know?!) where god would eat part of their souls (memories) and in the mc case also his name, the most important part of the soul, hence why he doesn't remember shit and have no name. I was searching for the いずれ最強 something, that I've seen people recommending, but I wound two, the one from Narou is pure trash: Spoiler: the opening is spoiling a event from shortly later, then have the mc rebuild into a high ranking vampire, just to say he is weak and shit. Mc does dumb thing and met an opponent he clearly can't handle and is saved by asspull and gets to tame the fucking opponent, because why the hell not. I dropped at this point. The other one I found, was the number one ranking on alphalopolis いずれ最強の錬金術師？ Mc can do anything he wants type of cheat basically, akin to death mage/kumo desu ga?, where they train a little and get skill/job while everyone needs to that 10x, but does not have the interesting plot or characters to back it up. Really average novel, but at least the mc snu snu his harem. @モンスターがあふれる世界になったので、好きに生きたいと思います This the new novel from the author of hetare earth dragon. Sincerely I've only finished reading because the setting is entertaining in itself for me, but the story, despite the great idea, it still weak and he didn't improve much the mc compared to the one from the hetare dragon. Spoiler: I've seen this plot a few times in chinese novels, but it's the first time I saw into a japanese one, the setting is about the apocalypse where monster roam free and the whole world changed. Protagonist got to kill the first monster and therefore got the skill where he earns more job/skill points and has to learn how to live into this 'wild' new world. @世界最強の後衛　～迷宮国の新人探索者 The protagonist is basically a white mage, he buffs people. Most of the story feels like a D&D campaign into the dungeon, but the mc buffs are really, really unbalanced, hence the title. This is the best novel from the ones mentioned in this post, but It's really slow, I've read near 50 chapters and didn't pass even a week since they died, while I don't mind the parts where they spent building the characters and such, yet the time they spent trading equipment (4 times already! despite going 4 times into the dungeon) and introducing things like a trap master to open boxes feels like wasting time when the author spends a lot of time into the preparing into the dungeon, but doesn't update often. Images Spoiler: Heroines Spoiler: Valkyrie: died together with the mc, former boss in japan, has a sharp moth Receptionist of the guild: Ero One-san type, big chest, green hair and has a mole bellow the eyes. Rogue Lizardman: looks like a girl cosplaying, 亜人. doesn't talk. Yamato Nadeshiko Miko: died together with the mc, entered into the party when the mc saved her party. Otonashii type. Gambler Gyaru: died together with the mc, entered into the party when the mc saved her party. Genko type. Blonde Loli: Veteran seeker (level 8), recruits gambler and miko to the party, but meets a wild boss and mc saves her party, joins the mc after.

2017-11-11, 21:43	Link #6722
Akiraa rc Join Date: Jan 2014 Location: SP	^Yeah, I agree. The plot seems flawed, why would you summon a whole class that is mostly females into a world where only males can use magic as heroes? Okay, I get it, earthlings have special bs powers, but seems moot considering the heavy restriction on them and males have the same unique bs power. Maybe they intended to summon just the mc and class came with him as error?

2017-11-11, 21:54	Link #6723
sasuke706 Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2008	There only being one male student and the rest female was intentional during the summoning. Some nobles wanted some exotic sex slaves. They were able to peek at the location beforehand, so yeah. So it's a plot point. If you mean it's bad class balance, the guys and girls in his class chose different electives and most of the guys were doing sports at the time.

2017-11-12, 18:29	Link #6727
Garn Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2016	For some reason I feel that class is a pain in the ass, and if in the end the harem is of the whole class (as you say the author said), it means that the story will have ntr/netori, based on what you said one that became a queen, making room for the class to be tasted before they reach the MC :P.

2017-11-14, 13:38	Link #6729
sasuke706 Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2008	^There's actually a (dead) thread for the second one.

2017-11-16, 07:55	Link #6731
Valky Radioactive Join Date: Dec 2011 Location: The Big Durian	Oh, so the rear guard one also got published. The art is quite good actually. __________________

2017-11-16, 08:00	Link #6732
wuhugm Confused Shark Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Atlantis	I skimmed that Rear Guard before Still childish interactions, like Death March Can't see it go close to serious romance anywhere soon __________________ ------------------------------------------ [SPOILER] Manga, Anime, & LN Where The Girl MC Ended Up With Is Not The Main Heroine All My Threads

2017-11-16, 08:07	Link #6733
Valky Radioactive Join Date: Dec 2011 Location: The Big Durian	Right, the reason why I put it on hold currently .. not to mention, update speed is not exactly the author's strongest point. I'd still read it later though since although there's some part that bothers me, overall it's not bad. __________________

2017-11-16, 08:12	Link #6734
wuhugm Confused Shark Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Atlantis	I wish those novels that only put many girls around MC but not in romantic way would stop giving harem tag to them. Kinda misleading. __________________ ------------------------------------------ [SPOILER] Manga, Anime, & LN Where The Girl MC Ended Up With Is Not The Main Heroine All My Threads

2017-11-16, 08:20	Link #6735
Valky Radioactive Join Date: Dec 2011 Location: The Big Durian	It's still fair game as long as it's not completed yet, I guess. lol. But yeah, I also think so. Another thing I wish is for the author to stop spoiling the next story on the bottom author's note. Kinda kill half the expectation when the author does that. There are quite a lot of author that does that. __________________

2017-11-16, 08:23	Link #6736
Rasty Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2015	^^ I would say something like 真ハーレム tag or something similar clearly stating that the works harem is real might have a better chance of succeeding. As for the Kouei one... I read it quite far once (which means it is not unreadable), but I have to say it was kinda boring. Romance is almost DM level, drama nonexistent as everyone survives (not only main characters) and MC going around saving people "because it's the right thing to do" and such... just boring. Last edited by Rasty; 2017-11-16 at 08:45.

2017-11-16, 08:29	Link #6737
wuhugm Confused Shark Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Atlantis	^I really want it to be good because I like the illustration of that masked girl though Hoping it'll get better. Agree for 真ハーレム ^^If we accept that excuse, they can just do the "By the last chapter, do time skip and show that everyone is married to MC" happily ever after bullshit. Which actually being used quite many times already. Like that Netoku, Ikai Majutsushi, and probably, no, definitely Death March. __________________ ------------------------------------------ [SPOILER] Manga, Anime, & LN Where The Girl MC Ended Up With Is Not The Main Heroine All My Threads

2017-11-16, 08:43	Link #6738
Akiraa rc Join Date: Jan 2014 Location: SP	I think the problem with class transfer and shit harem just happen if it's revenge story or nocturne. It's rare for a history to cover time passing in a fast pace, therefore most of them still hold their japanese precepts of hetareness to make a move, especially if there's clearly a lot of girls that like them. The mc is aware that lizard girl and miko are into him but he wouldn't make a move into a party with 6 girls.

2017-11-17, 06:12	Link #6739
wuhugm Confused Shark Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Atlantis	^Ugh Browsing narou again Nothing good found yet Many with status system still make the same mistake, that is sudden stats jump like from 100 > 100000000. Making the system itself meaningless Hetare MC still dominant Haaa... __________________ ------------------------------------------ [SPOILER] Manga, Anime, & LN Where The Girl MC Ended Up With Is Not The Main Heroine All My Threads

2017-11-17, 07:13	Link #6740
Akiraa rc Join Date: Jan 2014 Location: SP	^It's like taking HxH, goes ham on explaining the nen system, then later ignore it. What was the point? Yeah. I like the concept of skills and stats, especially when the author can't write battle scenes, so it helps me visualize the battle, but ít's rare to get them right. On Narou these days I filter from the get go hetare, doukan and 主人公最強 just don't have to deal with these bs, doesn't matter anyway. Browsing a few vrrmo novels lately and just getting 1- production skill only, 2-has some cheat that you even wonder why they don't ban the mc, 3- don't actually play the game, spends most of the time on 2ch board and meme about stalker, lolis, etc.