1. Malin - It's okay, kinda monotone but okay. A bit too much starry stuff floating around.
2. Urei - Again, too many stars, the border is kinda bleh and it's lacking something. It feels too empty.
3. Katocchi - The quality is just HORRIBLE, so pixelated, over saturated, too many flashy colors. It kinda scratches the eye.
4. forgottendiary - On the first glance, it has nothing really to do with the theme at all. The ornaments are too much, it gives off more of an aquarium feeling than space. The render is in bad quality and cut out kinda badly.
5. ryuuzaki YES - The guy at the lower right corner is totally useless, text placing is bad, the black spot on the planet is ugly.
6. Arceon - Tho it lacks something, I like the colors. It's doesn't give off the feeling that it was kinda forced or I dunno if you get what I mean. One of the few decent entries.
7. Larthak - It's not bad but, other than the little icon in the left lower part, where's the space
8. Drake - It's okay, the text is a bit bleh, too much starry stuff, (you won't see that much through the atmosphere xD)
9. CrowKenobi - Ugly font, ugly spaceship (yarly xD) idk the popout is weird and the quality is suffering because of it.
10. KholdShare - Props on the slicing but that's about the only thing worth mentioning. It's overcrowded, oversparkly and too bright all in all. This could've used some more contrast in colors.
11. Evil Rick - The cut, the font, the roboty guy. Sorry doesn't do it for me xD
12. geki~ (mine) - I'm not happy with one of the woosh thingies that I blurred. I still feel that it's lacking something but yeah I admit, I had about 0 inspiration :<
13. White Manju Bun - TOO. MANY. STARS. some of the texture is at a weird angle, the background is not flowing right.
14. Faeyice - It's way too bright and sparkly and kinda out of the theme.
15. Ehko - Nasty white spots on right and left upper sides and if it wasn't for the text, I wouldn't get that it has something to do with space at all ^^'' so it feels kinda forced in.
16. AtomicoX - The C4d behind the planet looks like a mecha, imo it's too visible. The pink is too bright and too many stars again
17. konstargirl - The scanlines don't fit, the render quality is low and the white lines on the right hah??
18. Simple1 - Okay sig but, again, other than the text, where's the space??
19. Kai the Reaper - The animation is so stiff and bulky. It' looks like a dart is flying into a ball...
20. Cierra - Hi? Could you use a little more stars? I don't understand the text AT ALL. etc. etc.
21. Frailty - The nipples I mean, the glittery stuff is WAY. TOO. MUCH. No matter how many stars you add, if your sig doesn't fit into the theme well enough, IT WON'T HELP.
22. Eps~ - Here's a nice and original idea. Nothing to complain.
23. gelato_ - an Idol in space. Right. The placement is bad, the colors are bad, the icons are bad, the text is bad. It's a forced in signature.
24. Marina - I'm disappointed, I've seen pretty sigs from you but that one is really ugly. The font and text placement is weird, the girl's and the ship's colors are not in harmony and the blur on the background is unnecessary.
25. Ratche - It's too blurry, too bright and the composition has kinda gone wrong.
26. escimo - A nice and original idea but the execution is kinda poor. The space and Moon ground look way too brushed and unnatural.
27. Riker - you usually do nice animations and this would be a nice one as well if it weren't for the horrible effect you used on it. It barely looks like space, more like a canvas gone horribly wrong.
28. P.G. - It feels kinda forced. It's not a bad sig but idk.
29. Deathkillz - bad bad font, can barely see your text. Also it'd probably fit another theme better ^^''
30. KiNa - I dunno, somehow the color of your space is too blue, it goes into conflict with the inside of the cockpit. I know it's not that easy to animate everything, but I feel that it's lacking something. The machine is like standing still and it feels more like in a simulator rather than really flying.
31. Terrestial Dream - Actually the animation is barely noticeable. The sig is so monotone it looks like a texture rather than a completed piece.
32. Miko Miko - Way too many stars, bad render placement, no real composition.
33. Hypnox - Grayscale with pink hearts? The render looks distorted, lacks something on the right side (like a text
). Colors would have made it much better.