2009-08-07, 22:18 | Link #201 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
Where the comparison is somewhat more fair is to look at what Robotech humanity has achieved versus what Macross humanity has. And in this comparison, it's quite obvious that the Macross civilization has a marked advantage, and in just about every conceivable way. One stark example of this is that SDF-1 would be considered an extremely potent ship even in Shadow Chronicle-era Robotech, while the NUNS can lose SDF-4 Global and barely notice it.
__________________
|
||
2009-08-08, 12:17 | Link #202 |
Catholic = Cat addiction?
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: MURICA!!
|
I don't know if I can agree with the notion that humans were desperately trying to survive. To me, they were just being alive, and some simply lived for the thrill of the moment. I am not sure if the humans collectively thought about long-term survival at all. Now, I admit I have not seen Robotech in its entirety, but I did watch all of the original 3 shows, and by Mospeda/3rd generation, human moral on Earth is at such a low point I did not get the jest that they were thinking about long-term survival at all. Sure, a small, organized group of humans probably were doing their best to fend off the Invids, but as a collective, its hardly convincing they were thinking long-term goals.
Robotech was not exactly meant to have an expanded universe when its creators smashed three unrelated shows into one giant one to fool children. So when the expanded universe of Robotech was created due to unexpected success of the show, its creators found themselves rather confined in a rather confined situation. The result is not a pretty one. - Tak
__________________
Last edited by Tak; 2009-08-08 at 12:39. |
2009-08-08, 13:34 | Link #203 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
If you look at the colonization patterns, the same kind of message appears - a more secure civilization would have taken a much more conservative approach to colonization. They would have taken their time to build up their population and not colonized so quickly. Moreover, all of the colonies would have been built much closer to one another, and any attempts at long distance travel would been reserved to the pure exploration fleets; like it's done in other universes. And of course the colony fleets wouldn't have been so lavishly equipped, nor would they be given as much independence. All things considered, given that humanity was a hair's breadth away from getting exterminated (all it really would have taken was for SDF-1 to take an unlucky hit before blowing up Boldoze's ship), it's only natural to worry about the fragility of their civilization. This doesn't affect the younger generation of characters because they tend not to be the ones in charge, and because they didn't experience the Zentradi onslaught. I think that this hangs together remarkably well, and it really is a credit to the kind of geeky thinking that I'm pretty sure that Kawamori indulges in. Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||
2009-08-08, 15:49 | Link #204 | |
Catholic = Cat addiction?
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: MURICA!!
|
Quote:
Now, the problem with Robotech is that many people simply will not read the novels. I never read one, and probably won't. So if the show already failed to convince me in its animated form due to obvious plot-holes and glaring unanswered questions, using novels to gap the disparity is a pretty half-assed affair. Really, to have Earth hammered for three generations and still not able to finish the war by the time generation 3.5 (SC) came about? Boy, one really has to wonder... - Tak
__________________
Last edited by Tak; 2009-08-08 at 16:01. |
|
2009-08-09, 04:24 | Link #205 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Hamburg, Germany
Age: 48
|
Quote:
First off, I didnīt find the Sentinel novels to be so dire, to be honest. Maybe itīs wistful memories and not knowing Macross, but after years and years of wanting to see a continuation of the Macross part of the story ( since the other two kind of, ah, sucked ^^ ), having further adventures of Rick, Lisa, Max, Miriya and Breetai really was something nice. Secondly, IIRC, there was a Sentinels series being worked on, but after they had finished most of it, the warehouse containing the tapes burned down, effectively destroying most of the series. Only the pilot survived, but the rest of the series wasnīt done again, since financial support collapsed. Hence, the novels were written from the scripts left behind. The series was finished, finally, with an original novel, which wrapped up the plotlines, had the original cast and the most important members of the cast of the other two series all being involved and finished on a very optimistic note.
__________________
|
|
2009-08-09, 05:55 | Link #206 | |
Professional Lurker
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: NS, Canada
|
Quote:
There was also the Robotech: The Sentinels comic which I also have a few of. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robotech_II:_The_Sentinels |
|
2009-08-09, 06:11 | Link #207 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Hamburg, Germany
Age: 48
|
Quote:
Oh, well, in any case, the series never was completed, but the novels werenīt really that bad.
__________________
|
|
2009-08-09, 16:43 | Link #208 | ||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
Most of the Robotech human struggle for survival shows up after the end of the Macross part of the story. The military is split into two portions: the Robotech Expeditionary Force to go and take on the Robotech Masters in their homes (thus explaining why there aren't any familiar faces from part 1 ), and the United Earth Forces to defend Earth until they get back. This probably didn't get explained as well as it could have been in the cartoon, but it's dwelt on in a fair amount of detail in the novels. Does this excuse the weaknesses of the cartoon completely? I don't think so, but I think that it does mitigate them somewhat. Quote:
Quote:
On the other hand, I loved what they did with Breetai - he wasn't all that consistent with his Macross (Saga) incarnation, but he was awesome. I wish that the writers had given the same kind of treatment to the human characters as well.
__________________
|
||||
2009-08-09, 18:20 | Link #209 |
A blast from the past
Artist
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Fortaleza-CE, Brazil
Age: 46
|
Well... but then, they go and give us stuff like that Shadow Chronicles thingie... I mean, we even find out in the comic prequel that Lisa hasn't been able to get pregnant for three whole decades, and, at 58-60 years of age, ends up that way. And then...
Spoiler for Lisa Hayes-Hunter fate, comic-wise:
__________________
|
2009-08-09, 19:00 | Link #210 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Hamburg, Germany
Age: 48
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2009-08-09, 19:07 | Link #212 | |
Catholic = Cat addiction?
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: MURICA!!
|
Quote:
But the primary difference? In Macross, humanity is not suffering from some sort of twisted introversion. They took a hit post Space War I, but they got back up on their feet and advanced. In Robotech, humans, well... I am not too sure if I should accuse them of being introverted or just plain incompetent. Fact remains that by the time of the 3rd generation, the general moral of humans on Earth had sunk to such a level that redemption just had to come from elsewhere. And don't you think its funny that while the REF went to war, Earth had already been occupied for numerous years without their prior knowledge? How did that fact slip past them!? - Tak
__________________
|
|
2009-08-09, 19:29 | Link #213 | ||
Professional Lurker
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: NS, Canada
|
Quote:
Quote:
It's been a long time since I've read the novels... so my memory is a bit spotty here, but there were problems with communication, no? And when they did find out they spent some time rebuilding their fleet so they could send help. Not the greatest explanations, but at least they addressed it. |
||
2009-08-09, 23:06 | Link #214 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
It's also important to note that Robotech humanity lacks a lot of the resources and technologies that Macross humanity had access to. For example, the Robotech Factory Satellite is much less capable (due to breakdown and lack of power) than the Macross one. The former was only capable of building a couple of SDF-1 scale ships and a number of smaller vessels by 2029, while the UNS is launching million-person colony fleets with huge numbers of large vessels by 2030. In terms of human resouces, Robotech is at a disadvantage as well. While a lot more humans survived the Zentradi attack in Robotech, they were from the poorer and more destitute countries and communities. This inhibits the growth of infrastructure and technological advancement as all of these people have to be brought up to speed. And indeed, much of the Earth was still relatively undeveloped even by the 2029 era. Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||
2009-08-14, 00:46 | Link #215 | |
Minmay Guard
Join Date: May 2009
|
Quote:
I think a lot of it was because I really, REALLY wanted to know more about the three original component series of RT, and I (foolishly) thought that eventually, Carl Macek would say, "Okay, guys, you liked Robotech? Well, NOW, let me introduce you to Macross, Southern Cross, and Mospeada!" (Yes, that eventually happened, but it took quite a while.) Instead, I got a bunch of material trying its damnedest to weave everything into a cohesive whole, which was (and is) a project doomed to failure. Nearly every "innovation" in the novels seemed artificial and forced to me. Still, I read 'em all as they came out (except for books 19, 20, and 21), so there must have been something there that kept me coming back... |
|
2009-08-14, 03:57 | Link #216 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Hamburg, Germany
Age: 48
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2009-08-14, 08:28 | Link #217 | |
Minmay Guard
Join Date: May 2009
|
Quote:
But yes, to each his own. I think the main problem for me with the books was that by the time they started coming out, I had already seen DYRL, and was full-swing into raw anime, and Americanized versions just couldn't do it for me any more. And if the show was Americanized, the books were even more so...I wanted to get closer to the source anime, not deeper into "Macek's vision." And remember, I was obnoxiously self-righteous as only a thirteen-year-old can be. If I hadn't known it was all cobbled together from different shows, I probably would've liked them more. |
|
2009-08-14, 08:47 | Link #218 |
Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Michigan
|
I thought the ending was odd too but the story had become so metaphysical and weird that the ending was bound to be crazy. That said I loved reading the books. At the time I'd seen Robotech about 50 times and the novels were the only way I could get my fix.
As far as the Americanization of the show goes, I'm of two minds when it comes to that topic in anime in general. For one, I don't know the Japanese language or the culture so watching a dubbed, Americanized version makes it easier for me to consume. On the other hand barring translation goofs I do enjoy watching it as the creators intended. |
2009-08-14, 10:09 | Link #219 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Hamburg, Germany
Age: 48
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2009-08-15, 08:37 | Link #220 | |
New Macross soon
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Macross 30 Emigration Fleet
|
Quote:
|
|
|
|