Rate That Signature!

[ganbaru]

Konakata 8.3/10 nice picture
Chimuts 8,2/10 a bit too small

Originally Posted by Chimuts

ganbaru 8/10 : Nice poems as always but I feel that the render is a bit low in quality compared to the background :x

The picture used for making the render is smaller than what I usually use.

[Chimuts]

Originally Posted by ganbaru

Konakata 8.3/10 nice picture
Chimuts 8,2/10 a bit too small



The picture used for making the render is smaller than what I usually use.

Yeah I was wondering about the size as well XD enlarged it a bit now~

I see! that explains it

[Rikimtasu]

Chimuts 8/10 I can ship those two all day long!
ganbaru 8/10 As usual
Konakaga 9/10 Haven't see LS so long...
~ Motoko Chan ~ 7/10 It's ok.

[ganbaru]

Rikimtasu 8,3/10 good use of transparency, but it do look a bit plain

[Akito Kinomoto]

ganbaru--Solid color mix. 8.3/10
Rikimtasu--The sprites could be more evenly spaced. 8.2/10
Chimuts--Move the watermark to the neglected top-left corner and partially change the letters to black against the white and grey background. 8.3/10
Konakaga--Watermark placement clashes with the subjects. 8/10
~ Makoto Chan ~--It needs a border. 7.9/10
Frailty--Solid focus. The borderlessness is noticeable toward the middle. 8.1/10
Clarami--Points for originality. 8.2/10

[ganbaru]

Akito Kinomoto 8,3/10 the contrast between the background and the character is a bit too strong.

[Auxilism]

Konakaga 8.3/10
The hands are in kind of a weird position.

Chimuts 8.5/10
I'm lazy to check if your blurred border has true transparency but I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. The left side is a little empty, I would prefer them to be centered or have some text filling up the space.

Rikimtasu 8/10
Yay for not a rectangle at all but it looks more like four completely different images tossed together rather than merged to form a complete picture.

Akito Kinomoto 8.2/10
The text is a little too thick to go with the visual of the character.

ganbaru 8.7/10
You've done a lot of different shapes for avatars, why are your signatures rectangles?
Effects are very nice though, I thought she had a tail at first.

Please ignore the png text on the right while rating mine.

[ganbaru]

darkhalo191 8,4/10 I would suggest to use only one of those animation. it would help the focus.

Originally Posted by darkhalo191

ganbaru 8.7/10
You've done a lot of different shapes for avatars, why are your signatures rectangles?
Effects are very nice though, I thought she had a tail at first.

I did try to use different shape for my signatures a few years ago, but it wasn't really worth it.

And BTW, she do have a tail

[Knightrunner]

Akito Kinomoto: 8.3/10-besides the sharp color contrast maybe a change of word style would be beneficial

Motoko Chan: 8/10- It is very crowded with so many characters with the same colored red hair

ganbaru: 8.7 nice single character sign. Maybe if your name has a darker pink.

[ganbaru]

Knightrunner 8,5/10 I can't remember if I rated this one before

Originally Posted by Knightrunner

ganbaru: 8.7 nice single character sign. Maybe if your name has a darker pink.

Actually, I don't care much about my name's visibility on my signatures

[Auxilism]

Knightrunner 8.6
Center is a little empty; nice faded effect around the image but it's jpg so there's points lost (in uniqueness) for ultimately being a rectangular signature.

Originally Posted by ganbaru

And BTW, she do have a tail

Oops I meant that I thought that she had a giant tail.

[HasuMasu]

Akito Kinomoto: Hmm~ red is a bit jarring. - 7/10

[Knightrunner]

darkhalo191: 8.5/10 I like the animation loops especially Misaka, but maybe in a bigger size?

Masuzu: 9/10 Who is that character!? Love the bright colors.

[ganbaru]

Masuzu 8,4/10 nice picture, could use a border.

May I ask for a rating for this oversized one as well:

[Myo]

ganbaru: Oversised: I like it. It would look better if only the eyes were that colour.

Current: I prefer the other one, but it's still nice. I really, really like the colours around the character. They are beautiful.

[Knightrunner]

Myo: 8.4/10 If Wendy could be brighter with maybe a background pic instead of showing partial faces of other characters.

Ganbaru:
Current 8.9/10 I like the colors of the current signature

Oversize 9.5/10 I think you should do more signatures like this Simply beautiful.

[ganbaru]

Myo 8,3/10 a little too many character, that kind of ruin the focus.

[Libros]

Ganbaru: 8.5/10 very nice colors but maybe you could have made the text a bit bolder or in a darker color?

[ganbaru]

Libros 8,1/10 good picture

[MogMoogle1]

Masuzu - Makes me wanna chill out there too. 9/10
Myo - It's alright. I would probably place a border around it, so the cut off on the character portraits look nicer. 7.5/10
Knightrunner - Nice focus and border effect. 9.5/10
Libros - Not bad, probably would be better with a full border maybe? 8/10
ganbaru - Tits are too big... j/k! 9.5/10