|
View Poll Results: Valkyria Chronicles - Episode 20 Rating | |||
Perfect 10 | 17 | 29.82% | |
9 out of 10 : Excellent | 15 | 26.32% | |
8 out of 10 : Very Good | 9 | 15.79% | |
7 out of 10 : Good | 6 | 10.53% | |
6 out of 10 : Average | 4 | 7.02% | |
5 out of 10 : Below Average | 1 | 1.75% | |
4 out of 10 : Poor | 0 | 0% | |
3 out of 10 : Bad | 0 | 0% | |
2 out of 10 : Very Bad | 2 | 3.51% | |
1 out of 10 : Painful | 3 | 5.26% | |
Voters: 57. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools |
2009-08-20, 18:18 | Link #322 |
Army of One
Join Date: Apr 2007
|
Guys, important announcement to make, I am not going to watch the VC OVAs I repeat not going to watch them. I know, I know, you're all disappointed in me but I just don't feel like it.
Ok now I gotta go do this for every series that I've dropped or will not watch. This almost makes me feel as big as giving a rep. |
2009-08-20, 19:02 | Link #323 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
|
Yeah, the first 16 episodes are pretty draggy, usually with 1-2 battle eps followed by 1-2 eps at the base. And by "battle" ep I mean like...there'd maybe be 5 minutes of fighting. And then ever since 17 it's been more drama than anything (18 could count as a "base ep" but because of what happened in 17...yeah)
|
2009-08-20, 19:54 | Link #324 |
Catholic = Cat addiction?
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: MURICA!!
|
Originally, I expected something different from Valkyria, and definitely not what we are presented with now.
I expected an adaption heavy with strategy, because that was the game. The emphasis being how to survive against numerous odds utilizing little more than courage and familiarity (of Gallia) on your side. Anybody who played the game would know, you spend countless hours attempting to outflank Imperial forces, exploiting shortcuts, assaulting gaps, and then disappear into the midst of night before the Imps ever knew what hit 'em (ok, not quite in that order). In this setup, respite was a reward. Instead, we get this. A happy war story in the vein of a high-school drama, where characters spent more time baking bread and hanging clothes than cleaning their rifles (hell, have we seen them actually clean their rifles?). Battles last within the time-frame of 5 minutes, while the strategies employed here were pathetic even to an amateur. Ultimately, victories were declared by commanders shouting charge, while missing a lot of process in between. Never mind the laughable portrayals of political intrigue in the anime. Look, we are talking about a overwhelming invasion of Imperial forces, and you'd ground Platoon 7 due to personal reasons? Sure, General Damon was an asshole in both game and anime, but in the game, he was not an idiot. He knew when to respond and where to dedicate resources! So what did this anime accomplish until now? By dumbing down the characters and forcing drastic changes, it generated a plothole so big you can fire 120mm shells at it and not miss even if you fuck up the trajectory. Hell, if this was the backdrop I had to deal with as a player of the original, Gallia would have been conquered in days! - Tak
__________________
Last edited by Tak; 2009-08-20 at 21:50. |
2009-08-20, 21:32 | Link #325 |
from head to heel
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Vancouver, Canada
Age: 42
|
True.
I think it's sad, that for some, the anime would be the first experience to this wonderful cast of characters and setting. One can argue that the anime and the game are two different species, but I think the game simply offers more even within the area of interpersonal drama—and it doesn't even need a made up love triangle to do that. The often sudden or brief turn of events in the anime inadvertently affects the development of the character themselves, as if they too have to either compensate for and adapt to the odd pacing while ironically setting it at the same time. The whole show somewhat feels like a mess or lacks focus. Sure, at the end of the day Valkyria Chronicles is still a JSRPG that doesn't dwell too heavily on dark overtones of war and politics, but I can't help but feel it's been dumbed down even further, and I hope that the anime wouldn't be the one leaving the lasting impression of what this story is really about. And I haven't forgotten. Killing off Vyse is unforgivable... the bastards. |
2009-08-20, 22:22 | Link #328 | ||||
The Dark Knight
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: From the deepest abyss in the world, where you think?
Age: 38
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I mean I wouldn't be surprised if some guy was watching the show and then be later like, "The hell? There's a war going on?" Quote:
|
||||
2009-08-20, 22:31 | Link #329 | |
Army of One
Join Date: Apr 2007
|
Quote:
1)Got too big of a role for a side character. 2) Too perfect for a side character. 3)Discovers Alicia is a Valkyria too easily. 4) Shot Alicia without much knowledge of how to awaken her. See, if Fabio was gone, the story would of been pretty good! No need to waste 6-7 eps for the love triangle as well! |
|
2009-08-20, 23:00 | Link #330 | |
Senior Member
Graphic Designer
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Calgary, Alberta
Age: 31
|
Quote:
Also, the characters in this series could have been portrayed as much better. Isara's death was one of the most important point in the progress of the game, and the representation done by the show completely ruined the moment imo.
__________________
|
|
2009-08-20, 23:08 | Link #331 | |
Senior Member
|
Quote:
|
|
2009-08-20, 23:32 | Link #332 | |
Catholic = Cat addiction?
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: MURICA!!
|
Quote:
Quite frankly, I thought the existence of the LT was utterly unnecessary and unneeded, but thats just one aspect of this series' mishandling. - Tak
__________________
|
|
2009-08-20, 23:58 | Link #333 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2006
|
Pretty much every mission in the game could have been covered decently with 1 to 1.5 episodes worth of content.
There are 20 missions. Therefore it is easily possible. Here, let's see what we can do! C00 : Prologue: Gallia, to Arms! C01 : Chapter 1: In Defense of Bruhl C02 : Chapter 2: Escape from Bruhl The first three chapters could have been compressed into 1, maybe 1 and a half episodes easily. The last half episode could be showing the formation of Squad 7. Tally = 2 Episodes C03 : Chapter 3: Vasel Urban Warfare RP1 : Report: Ellet Embedded C04 : Chapter 4: Operation Cloudburst The Vassel Bridge could be handled in a single episode jam-packed with action. Tally = 3 Episodes C05 : Chapter 5: The Kloden Wildwood Kloden deserves its own episode because of the introduction of Jaeger. Tally = 4 Episodes RP2 : Report: Largo's Passion RP3 : Report: A Taste of Home We could have a fun little side episode, perhaps with Alicia baking bread while the Edy Detachment + Largo go saving the VEG-TA-BULS! Tally = 5 Episodes C06 : Chapter 6: A Desert Encounter C07 : Chapter 7: The Battle at Barious Barious would be a two episode special, with the first doing the assault on the guard forces, and meeting Max and Selvaria in the ruins. The second being the battle with the Batomys. Tally = 7 Episodes C08 : Chapter 8: The Woodland Snare Lots of character development for Alicia x Welkin here. One episode. Tally = 8 Episodes C09 : Chapter 9: A Midsummer Incident Cordelia being kidnapped is important enough with all the side info about the VC world. One episode. Tally = 9 Episodes C10 : Chapter 10: Liberation of Fouzen RP7 : Report: War Without Weapons Fouzen is also worth a fair bit. One and a half episodes devoted to it, then at the end of the second episode have War Without Weapons to round out Rosie's continuing development. Tally = 11 Episodes RP8 : Report: Flower of the Battlefield RP6 : Report: What Lies Beyond Hate Have the former lead into the latter. Flower of the Battlefield is meant to be later on, but these two reports could easily feed off one another given that the hostages of the latter could be kidnapped from the former. This is the last of the detours before we hit high gear towards the finale. Tally = 12 Episodes C11 : Chapter 11: The Marberry Shore C12 : Chapter 12: The Fight for Bruhl Two episodes for these linked parts. Tally = 14 Episodes After this there are 7 missions and 12 episodes left. More than enough to do justice to the climactic portion of the game. Anything not included could be DVD specials. They could have done something like this... unfortunately they chose to do what they have done. |
2009-08-21, 02:40 | Link #335 |
Senior Member
|
Kalbron, you should have been director, then maybe even Michiko Yokote would not have ruined it.
One thing is why Kalbron can make such simplistic planing that works is that he is a fan of the series. While being a fan not always works, it has the advantages - I am pretty sure Kalbron and many of VC fanplayers know VC better than the actual director and the script writer of the anime. Do not delude yourself into thinking that director or script writer study the series inside out - sure they know what the are working with, but only on a professional level, which is enough to start working but usually not enough to make a good mix of original and series based material (unless director is a real talent, which is obviously not the case in VC). Adding such idiotic thing like LT does not help specially when it steals so much of screentime and adds nothing to character and plot development. While LT was a bad conception to begin with in VC, it could have still been done well if director and script writer would know the series 'inside-out' (Faldio's role in LT wold have been decreased a lot and make him more 'watch-from-far-away' character, but it wold have worked and would have reduced time wasted), instead we get a pack full of Faldio fanboyism (some directors/scripters are known to get attached to characters specially when the character is altered a lot to their taste) and bulldozing of the last capters due to time limits because of bad director's work. |
2009-08-21, 05:09 | Link #336 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Cracow
Age: 46
|
Quote:
Well made love triangle IMHO could be best part of this story, not worst. Faldio even could stay as a super faldio, but Welkin should be portrayed as a better (smarter) man, although socialy retarted. And most importantly since episode 5 it should be clearly shown that Alicia and Welkin are in mutual love, they are on path to be a couple soon. Faldio love had to be unrequited. I episode 20 Faldio should shoot Alicia cause of jealousy and sadness (after death of his friends), not because he suspected her to be Valkyria. That would make sense. Also after Kloden Woods there should be episode or at least half of episode showing that members of Welkin squad, Alicia including, started to trust and admire Welkin. In anime there is no explanation why Alicia and squad memberst started to care about Welkin - time skip was only "explanation". Portraying Damon and few other evil Galians as a morons is another flaw of this anime. It's common to show evil people as ugly and stupid in cartoons for small kids. IS VC a show for small kids? I've started to thinking it is...
__________________
|
|
2009-08-21, 05:37 | Link #337 | |
Zetsubou gunsou
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Switzerland
Age: 43
|
Quote:
Faldio should shoot Alicia purely out of rational logic. An emotional Faldio is completely out of character. In the game story he's there as a counterweight to Welkin by going the path of "the ends justifies the means" without care for individuals, even those close to him. In the game it took him long researches, preparation and thinking until the point he shot Alicia. Well in the anime they couldn't do that. They spent so much efforts and screen time turning Faldio into a perfect infallible Marie Sue superhero the only way they could make him shoot Alicia is by some out of character sudden mental breakdown. Even with a pistol, even after loosing his whole platoon, he should have still shot Alicia with a straight face and not that exaggerate grimace. That is the kind of character he is; purely rational, calculating but for a greater patriotic sense. |
|
2009-08-21, 05:43 | Link #338 | |
yare yare..
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Earth (:
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2009-08-21, 10:01 | Link #339 |
Squishie
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Canada
|
@ kalbron, that's a great layout, although Reports 7 & 8 are happening before the actual event they stem from :P War Without Weapons happens after Mulberry Shore, and Flower of the Battlefield after Naggiar? - I forgot the exact Chapter >.<
|
2009-08-21, 10:32 | Link #340 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Cracow
Age: 46
|
@don_Durandal
So shooting a girl he loves is rational? Gambling life of beloved just on rumors and myths? God, keep me far away from people with such "rationality". As I've heard in game he shoot her too, but in game she was just his aquitance, not beloved. His mental breakdown is also very convicing - till last episode he didn't care at all about casualities, as he prooved in episode about Darkscens concentration camp. Till episode 20 he cares only about well being of Alicia, he tried to protect very hard, but suddenly he become concerned about death of his subordinates, so he shoot his beloved. It doesn't proof Fabio went crazy, it prooves script writer is a moron.
__________________
|
|
|