Rate That Signature!

[iluvnuriko]

Klashikari
I really like the second sig......9/10. The angle at which that girl is looking at me really appeals to me!

[KiNA]

@ Cyz .. !!Kaede!! ... well.. You still need to learn extracting ... Screencap is not a good source of extraction unfortunately..

@ KiNA...
__________________

[Potatochobit]

KiLA - i like it very much
KiNA - its good but no sparkles! 5 yard penalty!
iluv - pretty good
klaksh - very good, but the middle dark triangle, what does it represent?

the rest of you shame on you for removing your sigs so they cant be rated!

this sig was made by pelliser

[Deathkillz]

cyz ~ well you are on your way to making some beautiful siggies :3 (we were all beginners once ^_^) ~ lets see...imo you should remove the outer glow on kaede...or at least change it to white instead of having that yucky yellow colour ~ the mood is nice but i dont like the red lines on top...the look bleached out and it hurts my eyes O.o 6/10

kiNa ~ CC unfortunatly it looks a but dull...CC doesnt blend well with te BG and the outlines are pixilated >.< 7/10

iluvnuriko ~ i really like the mood of the sig...the colours are nice and the boarder is unique :3 8/10

potatochobit ~ cute! ^_^ 7.5/10

[Klashikari]

Radiosity : oi... you didn't have to remove your sig heh ~~

Cyz : this is probably a futile advice but well : never use a glow to lessen some cut irregularities, it won't help, and can make the edge worse.
as for the whole sig, the concept is here, though the execution needs some tweeks (but rather honorable one for a beginner )
i will agree with Deathy : the red lines aren't really consistent and doesn't really have a good impact here.
try also to juggle with the fonts and format of the texts.
6/10


iluvnuriko : the ratio is pretty neat, the color fits nicely Syoran, Sakura and gives some effect of photograph.
I'm just nitpicking a bit about this color filter, since it doesn't give justice to the tones and shades of the picture, in example, their hairs (i would say a specific blending mode, and some additional layer with color burn, etc might do the trick)
the font of the text can be slightly tweeked i think ^^"
8.5/10

KiNa : well...i like how discrete but noticeable you put some "text interface" in the BG.
however, the style of this element is conflicting with the forms in the BG. (curved lines, stars and crescent moon hardly fit some tech UI)
CC picture suffers a bit of jagged cut, not too bad.
And, as a final nitpick, her face is a bit too bright with the rest of the pic.
8.5/10

Originally Posted by Potatochobit

klaksh - very good, but the middle dark triangle, what does it represent?

well, the dark triangle has lots of significations, like a Glass Shard, 2 sword slashes, a blue ray of light, etc etc. mainly put it as an abstract contrast.

Potatochobit : the animation appears to be a bit too sudden, without really a fluent loop. it is kinda solely focused on that peculiar scene, which gives some impression of "bigger avatar" in fact, but that's L*S anyway ^^"
8/10

[kira_lacusXX]

Klashi, I've always thought you sigs were pretty unique (: they always have japanese words on it, and not a lot of sigs have that. The blue combinations are just perfect and the image is right (: love it!

Potato, ahaha that face (Konata's) gets me everytime! bit avatarish, but that's okay (: very cute!

KiNa, oo I like! NOT the boobs. I like the background (: the small text and font suits her very well and the sticking out of the sig seems to be in style lately (:

iluvnuriko, Sakura and Syaoron! Love the text, border and colour (: but it should be your naame, not a website! (wait, unless it's yours) good!

Cyz, I agree with everything said from Klashi and DK (: good job!!


Not to boost, but I love my sig. I have never made a Yotsuba sig (or have watched it) but I always see wallpapers made of it on AP. They are aaaaalways so cute and great. So I found this image (: I thought it would be cool to make it have like that crayon/pastel feeling.. so I vectored kinda and coloured it again. tada! yotsuba's an artist AND me. I seem to be finding a lot of good pictures with sig potential, yay KiLa's on a roll again!

[pirs]

kira_lacusXX: very nice! 9/10
Klashikari: about the 3 sola ones.. amazing!! 10/10!

[felix]

KiLa I've always loved pics with that character even tho.. I never saw the series.
11 - 11

[RedFrame]

Cats: sweet and simple although the color doesn't seem too solid : 7/10

Radiosity : hmmm... my browser fails to view your sig but everyone can ?/10

Kina: I like the bg but as you can see th... >_>.... <_<....>_<... okay i like the pic actually nice bg and pic so (7+1) =8/10

Kila: I like how you recolor it into pastel color, very nice : 8/10

Klashikari : I like the 2nd , the bg and lighting are good 8/10

Cyz :Orange FTW! Cyz look my sig, though kaede isn't there Kaede aura is in my sig Okay back to topic ... Taking screencapas source, i always do that, certainly you need to recolor them especially when making gif sig 6/10

Potatochobit + Pelli : Gif sig... and i can't hold back any more so i give u this 10/10

RedFrame: Mame daifuku!!!!! Its from Nagarasete Airantou ep4. The chara voice and the expression of Suzune face are very cute :3 anyway i wonder if it would be better is i put black border around it...

[KiNA]

@ Red .. Aww, her eyes melting me >.< .. borders kinda fitting.. except for those white spot shouldn't overlap it IMO .. ^^b

@ Cats .. The S in Sweet Dreams kinda got eaten =/ Other then that .. near flawless ^^ . Cropped?

@ KiLa .. !! I can draw like that too .. when I was 3 years old or something.. Points for a refreshing sig ^^

@ iluvnuriko .. Too yellowish IMO .. but nicely done IMO.

@ KiNA.. half an hour break from study.. and you get this D: ... Both sig and av combo ^^v ... yey for me!~!!

[Areguzanda]

Kira_Naruto: pretty, and just like your style 8.5/10
Cyz: kaede in that mood....*backing off sloowly...* O_O 8/10
iluvnuriko: Tsubasa! Sakura! nice calm colors. 8.5/10
Kira_Naruto: C.C version: lovely. nice strong colors. 9/10
Deathkillz: ecchiness+cutie= 9/10
Cats: aaah. kawaii!!! 9/10
RedFrame: oooh I think I see some drool^^ 8.5/10

new sigg. Matsuri's one from Klashikari Sola Sigg Set!
I grabbed it 4 minutes after he posted it in the Sola avatar/sigg thread. lucky me I refreshed the site at just the right time.

[kira_lacusXX]

Aregu, ooo a Klashi sig! Really pretty, love the clouds and the sunlight coming from the corner! Nice glowy feeling (;

KiNa, I must admit, you must've been a pretty good drawer when you were three (: not your best but it's still good. The right image doesn't really blend with the rest of the sig, but that's okay!

RF, ahahaha, I love eyes like that, it's so cute. Your sig completely captured the moment (: white spots match the mood too!

Cats, I can just eat that cat up! it's adorable and the sig is calming and flawless except for the "S" that KiNa pointed out already, but that can be ignored :]

[leofish]

kira: sketch look is awesome, idk about the brown for text color though, 8/10
Aregu: hmm.. render seems a little too blurry, maybe it's just because it has a sunlight glow from both directions? otherwise nice composition 7/10
kina: yoko ! the two images dont really match do they D; nice concept though 7/10


konota.... :3

[Cyz]

@ kira_lacusXX: An artist at work eh? Pretty artistic as always 8/10

-> Another sig I made. Well, never seen Gurren Lagann yet but the girl is hot (I blame KiNa for the influence ). Anyway, the BG is a little plain because I'm still working on it. But this was the first time I actually put an lot of effort on making it.

[Aoie_Emesai]

Cyz - quite nice, a nice blue monochrome color ^^. I feel like an idiot not knowing who she is. 8.5/10

iluvnuriko - nice coloring. 8/10

Deathkillz - what a ecchi panty shot of Fate, reminds me of Xellos sig of Asa. 8/10

kira_lacusXX - lol, Yotsuba sure is cute. 9/10

Cats - I really love your signature this time Cats. 11/10

ps: haven't done anything to mine . Still like this image too much ^^

[KiNA]

@ Cyz .. Yoko! If that glow behind the left Yoko is bigger by just a little bit.. it would be excellent .. font matching , but its color do not.. too far away from the other red, so its gets a bit alienated ...

@ Aoei .. Hiro's work never cease to amaze me ... Expecially since she was the one that draws Kaede and nerine < prettiest demon ever IMO.

@ KiNA .. Let see how far I can stretch the rules here.. no nips showing .. SAFE!!! It seems like my study period is in danger of .. well ...

x_X

[Cyz]

I really need to learn how to match colors and fonts to the pic . Anyway, the BG Yoko is closer now and I made the font color close to her red haired color thing.

@ KiNa: Very sexy. I can barely see your name though. 8/10

[Skyfall]

Cyz: Nicely done. Though i am not sure whether the background color fits that of Yoko's hair/your name. 7/10

KiNA: I like the effect with your name, but i am not a big fan of characters going over the borders. The front pic could use some work - doesn't look very smooth. 7/10

@ KiNA .. Let see how far I can stretch the rules here.. no nips showing .. SAFE!!! It seems like my study period is in danger of .. well ...

If we go by my mileage, you are still miles away from stepping on the line. Try harder

[KiNA]

I think I go wih the mileage from Ojiisan ...

@ Cyz .. Closer inspection reveals there's some white leftovers from the Yoko on the left .. Also the BG Yoko have jagged edge hairs as well.. Train more in cutting renders ^^

@ KiNA .. wrond saving option.. shouldn't have jagged edge on her hair now.. but I'm really sleepy @_@ ...

@ Skyfall, popout sig depends on the front pic IMo.. It do or die sig =/

[Cyz]

I did what I could on the sig. It still subject to change though

@ Skyfall: It's so dreamy no? 8/10