(L) Seirei Tsukai no Blade Dance [Light Novel]

[blitz1/2]

Originally Posted by sky black swordman

Spoiler for Here is some VA choices that I can only think off the top of my head. :

For Kamito: Yoshitsugu Matsuoka or Kaito Ishikawa

For Est: Yui Ogura, Kana Hanazawa or Yui Horie

For Claire: Ayana Taketatsu, Kanae Itō, and or Yōko Hikasa.

For Fianna: Ayako Kawasumi, Eri Kitamura, Shizuka Itō, Yōko Hikasa, or Yukari Tamura.

For Rinslet: Haruka Tomatsu

For Ellis: Kaori Nazuka, Ayahi Takagaki, Ami Koshimizu, or Marina Inoue

For Greyworth: I'll get back to you.

For Restia: Yukana or Maaya Sakamoto

How can you forget Kugimiya Rie for Claire?! I am not sure if Yui Horie can pull off a good Est, I don't know much characters that she does that are monotone. But agree with Est, especially with Yui Ogura's role as Tsukiko from Hentai Ouji.

Restia....Yukana is too genki for my taste, and her CC voice doesn't match what I think. Maaya...kind of debating for this.

[Reek of Blood]

Do people still operate under assumption that LN adaptations are always screwed up? It seems to me everyone's statement here are pretty much biased just because of certain screwing (Campione, and Itsuten, to lesser extent), while ignoring some succesful and faithful LN adaptations (Kamisama no Memo-chou and Durarara! on top of my head).

[Endscape]

Originally Posted by Reek of Blood

Do people still operate under assumption that LN adaptations are always screwed up? It seems to me everyone's statement here are pretty much biased just because of certain screwing (Campione, and Itsuten, to lesser extent), while ignoring some succesful and faithful LN adaptations (Kamisama no Memo-chou and Durarara! on top of my head).

Firstly, don't compare the Campione and Itsuten animes. Th only problem with Campione was that they tried to adapt too much, plus the ending. Itsuten's problems were much worse.

As for adaptations, from what I've seen, the quality drops the more source material they try to adapt, with the aforementioned Campione as an example. The LN adaptations that get the worst reviews follow that pattern. Hataraku, for example, is only adapting 2 volumes, and it's getting rave reviews.

[Avrorrange]

Originally Posted by Endscape

Firstly, don't compare the Campione and Itsuten animes. Th only problem with Campione was that they tried to adapt too much, plus the ending. Itsuten's problems were much worse.

As for adaptations, from what I've seen, the quality drops the more source material they try to adapt, with the aforementioned Campione as an example. The LN adaptations that get the worst reviews follow that pattern. Hataraku, for example, is only adapting 2 volumes, and it's getting rave reviews.

I strongly agree. The original material's brilliant. As long as you follow what happens in the story accurately, there's no way you can get it wrong. Rushing does more harm than good--often leaving the reader confused. As for Campione, I still can't believe the f@*k they did at the end. Can't believe they were stupid enough to alter the story like THAT when it was unnecessary.

[sky black swordman]

Originally Posted by blitz1/2

How can you forget Kugimiya Rie for Claire?! I am not sure if Yui Horie can pull off a good Est, I don't know much characters that she does that are monotone. But agree with Est, especially with Yui Ogura's role as Tsukiko from Hentai Ouji.

Restia....Yukana is too genki for my taste, and her CC voice doesn't match what I think. Maaya...kind of debating for this.

I didn't forget her, just thought of other VAs who can do just as good job as she can voicing Tsundere chracters.

Heh, interestingly enough, my first choice for Est was Yui Ogura. And the reason I choose Yukana was because of role Code Geass as CC. The reason I choose was due to her role in Nisemonogatari as Shinobu.

What do you about my other VA choices ?

[dracknath]

They Screw up on Est and Restia and its done for....there and then.....They mess up Kamito, and Est bed scenes they already screwed up....

Choose the wrong VA its done for before it even began..... :l

[Eijigawa]

Volume 11 cover ?!

[kazzuya13]

Originally Posted by Eijigawa

Volume 11 cover ?!

Geh!!!! it's a petanko sensei.

[bludvein]

That doesn't look like something they would use as a volume cover. The clothes are wrong, so it must be some kind of special

[blackwhite67]

Originally Posted by Eijigawa

Volume 11 cover ?!

How do we end up with this?

[shadow1296]

Originally Posted by blackwhite67

How do we end up with this?

if i had to guess greyworth tricked them again

[sky black swordman]

Originally Posted by Eijigawa

Volume 11 cover ?!

This is a Claire, I have not seen before. Claire sensei, aye.
I would rather have Fianna or Ellis as a sensei. Probably Fianna sensei a bit more as she may be ok with a teacher and student relationship!

[Yami no Ou]

Claire is so cute LOL

[dracknath]

My opinion
Claire: Cute, and tsundere....ok
Ellis: ok....cute....big bust......has the quality of a maid
Rin: OK.......Cute.......Maid-sama.......Big bust...
Fianna: seems kinda yandere to me :l, ok , moderate bust......very naughty
Est: Best of the Best! Cute! Kuudere! Love her the most!

[XFire]

Originally Posted by dracknath

My opinion
Claire: Cute, and tsundere....ok
Ellis: ok....cute....big bust......has the quality of a maid
Rin: OK.......Cute.......Maid-sama.......Big bust...
Fianna: seems kinda yandere to me :l, ok , moderate bust......very naughty
Est: Best of the Best! Cute! Kuudere! Love her the most!

........How on earth is Fianna a yandere? And you forgot the legal wife, Restia.

[holybell84]

Originally Posted by XFire

........How on earth is Fianna a yandere? And you forgot the legal wife, Restia.

Yeah, and the rest are just concubines

[Voceane]

Don't you think Carol is the spy in the academy?

[Yami no Ou]

^maybe she is but I dont really think so,what for is she spying anyway?

[sky black swordman]

Originally Posted by Voceane

Don't you think Carol is the spy in the academy?

Doubt it, IIRC Carol has been Rinslet maid for quite a long time and is at the academy only because Rinslet is there.

[Voceane]

Originally Posted by Yami no Ou

^maybe she is but I dont really think so,what for is she spying anyway?

Seireitsukai are the strengh of the nation. It's natural to want to know this strengh and weakness. If there is a war most of the seireitsukai will come from the academy.

An other thing, I found a news Shimuzu Yuu the author is (was) in hospital. Does there is a disease who target the japanese culture?