AnimeSuki Forums

blakstealth · 2014-02-13, 14:58

ganbaru: I like the gurl you picked. I think the colors could blend a bit better though, but that's your style that I've noticed/10

Akito Kinomoto · 2014-02-17, 22:41

blakstealth--Borderless look is working, nice balance, good focus. 8.6/10
ganbaru--Nice focus, nice text, good color blending. IS THAT TOUKO?! 8.6/10

ganbaru · 2014-02-17, 22:47

blakstealth 8,6/10 very interesting one, especially the colors and choice of subject.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Akito Kinomoto

IS THAT TOUKO?!

Yes, it's her.

delorean2200 · 2014-02-18, 09:27

Ganbaru: 8.5/10 the faded green added to the border seems a bit out of place otherwise not bad.
blakstealth: 8.4/10 interesting but kind of jaggy.

Libros · 2014-02-21, 13:19

Delorean - 8.5, I'm not entirely sure but maybe I've gone over your sig before? Either way, it's gorgeous.

Ganbaru - 8, Vivid. That's the only word I can use to describe your sig. Lovely artwork.

Frailty · 2014-02-22, 22:08

haven't posted here in a long long time.

Libros
8/10
The background's a bit too dark. It doesn't match the render, IMO. Maybe dodge a few spots or adjust the brightness and contrast of the background and I think it'd look pretty well

delorean2200
7/10
fairly simple. Text color doesn't fit the colors of the signature.

ganbaru
7/10
middle part is too bright. The white in the background gets in the way of the render's focal point so it's kinda hard to see.

Akito Kinomoto
7/10
lol.

blakstealth
9/10
I like the overall composition of the sig. I love the text, most especially. The only thing I didn't like is probably the random starry lights at the sides. The ones at the middle fits but it's a bit messy on the sides. I still love it though, good job

ganbaru · 2014-02-22, 23:28

delorean2200 8,3/10 nice one
Libros 8,5/10 I agree with Frailty on yours

Kotohono · 2014-02-26, 06:53

ganbaru: Great effects, and very pretty, though the text color makes it difficult to read, 9.2/10.

Frailty: Looks nice, though feels it could use a border on the sides 8/10.

iSuckAtWriting · 2014-02-26, 09:47

Libros The image height needs to be 157 to avoid being cut out on the bottom. Nice blend of warm and cool colors though. 8,2/10
ganbaru Bungaku Shoujooo~ 8,4/10
delorean2200 Small nitpick, but the border could be more lively to match the picture 8,3/10
Frailty If you were going for a cinematic look, the bars need to be a bit thicker 8,2/10
Konakaga The text could use its own border. Won Chu Kiss me?/10, or 8,4/10

ganbaru · 2014-02-26, 10:37

Konakaga 8,3/10 nice, but the background I a bit too plain
iSuckAtWriting 8,2/10 could use some more work, a border for example.

blakstealth · 2014-02-27, 20:49

frailty: really like the background and the overall green. It reminds me of all the money I wish I had. I also don't see a lot of "2 borders" sigs around, so that was refreshing to see. /10

Konakaga: cute girls on white. simple and to the point/10

iSuckAtWriting: them nails tho/10

just an interesting observation. people like their borders

delorean2200 · 2014-03-07, 18:33

ganbaru: 8.9/10 dunno about the texturize effect but love the rest, nice work.
Konakaga: 8.7/10 simple yet quite cute, only critique i could add is that the renders are a bit jaggy around the edges.

ganbaru · 2014-03-08, 09:29

delorean2200 8,4/10 the girls are too bright compared to the dark background

Kirito · 2014-04-07, 20:31

...Been awhile since I was here. None the less, as usual, calm my nerves, and let's get started...

Ahem:

Dist 8/10 - I really like the coloring and the character design. Has that peaceful but fiery sunset theme which I like.
CMHerrera 8/10 - Pretty bishounen-ish... but looks really neat and cool.
ganbaru 9/10 - It's been awhile since I've rated a signature of yours, ganbaru. Nothing cryptic and creepy this time again...weird. But for some reason I feel some sort of sadness and pain coming from this signature of yours. I really like it, nicely done.
Akito Kinomoto 9.5/10 - Since I've been playing Phoenix Wright and Dangan Ronpa a lot recently, this was a nice treat to see. Great choice, I applaud you "applause".
Tornado The Dragon 7.5/10 - Little plain but simplicity can also be a good thing. Is it something out of FF13 by any chance? Just asking...just in case.
delorean2200 8.2/10 - Not a big fan of Muv Luv. but I like the characters in the signature that are present. Need to start investing in the series more, but the question is: where do I start?
blakstealth 7.8/10 - The coloring and background looks neat, but a little simplistic. Nothing wrong with it, really.
Libros 8.5/10 - The coloring and the background are really well done, and the heroine in the signature looks really neat and tragic...that's what I'm getting. I really like it, nice!

Konakaga 9.7/10 - As a yuri fan I give this an amazing score. Speaking of yuri I still need to finish Sakura Trick...after I fully prepare myself that is.
iSuckAtWriting 9.2/10 - The color and the background looks really serene and blissful, like I'm staring at a peaceful eternal sky. I feel like I've seen that heroine before though...can't remember where. I really like it. Really neat and pretty to look at, bravo to you on that.

iSuckAtWriting · 2014-04-07, 22:28

Clarami 8,3/10 Slightly unbalanced on the left, no objections otherwise. This heroine, btw, is Miu Asakura from Bungaku Shoujo~
ganbaru Text triangulation, outer fog and background are thick where it needs to be. 8,6/10

blakstealth · 2014-04-07, 22:45

ganbaru: some pretty deep shiet as usual. Text is kinda hard to read without focusing, though. The girl is kinda cute, too/10

iSuckAtWriting: Pretty simple sig going on here. The blue border works/10

Clarami: Claris is pretty cool, so the sig is cool. The colors are appealing, as well. I dunno if I like those flowers, though/10.

ganbaru · 2014-04-08, 05:19

Clarami, 8,5/10 Did I rated this one before ?
iSuckAtWriting 8,4/10 I would had show a little more on the left, to rebalance the signature.
Blackstealth 8,4/10 Not too sure about the text and the two light flares.

Triple_R · 2014-05-01, 23:20

ganbaru: I love the texture and coloration. Very distinct. 8.8/10
Kirito: Very cute sig. The blue/pink contrast well together. Lovely imagery. 8.8/10
iSuckAtWriting: I like all the embedded links. Pretty good picture. I agree with ganbaru's critique. 8.6/10
blackstealth: Love Live! rules of course, so awesome sig. Great work getting all nine members of Muse in! I agree with ganbaru on the text choice though. 8.9/10

ganbaru · 2014-05-02, 06:34

Triple R 8,4/10 nice one, even if I am not a fan of the white added to the texts.

delorean2200 · 2014-05-06, 04:34

Kirito: 8.9/10 nicely done sig.
Ganbaru: 8.8/10 love the colors and how they blend.
Triple_R: 8.8/10 love the sig though i have to agree with ganbaru the white added to the text or the text itself doesn't quite fit.
balckstealth: 8.7/10 nice sig though agreeing with ganbaru regarding the text though the two light flares seem fine imho.

2014-02-13, 14:58	Link #20621
blakstealth Les Pays Bass Join Date: Jun 2011	ganbaru: I like the gurl you picked. I think the colors could blend a bit better though, but that's your style that I've noticed/10 Last edited by blakstealth; 2014-02-13 at 20:33.

2014-02-18, 09:27	Link #20624
delorean2200 ヒットハード＆高速 Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Scanning... Age: 37	Ganbaru: 8.5/10 the faded green added to the border seems a bit out of place otherwise not bad. blakstealth: 8.4/10 interesting but kind of jaggy. __________________

2014-02-21, 13:19	Link #20625
Libros I never hid my hurts. Join Date: May 2012 Location: Where the wild things are--Hell.	Delorean - 8.5, I'm not entirely sure but maybe I've gone over your sig before? Either way, it's gorgeous. Ganbaru - 8, Vivid. That's the only word I can use to describe your sig. Lovely artwork. __________________ "Let the flesh instruct the mind" - Claudia, Sister Death, Interview with a vampire by Anne rice

2014-02-22, 22:08	Link #20626
Frailty Constellation Graphic Designer Join Date: Jan 2008 Location: Pearl of the Orient Seas Age: 31	haven't posted here in a long long time. Libros 8/10 The background's a bit too dark. It doesn't match the render, IMO. Maybe dodge a few spots or adjust the brightness and contrast of the background and I think it'd look pretty well delorean2200 7/10 fairly simple. Text color doesn't fit the colors of the signature. ganbaru 7/10 middle part is too bright. The white in the background gets in the way of the render's focal point so it's kinda hard to see. Akito Kinomoto 7/10 lol. blakstealth 9/10 I like the overall composition of the sig. I love the text, most especially. The only thing I didn't like is probably the random starry lights at the sides. The ones at the middle fits but it's a bit messy on the sides. I still love it though, good job __________________

2014-02-22, 23:28	Link #20627
ganbaru books-eater youkai Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Betweem wisdom and insanity	delorean2200 8,3/10 nice one Libros 8,5/10 I agree with Frailty on yours __________________

2014-02-26, 10:37	Link #20630
ganbaru books-eater youkai Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Betweem wisdom and insanity	Konakaga 8,3/10 nice, but the background I a bit too plain iSuckAtWriting 8,2/10 could use some more work, a border for example. __________________

2014-02-27, 20:49	Link #20631
blakstealth Les Pays Bass Join Date: Jun 2011	frailty: really like the background and the overall green. It reminds me of all the money I wish I had. I also don't see a lot of "2 borders" sigs around, so that was refreshing to see. /10 Konakaga: cute girls on white. simple and to the point/10 iSuckAtWriting: them nails tho/10 just an interesting observation. people like their borders

2014-03-07, 18:33	Link #20632
delorean2200 ヒットハード＆高速 Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Scanning... Age: 37	ganbaru: 8.9/10 dunno about the texturize effect but love the rest, nice work. Konakaga: 8.7/10 simple yet quite cute, only critique i could add is that the renders are a bit jaggy around the edges. __________________

2014-03-08, 09:29	Link #20633
ganbaru books-eater youkai Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Betweem wisdom and insanity	delorean2200 8,4/10 the girls are too bright compared to the dark background __________________

2014-04-07, 20:31	Link #20634
Kirito Enjoying Snack Time! Join Date: Oct 2011 Location: Where It's Legal to Marry Clara and Alice Age: 35	...Been awhile since I was here. None the less, as usual, calm my nerves, and let's get started... Ahem: Dist 8/10 - I really like the coloring and the character design. Has that peaceful but fiery sunset theme which I like. CMHerrera 8/10 - Pretty bishounen-ish... but looks really neat and cool. ganbaru 9/10 - It's been awhile since I've rated a signature of yours, ganbaru. Nothing cryptic and creepy this time again...weird. But for some reason I feel some sort of sadness and pain coming from this signature of yours. I really like it, nicely done. Akito Kinomoto 9.5/10 - Since I've been playing Phoenix Wright and Dangan Ronpa a lot recently, this was a nice treat to see. Great choice, I applaud you "applause". Tornado The Dragon 7.5/10 - Little plain but simplicity can also be a good thing. Is it something out of FF13 by any chance? Just asking...just in case. delorean2200 8.2/10 - Not a big fan of Muv Luv. but I like the characters in the signature that are present. Need to start investing in the series more, but the question is: where do I start? blakstealth 7.8/10 - The coloring and background looks neat, but a little simplistic. Nothing wrong with it, really. Libros 8.5/10 - The coloring and the background are really well done, and the heroine in the signature looks really neat and tragic...that's what I'm getting. I really like it, nice! Konakaga 9.7/10 - As a yuri fan I give this an amazing score. Speaking of yuri I still need to finish Sakura Trick...after I fully prepare myself that is. iSuckAtWriting 9.2/10 - The color and the background looks really serene and blissful, like I'm staring at a peaceful eternal sky. I feel like I've seen that heroine before though...can't remember where. I really like it. Really neat and pretty to look at, bravo to you on that. __________________ Last edited by Kirito; 2014-04-07 at 20:45.

2014-04-07, 22:45	Link #20636
blakstealth Les Pays Bass Join Date: Jun 2011	ganbaru: some pretty deep shiet as usual. Text is kinda hard to read without focusing, though. The girl is kinda cute, too/10 iSuckAtWriting: Pretty simple sig going on here. The blue border works/10 Clarami: Claris is pretty cool, so the sig is cool. The colors are appealing, as well. I dunno if I like those flowers, though/10.

2014-04-08, 05:19	Link #20637
ganbaru books-eater youkai Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Betweem wisdom and insanity	Clarami, 8,5/10 Did I rated this one before ? iSuckAtWriting 8,4/10 I would had show a little more on the left, to rebalance the signature. Blackstealth 8,4/10 Not too sure about the text and the two light flares. __________________

2014-05-01, 23:20	Link #20638
Triple_R Senior Member Author Join Date: Jan 2008 Location: Newfoundland, Canada Age: 42	ganbaru: I love the texture and coloration. Very distinct. 8.8/10 Kirito: Very cute sig. The blue/pink contrast well together. Lovely imagery. 8.8/10 iSuckAtWriting: I like all the embedded links. Pretty good picture. I agree with ganbaru's critique. 8.6/10 blackstealth: Love Live! rules of course, so awesome sig. Great work getting all nine members of Muse in! I agree with ganbaru on the text choice though. 8.9/10 __________________

2014-05-02, 06:34	Link #20639
ganbaru books-eater youkai Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Betweem wisdom and insanity	Triple R 8,4/10 nice one, even if I am not a fan of the white added to the texts. __________________

2014-05-06, 04:34	Link #20640
delorean2200 ヒットハード＆高速 Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Scanning... Age: 37	Kirito: 8.9/10 nicely done sig. Ganbaru: 8.8/10 love the colors and how they blend. Triple_R: 8.8/10 love the sig though i have to agree with ganbaru the white added to the text or the text itself doesn't quite fit. balckstealth: 8.7/10 nice sig though agreeing with ganbaru regarding the text though the two light flares seem fine imho. __________________