AnimeSuki Forums

Om Nerabdator · 2011-07-07, 23:25

@rennir 9/10 could use some text

And how can i have one focal point when there are so many cute girls in setsubou sensei!

MinuSeveN · 2011-07-08, 05:49

matty543 9/10 wow, that one is great.

ganbaru · 2011-07-08, 05:53

MinuSeveN 8,43/10 interesting

~~Tsuyoshi~~ · 2011-07-08, 09:21

ganbaru: really nice color and very thematic, tho I feel that the focal is a little too sharp - 7.5/10

Dist · 2011-07-08, 09:37

ganbaru : Signatures with girls without a head feel really weird, even if the said girl's head is in your avatar. Other than that, looks pretty good though you should try something different sometimes.. All your signatures have this white aura thingy around the girls. 7/10

Haladflire65 · 2011-07-08, 10:18

matty543: 8.7/10
Tsuyo: Already chatted about this one

8.8/10

Rennir · 2011-07-08, 10:28

MinuSeven-8.8/10 Not liking the border but besides that great job!

@matty543: That's the point. One of the fundamentals of making signatures is having a focal.

ganbaru · 2011-07-08, 11:28

Tsuyoshi 8,9/10 very nice one

@ Dist, I usualy use the ''white aura thingy'' mostly as a tool helping the blending, that's why I use it often. And about trying something different, my next serie will have more variation than the others.

Kuroi Hadou · 2011-07-08, 11:39

Tsuyoshi: 9.3/10: Very nice.

@ganbaru: Can't wait to see them.

Om Nerabdator · 2011-07-08, 14:15

9/10 text is hard to read.........on my old monitor anyway >_>

Star-Wing · 2011-07-09, 08:26

@Tsuyoshi
Wow, so simple and beautiful *.* Really nice 9.2/10
(Just the left side seems to be extra..I mean the width could have been lesser)

Could I get reviews on this sig, please?

MinuSeveN · 2011-07-09, 10:01

Star-Wing (posted) - 8.6/10 I really like the colors and the image is nice. Effects are also ok but the black ... things around her are a bit too dark IMO. It's very good still.

ganbaru · 2011-07-09, 11:10

Star-Wing 8,8/10 it's looking great, I would rework the lightness/darkness at some area.
MinuSeveN 8,4/10 interesting but a bit empty

@Kuroi Hadou, don't get your hope too high; I said nothing about better or newer, just varied.

Rennir · 2011-07-09, 19:12

Star-Wing-8.6/10 Not bad, but try to find some more appealing C4ds and blend them in better. Love the colors and also awesome lighting

Black0raz0r · 2011-07-10, 03:07

Kuroi Hadou: looks cool 8.6/10
MinuSeveN: interesting

9/10
Dist: looks beautiful ^^ 9/10

Ludrio D. Zoki · 2011-07-10, 03:15

@Black0raz0r: 10/10, awesme Spartan II lifestyle of purple Sangheili blood, and cool ODSTs
@Star-Wing: 11/10 superb C.C. looking magical.

ninryu · 2011-07-10, 03:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by MinuSeveN

Star-Wing (posted) - 8.6/10 I really like the colors and the image is nice. Effects are also ok but the black ... things around her are a bit too dark IMO. It's very good still.

What anime your sig is from?

Star-Wing · 2011-07-10, 03:54

@Minu (Posted)
Nice effect and text

But the render is sticking out of the bg too much and I second ganbaru 7.5/10

@Black0raz0r
It seems cool but er...the image looks a bit lq plus the lightning doesn't seem to be in a flow 7.5/10

Thank you all for the reviews :3
@Ren, yea, you are right, I need more C4Ds

I just managed to rework the lightning a bit...

Umm...reviews, again, please?

EDIT:
@Ninryu Wow, that's a beautiful sig

Nice effects and colors, though the text needs a little reworking 8.5/10

ganbaru · 2011-07-10, 05:05

Black0raz0r 8,6/10 great artwork
Star-Wing posted 8,7 I prefered the first one, wat you did on that left corner...

Rennir · 2011-07-10, 09:54

Star-wing: 8.5/10 I like the first one better too (if you were trying to follow my advice then sorry for the bad advice

). Don't darken the tag too much. Lighting is important but it's more
Important to have subtle/realistic lighting. Don't burn too much of the edges because it takes away from the color.

2011-07-07, 23:25	Link #18821
Om Nerabdator ~Maru~ Join Date: Mar 2008	@rennir 9/10 could use some text And how can i have one focal point when there are so many cute girls in setsubou sensei! __________________

2011-07-08, 05:49	Link #18822
MinuSeveN Lurker with free time Join Date: Mar 2011 Location: Portugal Age: 31	matty543 9/10 wow, that one is great. __________________

2011-07-08, 05:53	Link #18823
ganbaru books-eater youkai Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Betweem wisdom and insanity	MinuSeveN 8,43/10 interesting __________________

2011-07-08, 09:37	Link #18825
Dist Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: Finland Age: 33	ganbaru : Signatures with girls without a head feel really weird, even if the said girl's head is in your avatar. Other than that, looks pretty good though you should try something different sometimes.. All your signatures have this white aura thingy around the girls. 7/10 __________________

2011-07-08, 10:18	Link #18826
Haladflire65 Senior Member Artist Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Normandy SR-2 Age: 29	matty543: 8.7/10 Tsuyo: Already chatted about this one 8.8/10 __________________

2011-07-08, 09:21	Link #18824
~~Tsuyoshi~~ Disabled By Request Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: The Great Justice	ganbaru: really nice color and very thematic, tho I feel that the focal is a little too sharp - 7.5/10

2011-07-08, 10:28	Link #18827
Rennir Quietly Lurking Graphic Designer Join Date: Mar 2010 Location: Beneath the prodigious sky...	MinuSeven-8.8/10 Not liking the border but besides that great job! @matty543: That's the point. One of the fundamentals of making signatures is having a focal. __________________ Gallery \| Anime List \| Manga List

2011-07-08, 11:28	Link #18828
ganbaru books-eater youkai Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Betweem wisdom and insanity	Tsuyoshi 8,9/10 very nice one @ Dist, I usualy use the ''white aura thingy'' mostly as a tool helping the blending, that's why I use it often. And about trying something different, my next serie will have more variation than the others. __________________

2011-07-08, 11:39	Link #18829
Kuroi Hadou Dark Energy Join Date: Sep 2010 Location: United States	Tsuyoshi: 9.3/10: Very nice. @ganbaru: Can't wait to see them. __________________

2011-07-08, 14:15	Link #18830
Om Nerabdator ~Maru~ Join Date: Mar 2008	9/10 text is hard to read.........on my old monitor anyway >_> __________________

2011-07-09, 08:26	Link #18831
Star-Wing Covered in Darkness Graphic Designer Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Missing~	@Tsuyoshi Wow, so simple and beautiful . Really nice 9.2/10 (Just the left side seems to be extra..I mean the width could have been lesser) Could I get reviews on this sig, please? __________________

2011-07-09, 10:01	Link #18832
MinuSeveN Lurker with free time Join Date: Mar 2011 Location: Portugal Age: 31	Star-Wing (posted) - 8.6/10 I really like the colors and the image is nice. Effects are also ok but the black ... things around her are a bit too dark IMO. It's very good still. __________________

2011-07-09, 11:10	Link #18833
ganbaru books-eater youkai Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Betweem wisdom and insanity	Star-Wing 8,8/10 it's looking great, I would rework the lightness/darkness at some area. MinuSeveN 8,4/10 interesting but a bit empty @Kuroi Hadou, don't get your hope too high; I said nothing about better or newer, just varied. __________________

2011-07-09, 19:12	Link #18834
Rennir Quietly Lurking Graphic Designer Join Date: Mar 2010 Location: Beneath the prodigious sky...	Star-Wing-8.6/10 Not bad, but try to find some more appealing C4ds and blend them in better. Love the colors and also awesome lighting __________________ Gallery \| Anime List \| Manga List

2011-07-10, 03:07	Link #18835
Black0raz0r Red vs Blue Join Date: Mar 2010 Location: Upper Austria Age: 33	Kuroi Hadou: looks cool 8.6/10 MinuSeveN: interesting 9/10 Dist: looks beautiful ^^ 9/10 __________________

2011-07-10, 03:15	Link #18836
Ludrio D. Zoki Comfortably Noxious Join Date: Jul 2011 Location: Between the Forest and Shadow Temples Age: 28	@Black0raz0r: 10/10, awesme Spartan II lifestyle of purple Sangheili blood, and cool ODSTs @Star-Wing: 11/10 superb C.C. looking magical. __________________ Ｙｏｕ　ｗｉｌｌｂｅｎｄ　ａｓ　ｉｆ　ｙｏｕ　ｗｅｒｅ　ｆａｌｌｉｎｇ～。。。

2011-07-10, 03:54	Link #18838
Star-Wing Covered in Darkness Graphic Designer Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Missing~	@Minu (Posted) Nice effect and text But the render is sticking out of the bg too much and I second ganbaru 7.5/10 @Black0raz0r It seems cool but er...the image looks a bit lq plus the lightning doesn't seem to be in a flow 7.5/10 Thank you all for the reviews :3 @Ren, yea, you are right, I need more C4Ds I just managed to rework the lightning a bit... Umm...reviews, again, please? EDIT: @Ninryu Wow, that's a beautiful sig Nice effects and colors, though the text needs a little reworking 8.5/10 __________________

2011-07-10, 05:05	Link #18839
ganbaru books-eater youkai Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Betweem wisdom and insanity	Black0raz0r 8,6/10 great artwork Star-Wing posted 8,7 I prefered the first one, wat you did on that left corner... __________________

2011-07-10, 09:54	Link #18840
Rennir Quietly Lurking Graphic Designer Join Date: Mar 2010 Location: Beneath the prodigious sky...	Star-wing: 8.5/10 I like the first one better too (if you were trying to follow my advice then sorry for the bad advice ). Don't darken the tag too much. Lighting is important but it's more Important to have subtle/realistic lighting. Don't burn too much of the edges because it takes away from the color. __________________ Gallery \| Anime List \| Manga List